Sugar River Pizza
Sugar River Pizza
Pickles seasoned, battered and fried. Best with our spicy ranch dipping sauce
Pretzel bites served with our homemade beer cheese sauce and Rhoda's mustard
Made with a perfect blend of spinach and artichokes. This dip is served hot with fresh house chips
A blend of smoked Gouda, cheddar, Parmesan, Romano and fontina cheese
House marinara with goat cheese served with a double order of our classic bread sticks
Chicken, tomatoes, onions and green peppers folded into a grilled tortilla with cheddar and pepper-jack cheese
Whole pieces of white chicken lightly battered and fried
Seasoned waffle fries served with a dipping sauce of your choice
Cheese-filled ravioli breaded, fried and served with a side of marinara
Cheesy garlic bread served with yummy and bubbly beer cheese for dipping. Simple winter comfort food
With bacon and cheddar cheese
Fried dough bites smothered with cheese and bacon. Great with our homemade ranch
Green County's finest cheese curds, battered and fried to perfection
Made to order and tossed in any sauce of your choice
Whole wheat bread sticks, drizzled with olive oil, herbs and our signature cheese blend
We start with our amazing cheese bread and then stuff it with more yummy cheese
Our classic bread sticks, served with your choice of sauce
Bread sticks topped with butter, herbs and two Wisconsin cheeses
Huge, battered onion rings served with your choice of sauce
Pesto, fresh basil, tomatoes, mozzarella and a drizzle of balsamic reduction
Our white sauce topped with fire-roasted fuji apples, bacon, caramelized onions, signature cheese and a swirl of Maple-Rosemary syrup
Alfredo sauce, chicken, julienned red peppers and a blend of our parmesan and signature cheese
Slow simmered and homemade. A creamy childhood favorite blended with cream and roasted red peppers
Always homemade and delicious, ask your server for today's selection
Mixed greens, roasted butternut squash, goat cheese and candied walnuts. Pairs best with our tarragon vinaigrette
Mixed greens, green pepper, onion, cucumber, cheddar cheese and crispy chicken tossed in buffalo sauce
Romaine, shaved Asiago, banana peppers, cherry tomatoes and croutons with our homemade Caesar dressing on the side
Homemade red pepper hummus served with flatbread, spring greens, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, cucumbers and chicken
Mixed greens, crunchy chicken, cheddar cheese, red onions and green peppers
A grilled flatbread with Parmesan garlic sauce and oven-roasted chicken topped with spring greens and fresh Parmesan cheese
Mixed greens covered with oven-roasted chicken, tomatoes, bacon, onions and cheddar
Mixed greens, Kalamata olives, green peppers, tomatoes, feta and a dash of basil. Try it with our Italian or Balsamic Vinaigrette
A true classic with tomatoes, onions, green peppers, cucumbers and topped with cheese
Grilled chicken or seasoned ground beef with black beans, tomatoes and cheddar cheese. Served with chips, sour cream and salsa on the side
Handmade cannelloni filled with spinach, butternut squash and whipped ricotta. Paired with our creamy alfredo sauce
Shrimp and garlic ravioli with red pepper cream sauce, sautéed mushrooms and crumbled goat cheese
Layers of our homemade marinara sauce with beef, sausage, ricotta, cheese and pasta
Our homemade 3-cheese Alfredo sauce over fettuccini, tossed with chicken and mushrooms
Battered chicken breast smothered in our marinara sauce and topped with cheese over a bed of fettuccini tossed with Alfredo sauce
Our creamy, homemade macaroni & cheese to make you feel like a kid again
Fettuccini tossed with our homemade creamy pesto and shrimp. Simple and delicious
Our classic alfredo with a touch of cajun seasoning, shrimp and andouille sausage
Spinach-stuffed Tortellini, Fettuccini, Spaghetti, Cheese Ravioli (+$1), Portabella Mushroom Ravioli (+$3.50), Garlic & Shrimp Ravioli (+$3.50)
Marinara, Alfredo, Basil Pesto Cream, Red Pepper Cream
Additions (+$1) Grilled Veggies, Sautéed Mushrooms, Goat Cheese (+$2), Sausage, Andouille Sausage, Chicken (+$2), Shrimp (+$4)
Our version of a ham and Swiss with Rhoda's mustard, smoked ham, apple-wood smoked bacon, tomatoes, onions and Swiss cheese
Layers of Canadian bacon, grilled chicken and Swiss cheese paired with a honey mustard dressing
Grilled chicken, bacon, tomatoes, red onions and cheddar cheese married together perfectly with our homemade ranch
Tasty pastrami from Usinger's, sliced in our kitchens and served with sauerkraut, Swiss cheese and homemade thousand island dressing
The showcase in this sandwich is the pulled pork. It's smoked in-house and served up Kansas City style with BBQ, grilled onions and just a touch of cheese ('cause we are in Wisconsin)
