The Bake Sale

I wanted to place a pie order for my birthday and went with the peanut butter and jelly pie. It was absolutely delicious! Tasted just like the real thing. It had peanut butter cream filling and layers of jelly. Also, while I was ordering I got a sausage and gravy pasty for breakfast and it was AMAZING! The croissant was so flaky and delicious! My boyfriend ordered a cinnamon roll and it was one of the best cinnamon rolls I've ever had, and I am usually not a big fan of them. We heated it up in the microwave so the frosting was nice and melted.

Stopped by The Bake Sale in West Allis - such a fun concept! They have a wide variety of treats baked in-house and sourced from local vendors, including a nice selection of gluten-free and allergy-friendly goodies. We grabbed a latte and a few items to go but they have plentiful seating inside.

The Bake Sale should be on your places to check out if you're ever in West Allis. They had an overwhelming amount of choices!! I truly wanted to try about 25 different things. Sounds like I gotta go back, right? Mine and David's favorite was the French silk pie. That was fantastic and I loved the crust. My second favorite was the cinnamon roll. It was a little dry but the amount of frosting they put on made up for it! I look forward to heating it up tomorrow then I bet it will be awesome. A little disappointed in the peanut butter cup brownie. There was no peanut butter flavor besides the few pieces of chopped up peanut butter cups. I see potential in the brownie but probably wouldn't get that flavor again. The raspberry and Nutella filled croissant dipped in chocolate was good, but also a little dry. Although that may be common with croissants? I'm no expert when it comes to croissants so maybe that's suppose to be. Overall we had a fun time trying The Bake Sale out. The worker there was soooo friendly and helpful as well!

Great little place for sweats, scones, coffee and bread. We also tried their pasties which are delicious and they will heat them up there for eating in or to go.

I had the most amazing almond cookie of my life here yesterday. The inside was perfectly gooey and sweet. A lot of places miss the mark on the sweet almond flavor, but not this bakery! My fiancé and I also got a brown butter oatmeal cream pie and snickerdoodle cookie, and both were incredible!Oh, and they have treats for doggies too! Get something for yourself, and something for your heckin' good boy/girl.HIGHLY RECOMMEND!

Cool little bakery and local goods shop.There's a case with pies, cakes, and all kinds of other bakery. I chose a slice of carrot cake, as I was still full from a burger across the street. My carrot cake was really good!They had shelves of local snacks and a couple coolers with other items. Everything appeared to be from local vendors.My wife ordered an ice coffee, which was made while we looked around. Kids got puppy chow and gummy worms. This place is mixed into a 2-3 block section of cool little businesses in West Allis. Definately worth the visit and easily supplemented by several other stops.

So many delicious treats! They make some of their own pastries and have tons of other local bakeries/coffee shops. You can also get some foodie items or a coffee drink. On this stop I got an iced coffee, $8 mini French silk pie, a Cranky Al's doughnut, and a delicious breakfast pasty filled with hash browns, cheese, peppers, a s sausage.

Just tried it today for the first but definitely not the last time. Such a cozy little shop. Employees were friendly and helpful. Omg the Ham is the best I've ever had. It's shredded with great smoke flavor but not overdone and came with 6 tasty rolls. Got a couple of pastries and enjoyed them too.

GREAT PLACE TO STUDY OR WORK!!! The costumer service was delightful and this is a super DAIRY-FREE, GLUTEN-FREE, and VEGAN friendly place to go (treats and drinks for all three)!! Definitely coming back!!

Love the pulled ham but hard rolls are very crumbly. Cheese pocket too much frosting but good otherwise. Like cherry pie