The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery

My husband and I got take out from here last week. And we both had different takes on our food.To start, the pizza that we got for take out was great! It wasn't super greasy and the crust was a thin crust which we loved! Everything about the pizza just tasted great; the crust, the sauce and the pepperoni slices were all awesome.I also did order a chicken wrap and that wasn't the best. It was falling apart before I eve picked the wrap up. The lettuce tasted soggy as if it had been sitting in the hot wrap for a while. I just wish it would have been easier to handle, and wouldn't have fall apart before I took a bite.Overall, we will come here again for the pizza.

Excellent Bloody Mary! Food was amazing! Very clean restaurant! Most importantly CHRISTINA! Our server brought smiles to our faces. We need more Christinas in the world! Very attentive, courteous and genuinely kind. After we ate we ordered two pizzas to go. Will be back for sure.

A staple in the local community. Always has great food and it's fresh! Breakfast is great for brunching in the Falls. Pizza is tasty and the burgers are some of the best! 10 out of 10 recommend!

Good food. Great service. Don't know how we missed going here for so long but glad we stopped in for dinner. Very friendly, casual atmosphere. Decent prices. Wish they had a slightly larger beer selection but they have most of the basics. We will be back.

Grumpy old lady bartending was pissed she had to stop eating to serve us, drank our beers and left!

A friend was in from California and I have never been to Alumni Club. We were greeted right away and instructed to find a seat wherever we liked. We sat near the front where the garage door was open. It was a cool summer night but the fresh air felt good. We happen to be there during a Packers game. It was my friend's first visit to the area so it was fun for her to experience WI during a Packers game. We had the Lakefront Brewery Pumpkin lager which was delicious. 50 cent chicken wings naked with habanero mango sauce and Alumni buffalo sauce on the side. The habanero mango sauce was a bit too sweet for me. I liked the Alumni sauce. It is a thinner buffalo sauce. We split the El Cubano and tenderloin steak sandwich. For $1.00 extra you can get tots or onion rings. The steak sandwich came with mushrooms and onions. The steak was very tender. I personally thought it was one of the better steak sandwiches I have had. The Cubano sandwich had the pickled taste you would expect but nothing out of the ordinary. The onion rings were crisp with the right mix of batter to onion. Tater tots were standard. There was a round of free shots of Apple Pucker and Sprite. Then a raffle for a free drink each period. I one won!Staff was attentive and very friendly. It was a great experience overall.

I ordered take out for 2 Fish Fries and a large cheese pizza with the following toppings: Sausage, Onion, Mushrooms and Green Peppers The pizza bare is 16.00 dollars, and everything is priced when adding. Meat is 2 dollar, and everything else is 1 dollar. It came out with the pizza with the toppings to 21 dollars. For some miraculous reason the pizza came out to a whopping 26 dollars! Each fish fry was 13.95, so that would be 13.95 x 2 equals 27.9027.90 + 21,00=48.90Not 56.72 cents. Even with taxes ,there's a discrepancy of 5.37 cents.That THEY STEAL FROM YOU!This place is scamming you and you don't even know it because they are so quick with ripping receipts away from you.This place deserves an IRS audit. ( And I will tip them)When I refused the pizza the lady got very pissed off, and didn't want to deal with me anymore.Also, they add a 2 dollar take out fee. Never knew a plastic bag, putting food in a box and leaving out on the counter to cool off costs 2 dollar.And the take out fee is listed as a beverage.FRAUD FRAUD FRAUD!They charge you and they pocket the extra.I hope they go out of business soon, because stealing from your customers is a quick way to get into trouble with the IRS.

The last two years we've celebrated our neighborhood Christmas party at the Alumni Club and each year it's been spectacular! The party room downstairs is perfect. It's decorated for Christmas and has music and TVs for entertainment. The food and drinks were wonderful. Christina took such good care of us; she anticipated our every need. Thank you Mitch and the Alumni Club for helping make our Christmas celebration so memorable!

We ordered the fish fry. Sorry to say, the fish was dry and the crust was very tough. Very disappointing.Cole slaw was good! Curly little fries were good.

Excellent food , excellent service ....ate 3 times in one week. So good . Went again today . A little loud at 4:30 .today but .. hey ..it's a bar ! Food was good ..I had a hot beef and spouse had fish . Everything was delicious . .. wait staff was pretty busy ..but did a good job ! We will be back !