The Edgewater Supper Club

We've eaten here a number of times and have always had a great experience. We went for dinner recently and love the relaxed friendly supper club atmosphere. Great selection at the bar. I loved my bourbon old fashioned from our friendly bartender. Our server was very pleasant and attentive. I had the 1/2 roasted duck with a side of beets and my wife had the sirloin with a side of lobster mashed potatoes, for an up charge. All was outstanding. Pricey, but well worth the atmosphere and outstanding food and service.

We enjoyed our visit. Both of us had the whitefish fish fry. It was generous and excellent as were all of the sides. Everyone on the staff was cordial and most helpful. We had a great view of the Rock River and even saw some wild life hanging around. This was our first time here and we will be back.

I've eaten twice at this cozy spot perched on the bank of the Rock River in rural Jefferson. It's not much to look at from the outside, but the food and atmosphere lives up to the "supper club" moniker.It's dark inside with a very low ceiling (watch your head) with lots of nooks and crannies including the picturesque "porch" area with about 8 tables and lots of windows with a view of the muddy river. We sat on the porch on our first visit and on our second, as we had six people we were in a "booth" which was more of an enclosed private room-vet private.The menu features all the traditional fare from steaks to fish. Having been disappointed by the lake fish fry on my first visit, I opted for the 8 0z. Tenderloin steak this time which was cooked to perfection. Entries come with a side-baked potato or wedges (steak fries) and a house salad with choice of dressing. At $48 this was a pretty good value.Be sure to try the cheese curds served with ranch dressing and you must save room for an ice cream drink-grasshopper, brandy Alexander, Cadillac or pink squirrel to finish things off.Service was a bit leisurely but as it was storming outside on our most recent visit,, we weren't in any hurry. The do take reservations if you call, but note like many spots like this the crowd tends to favor the early time like 5 or 5:30. We dined at 7 on both visits and were one of the last people there when we left around 8:30.A nice spot for a traditional Wisconsin dining experience.

Kind of expensive #pirtage # wisconsin # kymthompson # brianlawler. We enjoy shippig there

Had the salmon -- very good, not overdone. waiters attenriver. main factor was the beautiful old decor and the river views. a gem.

This is a great old fashioned quirky supper club. Not much from the outside on this dreary evening ,but the cozy atmosphere and cheerful service made up for that. The view along the river from the main dining area is great. Now, let's get to the quirky part...the entire dining room slopes towards the river, floors, table, ceilings. If you are over 6' grab the window seat and duck. Perfectly comfortable. It's like being on a bo

Awesome drinks and great food! The staff treated us very nicely and accommodated our friends request to bring in her service dog.

I think people like it here because they don't know any better. The food was terrible. My daughter had crab legs and they had a mush like consistency. Just awful.

The Edgewater is a charming place with outstanding prime rib on Saturdays. We had a marvelous dinner and the views of the river are beautiful. We all thought our waiter was outstanding, too. Our one concern, and for our group it was a major one, is that we were told the place was ADA compliant, and it was far from it. A member of our party had to be carried to two areas to get in and out. A portable ramp would do this place a lot of good. We felt a bit deceived.

What a great ole time supper club! The owner was very nice and made a great old fashioned. They sat us next to the window overlooking the river. Very cool atmosphere, Two of us ordered the Saturday prime rib special and one shrimp dinner. They weren't kidding in the reviews on the homemade rolls being yummy, the entrees were prepared perfectly. Checked this place off on my restaurant/supper club wish list. Did not disappoint.