We grill fresh mushrooms, green peppers, red pepper, red onions and tomatoes. It's just right paired with our signature cheese and basil pesto sauce
Our specialty cheese and Parmesan melted with battered and fried chicken breasts and just the right amount of our marinara sauce
Layers of salami, ham and pepperoni with red onions, green peppers, honey mustard and our stretchy signature cheese
Two toppings of your choice. Stuffed with creamy ricotta and cheese. Served with marinara
Want to forego the crust? We have you covered! Add the toppings of your choice (2 are included for free). Served with a side of marinara or any other sauce of your choice
Fettuccini or spaghetti with marinara or alfredo
With marinara or alfredo
Can be made gluten-free
We start with our creamy garlic cheese sauce and then top it with our signature cheese, smoked brats, caramelized onions and a swirl of bbq. OMG
Pesto cream sauce with artichoke hearts, broccoli, caramelized onions and signature cheese. Finished with an herb shake
Thousand island sauce, beef, pickles, onions
BBQ sauce, chicken, red onions, green peppers, pepper-jack
BBQ sauce, house-smoked pulled pork, onions. Add jalapenos or pineapple for something a little different
Alfredo sauce, spinach, chicken, mushrooms, roasted garlic
Taco sauce, seasoned beef or chicken, black beans, tomatoes, cheddar cheese. Served with lettuce, sour cream, salsa and chips
Steak sauce, steak, caramelized onions, green peppers and mushrooms
Pesto cream sauce, fresh basil, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and a drizzle of balsamic reduction
Pesto cream sauce, bacon, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, goat cheese, signature cheese
Pesto cream sauce, kalamata olives, spinach, artichoke hearts, tomatoes, feta, signature cheese
Buffalo sauce, chicken, onion, green pepper, pepper-jack. Topped with a swirl of ranch
Creamy garlic cheese sauce with jalapenos, bacon, signature cheese, cheddar cheese and toasted panko
Creamy garlic sauce, our signature cheese, Canadian bacon, crumbled bacon and a swirl of maple-rosemary syrup
Red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions,mushrooms
Red Sauce, pepperoni, sausage, whipped herb ricotta and oregano
Red sauce, Canadian bacon, pineapple, green pepper, red onion, cheddar cheese
Red sauce, bacon, ground beef, tomatoes, onions, cheddar cheese. Includes a side of pickles.
Red sauce, pepperoni, sausage, jalapenos, red onion, pepper-jack
Red sauce, spinach, mushrooms, tomatoes, green peppers, onions
Red sauce, salami, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, sausage, bacon
General Tso's sauce, chicken, onions, green peppers, pineapple, pepper-jack
Homemade mac N' cheese on our perfect pizza crust
Crispy thin, hand-rolled thin, hand-tossed or whole wheat
Italian red sauce (Gluten Free), Alfredo, BBQ (Gluten Free), Ranch (Gluten Free), Honey Mustard (Gluten Free), Buffalo Sauce (Gluten Free), Pesto Cream, Red Pepper Cream
Signature cheese, Cheddar, Habañero Pepper-Jack, Feta, whipped ricotta and goat cheese
Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Pulled Pork (premium toppings), Oven-Roasted Chicken, Salami, Canadian Bacon, Andouille Sausage, Buffalo Chicken, and Ground Beef. Artichoke hearts (premium toppings), Black Olives, Broccoli, Kalamata Olives (premium toppings), Green Peppers, Red Onions, Tomatoes, Green Olives, Red Peppers, Spinach, Fresh Basil, Jalapenos, Banana Peppers, Mushrooms, Pineapple, Roasted Garlic (premium toppings)
Oregano, SRP Herb Blend
Sriracha, Ranch, Balsamic Reduction, Maple-Rosemary Syrup
An Oreo crust with whipped peanut butter filling and homemade whipped cream topping. Finished with a drizzle of chocolate and crushed peanut butter cups
Fried cinnamon & sugar dough bites over ice cream with whipped cream, chocolate and caramel
A large homemade chocolate chip cookie all warm and yummy
A warm and gooey chocolate brownie with Salted Caramel ice cream
Fried dough bites covered in powdered sugar. Comes with chocolate, caramel or raspberry sauce
Coke, Diet Coke, Mr. Pibb, Fanta Orange, Sprite, Sprite Zero, Mello Yellow
Unsweetened, Raspberry, Strawberry
Regular & Decaf
Root Beer, Root Beer Lo-Cal, Cherry Cola, Grape, Cream Soda
Tazo Passion, Tazo Wild Sweet Orange, Tazo Zen, Tazo Earl Grey
Cranberry, orange, lemonade, pineapple
White & Chocolate
Chicken strips kids meal
Amazon Deluxe w/crispy thin crust (12"-$18.50)
Crunchy Chicken
Portabella Mushroom Ravioli with Marinara Sauce
Pizzas; missy fig and Amazon and Elote
The elote pizza
Build your own - onions, red pepper, goat cheese, extra sauce. YUMMMM
Asian chicken
Bacon chicken ranch salad
Kid's pepperoni pizza
Side salad with French and bleu cheese dressing
Ping pinging water and wine.
