Timber Creek Pizza

Pizza and lemonade, my two favorite things in this whole world. I can't get over how great this place is, their staff is great and they are super quick with orders. This isn't your typical one and done kind of place to be, as I've been to places like this and it definitely beats them all. The fact that it's right in the heart of Lake Mills is fantastic because whenever there are events happening downtown - deliciousness is a few steps away. I don't have much else to say about this place since anytime I've been here - it was a good experience. Good on you folks for keeping things groovy and sweet. I shall be back again soon for some more pizza and lemonade, can't get enough of that. Cheers,

Great pizza, delicious toppings and delivered with care and promptly. We are very glad Timber Creek is in Lake Mills.

I ordered on line a pizza and some sides and payed in advance. Got there to pick up, told to wait , got a few things , didn't get the pizza , waited a log time and could not get anyone to help , people walking by me a ton of times and no one asked if I needed help , finally got someone to answer me and took a long time to get my orderFood was good but service was not the best

Very expensive. I bought $50 worth of pizza for some of my employees and it was a very bad deal. I could eat 2 large by myself. A $5 Little Caesars is more pizza than 2 of Timber Creek's pizzas put together.

Went to Timber Creek Pizza and was welcomed by a wonderful employee named Kay. Not only did she patiently wait for me and my friend to goof up our order at least once, but she had a chipper attitude the entire duration we were there. Great little charm found in downtown Lake Mills. I would recommend their pizza and subs but I know that they have quite a few other options for food as well. It's right across the downtown park if you want to have an ice cream cone on the square. Worth a visit.

We wanted to grab something quick and fairly small to tide us over until dinner. I ordered a roast beef sandwich with cheese, and green peppers. Although I didn't order Mayo and lettuce it came with it. Even so, it was very delicious, and the bread is amazing!

Horrible service. We ordered food for delivery at 10:30 and they said it would be there by 11:30. 12:30 rolls around and there is still NO FOOD DELIVERED. We tried to call them multiple times and their mailbox was full. No contact about what time we would even get our food. Of course we prepaid and it was getting delivered to our work which we leave by 12:45 on Fridays. Therefore no food, spent money on this place, no way to discuss a refund. ABSOLUTELY ridiculous. Would never order from here again.

I took my boys and headed over to Timber Creek Pizza today. We had a large cheese pizza, garlic bread and fountain drinks. Everything was delicious! Afterwards, we tried out the ice cream and it was very very good too. I don't know how this gets rated worse than 5 stars honestly, but everyone has their opinion. I met the owner and he was a very nice guy on top of having excellent food. Five stars from us!

Pricey.. nothing special but we were hungry and it was just "ok". I'm not a fan of thin crusts but if you are you will like this one.

Great pizza at a great price! Don't forget the ice cream. Looking forward to my next visit!