The Red Mill Inn & Pizza

We were excited to try this place out based on the great reviews here recently. Unfortunately, we didn't have as great an experience as others.We stopped in on a Friday night to try their fish fry because they had both perch and bluegill on the menu. Apparently, their hostess wasn't on that night so no one was seating people for quite a while. A manager stopped by and put about 3 different parties on the wait list. When we asked how long for 2 people, he just said "a while". Busy night, got it. After about 5-10 minutes, a very nice server, Jess, saw it was just the 2 of us waiting and got us a high top in the bar area. Service continued to be great by Jess. Got the french onion crock which was a little salty but not bad. The fish fry was awful. The cod lacked flavor and was soggy. The bluegill had an Italian seasoned breading that seemed unnecessary and the fish didn't taste too fresh. Should've just stuck with pizza maybe. We watched groups cycle through after seeing how long a wait would be just to leave, and for those already seated, many people sighing in frustration as it would easily be 10 minutes until a server would stop at their table. It was definitely a longer dining experience but you could tell that Jess was busting it out and trying to get to all of her tables quickly. Unfortunately, for the price ($18/basket) and the hassle, this place wasn't worth it for us. Maybe we will try again in the future but not in a hurry to go back. If you do go, ask for Jess.

Beautiful outdoor patio and quite spacious. Indoor is like historic and service oriented staff. Average Italian and good thin crust pizza. Clam chowder was very good. Fish fry had a bland taste in my opinion. Unsure what it was as exactly but the batter is very thick. Calzone kinda bland unsure what would have helped it

I visited Red Mill on my last visit to Milwaukee and love the ambiance, the menu, and the drink special! We went on a Wednesday during half price bottles of wine - score! I ordered the filet dinner with a side of mushrooms. It was $24 and honestly I didn't have high expectations as I thought this was a pizza place; however, I was wildly impressed. I've paid WAY MORE for steak that was not good at all and this steak was cooked to perfection, well seasoned, and delicious. My friend enjoyed the margarita pizza which was delicious as well. I highly recommend stopping by!

Good food, nice atmosphere to visit with people. Outdoor seating was refreshing. Friendly staff.

Very good pizza and service but very expensive for what we ordered. We were quickly seated and cocktails and overall atmosphere was nice!

Great food!! Very affordable and quick service! Will definitely come back. Patio seating is also available. Would recommend for dinner any night of the week

Great history. Old jazz club now serving up pizza. Za was good not great. Staff was super nice and the location opened up some conversation with my 83 year old mother who used to come here to listen to music. Good walk down memory lane.

Love the atmosphere and the server was outstanding! We split a gluten free pizza which was over baked. We would still go back though!

If you're looking for a great pizza. This is the place. We have also had great fish fries from Redmill as well. Never disappointed. We highly recommend.

Really a great pizza bar experience! Our group of six out of town folks were made to feel at home. Even the small pizza is huge.