The Varsity Club

Excellent pizza, and decent service. Typical Wisconsin dive bar feel and I'm here for it. It does get pretty busy, so prepare yourself for that.

Good to know when (according to the staff!!) "creepy regulars" come through the bartenders will serve them instead of kicking them out.Sorry that apparently this person could hear us over a juke box and a full bar from outside and thought our voices were "sexy and intoxicating" cause apparently that warrants being hit on and propositioned..especially after we told him we aren't interestedBut protect that bag

The only reason I'm giving five stars is because I called about the Friday fish fry for lunch and I was told it starts at 3pm so my noon lunch was out for here. As I hung up the phone I thought did I just hear a bunch of people in the back ground so I called back and I asked if I can sit down for a beer and the woman said you can sit down for a beer so I went over.This has been my first beer in two months because all the bars were closed so it was nice to finally sit at the bar and have a cold draft. They have a few taps with domestic beers and some craft beers so I ordered the Alaskan amber and I got back $7 from a ten spot so $3 is not bad at all. The bar tender was super friendly and informed me that the kitchen doesn't open until 3pm for the fish fry but I can order pizzas until then.The place has plenty of parking, more cars than people which was odd. The place has a few outdoor tables around the building. The inside has plenty of wood all over with a small bar and tables in the rest of the space with flat screens. The place is not fancy but it's not a dive by any means so it's a decent little sports bar.I wasn't planning on going out for a beer today but it was nice to finally get out and socialize with people again in a relaxed atmosphere with a beer.

Hands down one of the best pizzas I have ever consumed. The other one is located in Argentina so this one is definitely closer to home! Seriously, you are missing out if you have never tried the pizza here. Recommend cheese (duh), sausage, mushrooms and onions. Usually just order carry-out but the staff and atmosphere are friendly and welcoming.

Thirsty? Like Wisconsin thin crust pizza? Like meaty wings? Then you'd do well to stop at the varsity club. Exceedingly friendly bar staff and decent selection of beers. Normal Wisconsin pub with a little more light than many. Look on their website for their nightly specials, but I'd go for the wings. Solid choice especially for your last stop of the night.

For a small bar the food was good our waiter was attentive and welcoming. Husband had fish fry with potato pancakes and I had baked fish. I'm gluten-free and had side salad instead of French fries. I was very pleasantly surprised by the fresh ingredients in the salad . Definitely going to come back and try the pizza!

I am reviewing the Varsity Club as it relates to the food as that is why I was there. Service was fine. It appears that this place is more pub than grill. We went there for lunch, clearly this place is more pub than grill as every seat at the bar was filled with an old man day drinking. We ordered lunch. Lunch was seemingly pulled out of the frozen foods section, fried and served. There was nothing special. If you are looking for food, this is NOT a food destination, it's a bar. Now, I did not try their pizza which they claim to be the best in New Berlin, but I imagine it's not a high bar.

Pizza was excellent. Garlic cheese bread was disappointing. Crowd was unfriendly (particularly one guy who was super preachy). Service was dog sh*t. Not worth going a second time. I would not recommend this place unless you are already "one of them."

Love this place. Food is great and the staff is wonderful!! They get their meat from a butcher and you can really tell the quality.

Awesome Food and Staff and friendly customers. The atmosphere is fun and inviting. So come on down.