Bread Sticks
Bread sticks (large)
Appetizers
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac N Cheese
16" w/ roasted garlic, hot honey
Kickapoo taco w/thin crust (12"- $18.50)
Amazon well decked with ingredients and meaty; my favorite.
Bacon Cheese burger thick crust pizza
Margarita and Cheeseburger
Double pepperoni and black olive pizza.
Sugar River Pizza
10" Thin crust pepperoni pizza
Alex W.
Jan 27, 2025
Fair prices, well cooked pizzas, and intriguing specialties. I find it interesting that they replace tomato sauce with whatever the base of the specialty calls for. For example, we got the Rio Grande bbq chicken, and typically I'd see the bbq sauce drizzled on top, but here it's fully incorporated within. My friend said it made the pizza too sauce-y, and I would agree (though I like bbq sauce so I didn't mind as much). Overall though, this is a great place with friendly service and I would definitely come back again to try some of their other flavors!
Read More
C B.
Dec 17, 2024
Picked up some food here while on a trip after hearing good things. Shouldn't have gotten the "stuffed" pizza. It was extremely doughy, not particularly flavorful, and overall pretty disappointing. Salad was fine. Kids enjoyed their spaghetti. I doubt I'll be back in the area anytime soon, but this was overhyped.
Read More
Christina L.
Mar 2, 2025
I tried this restaurant for the first time and it is fairly priced! The pizzas were delicious and had plenty of toppings. I got the Amazon Deluxe and I added pineapples. Quick service and good pizza. I would recommend!
Read More
Sho R.
May 13, 2024
I dined in on a weekend for lunch. There was a good number of people, but still I got a seat right away. The pizzas were very innovative. Asian chicken pizza was my favorite. It had nice flavor punch. The elote pizza was another excellent pizza. Kids chicken strips was good.
Read More
Dave J.
Jan 19, 2025
After many visits I've become a fan. Their basic pizzas are good and their traditional Italian entrees are big enough for two meals. When we dine in the service is constantly good.
Read More
Erik R.
May 24, 2024
Probably one of the best pizzas in Dane County. Try the Amazon pizza if you like meat and veggies, you won't be disappointed. Excellent beer list mainly with local breweries on tap and Paulaner Pilsner from Germany which goes great with the pizzas !
Read More
Tiffany T.
Oct 3, 2023
Wow! What a fantastic pizza place. Everything was sooooooo good.The service, the portions, the food! Not one single complaint. Nothing could have been better.It is worth driving 2 hours away for their pizza and salad. I had their gluten free pizza and will definitely get the taco again. The chicken bacon ranch salad was huge...and I only had a half portion. I repeat, what is shown is a HALF chicken bacon ranch salad.Go. You. Will. Not. Regret. It.Lastly, they have coke products!
Read More
Katie P.
Jan 4, 2025
We ate dinner at Sugar River Pizza on a Friday and it was great! They have a huge menu with a lot of different options. We got a 14in pizza- half Rio Grande BBQ Chicken and half The Tropics.The restaurant was busy but we didn't have to wait too long for our food. Service was great and our meal was very affordable!We will be back!*I highly recommend a reservation, we tired to go the Friday before and it was an hour wait. But we returned the next Friday with a reservation made earlier in the day and we were sat right away!
Read More
Marcos S.
Feb 28, 2025
Came in for the steak sandwich. Waitress seemed to not be in a good mood. No smile. Ended up not getting the sandwich as it was out and waitress said it's hard to come by. Ended up getting the pulled pork sandwich. Not very good. After I got my food, she asked if I'd like anything else, I asked for ketchup. Come to find out I got charged 50cents for ketchup after I got my bill. I would have not asked for it if I knew I would be charged for that. Ridiculous. I told the waitress that as a suggestion, she should let people know that it is a charge so people are not surprised by it. She said, ok. Not a thanks for the tip or sorry for the misunderstanding or anything. Never going back here.
Read More
Linda C.
Dec 21, 2024
I rarely eat the crust on pizza, but I love pizza. Some brilliant chef came up with the pizza bowl at Sugar River Pizza. It doesn't seem like it would be good, but I was in an adventurous mood. I picked sausage, black olives, artichokes & mushrooms. What a taste delight!!! The service was the best. I now have my very own pizza!
Read More
