St. Paul Fish - Mequon

I have been to the third ward location and obviously loved the freshness of their seafood but I think i prefer this mequon location because it is much larger, offers plenty of seating and i think for families with small kids this does not feel claustrophobic. I had their lake perch fish fry before and literally the only fish fry i will ever eat. My kids also finished it so its THAT good. I love the coleslaw too! My husband got the lobster roll which is one of their popular items and that did not disappoint. I had the lobster tail and grandma got the crab legs. Every single item we ordered were super fresh and perfect in flavor. Went there for an early dinner and this place is super kid friendly. Server was very attentive and always checked if we needed anything. The oysters were fresh and i will be back for their buck o shuck Thursday. They have a decent alcoholic beverage selection.

My second visit to St. Paul, I brought my daughter, who absolutely loved it. Our server Valerie was great. She was friendly, helpful, funny and full of smiles. She had great recommendations and was very attentive.This visit, I decided to try the St. Paul Lobster Tail Bloody. OMG. The presentation on this is amazing, and the drink itself was fantastic! The "Salmon Crack" garnish is offered as a starter, and after one bite you'll understand why. The sweet crust and the smoky salmon is an excellent combination. Think salty-sweet, but better! (Also big props for the beer chaser). We started out with the Cajun BBQ Shrimp, then I had the Shrimp and Sausage Gumbo. The Cajun BBQ Shrimp was tender, and the sauce was rich, creamy and spicy. I could have just dipped more bread in that and been fine. The Gumbo was also wonderfully spicy, with big pieces of sausage. It could have used a little more salt for me, but overall the flavors were very good. It's official. This place is now one of my favorites!

Food was very good! Happy hour prices and a cool vibe! AService was great! Very nice bartender. AAmbiance is outstanding. Laid back and awesome vibe. A

I was visiting from Texas and my uncle took me here because I'm a seafood lover. The ambiance was awesome. I loved the concept. There was a fresh seafood market when you enter and a restaurant through this open foyer. Surprisedly, there was no fishy smell. The fresh seafood was frozen which could have subdue the smell. In any event, the prices were reasonable and the portions were adequate for the price. Our waitress was attentive and friendly. I would have given this place a five star if my food would have come out hot; instead, the main course was warm and the sides taste at room temperature. I don't know if my was prepared first and it sat while the other orders were being prepared. It was strange but obvious that the food had different temps. However, the taste was good and I will definitely give them another shot when I visit again.

This was my first time at this restaurant, and I was really surprised at the size! Since their other location is in the Milwaukee public market and it's pretty small, I wasn't surprising such a big restaurant in Mequon. It's awesome that you can come here and buy raw shellfish/seafood and take it home. We came on Friday for fish fry, which they offer every day of the week. Usually, you can only find them on Fridays! We got the walleye and the perch, both were delicious. There's a lot of fish, not just breading. The tartar sauce was so good too, which I feel like can be hit or miss other places. I will say their appetizers are basically all shellfish, I think there was only 1 option for just a plain seafood dish instead of shellfish. We also ordered a Cesar salad and the portion was awesome for sharing!

My daughter wanted to treat me to a seafood dinner on Father's Day since we are the only 2 who love seafood, and boy did she! Wonderful atmosphere and decor made me feel like I was at the beach out east.We were in the mood for oysters, and they had a nice selection, so we chose 3 types and all of them were nice and briny and delicious. I ordered a shrimp Po Boy and it tasted just like the ones I've had in New Orleans! My daughter had a crab roll and it was unusual tasty and very large.Good prompt service.I have been to the one in the Public Market and that one is wonderful, but very crowded most of the time.I like the more relaxed atmosphere and space at the Mequon location better, and could not recommend this one with the huge selection of wines and drinks and food choices more!

Went here on Monday. It was pleasant enough to sit outside. Since it's on a hwy, the traffic is busy with cars and dump trucks. We didn't mind. Railroad tracks run along side of it. And the bike path extends up here. Very busy and much to look at. Service is fantastic Food is the best. It's seafood at its best. It is a casual place with great decorations. I love it. $$$

The friendly staff and fresh seafood makes the trip a great experience, andI've never been disappointed.

The St. Paul Fish Company is one of my favorite seafood restaurants. The Mequon location is a little more relaxed and spacious. The downtown location is cool too but much busier. They have a lot of great seafood options to choose from. The seafood boils are always great and plenty of food. I mainly go here for the Bloody Mary, the oyster shooters, the oysters, and the salmon crack. I usually get a pound of the salmon crack to go. Definitely recommend checking this place out if you haven't already. I always look forward to making a stop here when I'm back in Milwaukee.

Never had a bad piece of fish at this place. Always have what you're looking for and the staff is always friendly