Sweetly Baked Cafe Dessert Bar
outside
Vanilla, chocolate, carrot cake and funfetti
food
Dessert flight
interior
Lavender macaroon
Exterior of building
French 75 paired with a raspberry macaroon
Cranberry macaroon
Banana pudding
Espresso Martini paired with pistachio macaroon
Pistachio macaron
interior
interior
interior
Offering a selection of cocktails, mocktails, and wine.
Mobile Dessert Bar (find at events around MKE or available for private rentals)
Pistachio macarons
$5 Happy Hour on Thursdays!
Cake pops!
Carla R.
Feb 15, 2025
The desserts were outstanding but what really made it special was the full experience. We ordered the dessert flights and I 100% recommend doing this! Dave took care of us, informed us of what we were tasting, providing history and suggestions. The staff is very friendly and made the experience so special and memorable for us. The desserts were outstanding and paired so well with the drinks. My personal favorite was the lavender macaroon with the plum sake, nothing like you've ever tasted, it's a must! This is a small space, so I recommend making reservations as there are only 3 tables. We loved this experience so much, we hope to come back each quarter to try the new dessert flights.
Read More
Taylor H.
Nov 2, 2024
Had the opportunity to try a few treats from Sweetly Baked yesterday and my goodness were they yummy! Our favorites were the cookies and cake pops/cakesicles. I love that their hours extend until 9pm, as it's hard to find a place with sweet treats when you're out and about after dinner besides just ice cream. The two working when I came in were very friendly and welcoming. Cute interior, with a small seating area. Can't wait to head here after dinner again sometime soon to try more tasty treats!
Read More
Nava L.
Oct 15, 2024
Came with a group of friends and we all got a few different things to try and share! The people were super nice and friendly. Loved all the desserts honestly! I think the cake was my least favorite, but that could also be how amazing everything else was! Loved the tartness of the raspberry mouse and the banana pudding. Overall great and would definitely come back!
Read More
Allison B.
Jan 25, 2025
Absolutely adorable little bakery! So much loving attention to detail in both the beautiful treats and their space. Dog-friendly! Lovely, friendly staff. So glad we stopped in!
Read More
Nancy B.
Jul 10, 2024
New place for sweet treats in the Third Ward and I stopped by today to check it out. I only tried the macaron sample and it was sweet indeed. Their cookies and mini cakes looked appetizing so I'll be sure to stop by in the near future.
Read More
Dorothy H.
Nov 23, 2024
A cute little bakery I stumbled upon walking to my car. I got a banana pudding and two macaroons. One of the yummiest banana puddings easily taking the number 9 spot in my top ten. The gold edible glitter was an added flair I didn't know I needed. I find the cranberry macaroon quite delightful, while the lavender one was somewhat too much for my liking. I am eagerly anticipating the opportunity to indulge in the myriad other flavors and delights this hidden gem has to offer.
Read More
Julie Y.
Nov 1, 2024
Tried this place out for the first time today. The pumpkin angel food cake was really good. There's a small seating area (3 tables) and overall a cute spot for dessert. It's open fairly late, so it's a nice post-dinner dessert alternative to ice cream. The owners were lovely and very friendly!
Read More
James L.
Oct 6, 2024
Great coffee, unique dog wall, small seating area.Their bakery items are amazingly crafted with the nice twist on matching them with a wine. Have been here many times and they're always friendly.
Read More
Raina V.
Feb 21, 2025
Banana pudding was one of the best desserts I've ever had. Friendly service each time I've been there.
Read More
M C.
Dec 14, 2024
Great little cakes! Friendly staff (maybe owners). Wonderful place to buy a sweet treat from. All so pretty and delicious to eat!
Read More