Sugar River Pizza

What a pleasant surpriseI ordered the gouda bites nice tasty fried cheese. The Maple Bacon pizza hand tossed crust was recommended by Pearl the bartender and what a great tasting pizza it was unique from anything I had before Excellent service and a great beer selection I will return to try more

Great pizza. We went for a weekday lunch. Our server was distracted but it may be due to him being the only one, but they weren't busy. That said, the pizza was really good. We customized ours so it was pricey but well worth it. Drinks were reasonably priced. We will dine here again.

A good pizza joint when you want variety of specialty type pizzas at a decent price. We ordered a specialty pizza with some custom toppings split between the halves & it was great! We did a take-out so not sure of in store service, but place looked busy for a regular weekday evening. Plenty of parking spots nearby which is a plus. The portions of toppings are on higher side and it tasted really good.

This is a great place for a large menu/ lots of different options. One of my favorite pizza places. This is my favorite place for hand tossed pizza. All of the pizzas have a perfect amount of toppings, and they were all well balanced. Overall there is never a miss on any pizza I've gotten here, and the appetizers are also delicious. The food is always served quickly, and the service is always friendly. I loved the sweet treat, cinnamon nuggets. Portions are huge and prices are inexpensive. There was live music tonight, and I appreciated how it wasn't too loud but just loud enough to enjoy. Lighting and seating are great, with many places to sit with large groups.

We got a garden salad with ranch and a BYO pizza with sausage, onion, mushroom. Loved the fresh, local ingredients!Seemed it was some sort of trivia night (busy!!) but we got a table without a wait & food came out quick & fresh. Will stop again!

After hearing some decent reviews, my better half and I decided to stop in when we were in the area. The location is definitely built for a crowd as it spacious but lacks any real charm. A very expansive tap list (probably close to 50) is notable. We were in the witching hour between lunch and dinner and our waitstaff was a little brusque. We ordered the stuffed cheese bread along with an amazon deluxe pizza. They were fine. Definitely not noteworthy or something we would purposefully come back for. An option if you were hungry and needed a quick bite or a few beers.

Finally went to the delicious Sugar River Pizza! It was a surprisingly calm night with few people, and we enjoyed our food, drinks, and desserts. Our server was very nice and welcoming, the pizza and salads were excellent and oh my goodness, get the peanut butter pie and roll yourself out the door -- holy goodness that dessert is a top 10 for me.We had pretzel bites which were amazing, although they kind of sit in the butter pooled under them. The Hawaiian pizza was delicious, pineapple does in fact belong on pizza. I had the Asian chicken salad and was very happy with the portions and quality. The peanut butter pie was absolutely outstanding. I would drive the 25 minutes from my apartment just to order that dessert. It is incredible, I'm still thinking about it days later. Get one for the table!The ambiance isn't much to speak of, there's not a ton of decor or a theme going. The bathrooms were nice, but watch out, the foamy soap comes directly at you!

Stop by this place for dinner with family. What a cute sit down restaurant. Our server was very attentive but I didn't catch her name. We had a party of 7 and it was easy to get a table since it wasn't that full for a Thursday night. We ended up ordering onion rings and spinach and artichoke dip as our appetizers and 3 different kinds of pizza--Mediterranean, Garden Bella with added pineapples, and Amazon deluxe on a gluten free crust. Everything was so delicious. Would definitely come back again for their pizza and to try other things on the menu.

Best kept happy hour! Monday - Friday 2:30-5:30 all apps (excluding wings and tenders) are half off. I will never turn down a pizza here though, try the creamy pesto...it's the best I've had! As much as love SRP, the service is hit or miss, which is why the 4 stars. Sometimes things are fast and well-oiled, other times you could wait an hour to get an appetizer. Today our waitress never checked back after our food and we both needed refills on our sodas. I've had several meals made wrong, or even forgotten, and not given a comp, offered to make right, or much of an apology. I've eaten here a lot in the last two years and the food outweighs the potentially bad service.

Great place and great food plus the portions are huge! Wanted to try the avocado ranch but unfortunately they don't serve it anymore, went with the sriracha mayo instead and was very good!