SmallPie

I'm not even a pie guy. But even I know an excellent pie when I see one. And if they got your name in the title, as was the case with the Door county cherry pie we had from here, then you know it's gone be good.And it was. Everyone should try this...

Stopped here for a quick lunch to go. Overall I like the location, ambiance, food, and staff. They were friendly and pointed me to the food menu when I looked confused trying to find it. I grabbed a turkey pepper sandwich, 12 oz iced chai latte, and slice of key lime pie. The only reason I'm docking a star is the pricing. Those three items costed $30 and I do not think that's justified. The food was great, don't get me wrong. I think maybe if the sandwich came with chips or a side or everything was a couple bucks cheaper, I would come back more often.

Came here because YELP actually published a "best pie in every state" list while we were in Milwaukee, so of course we had to come try it.We got 3 slices for $26, a fruit one, a french silk, and a milwaukee mud pie. Pros:- Prices may seem steep, but the pie slices are HUGE. Also the french silk and mud pie were DELICIOUS - I even ate the rest of the mud pie the next morning and the taste still really held up. This place is literally a hidden gem. It tasted exactly like the best version of what I expected out of each pie. - Despite a very humble space, the outside area is very chill to take a bite of pie in- The service was very efficient- Has a bathroom- Not too busy, fast staff response10/10 would come back to Milwaukee for this, probably my favorite thing we ate during our trip!

Small Pie is a cute little space with a small outdoor patio when weather permits to have delicious treats and bakery. We ordered a pie online for pick up as a gift for our daughter and hubby for their 3rd anniversary. It worked out super easily and well. The gals were kind and friendly at the store and our pie was ready to go at the pick up time. We also purchased a gift card as a gift for a future pie. This was warmly received and super delicious. If you're looking for a unique and sweet special (as the pies are costly , but made with quality ingredients) gift for someone- consider one of their pies. YUM!!!!! There isn't a lot of parking availability. But, you'll manage. :) If you are elderly or can't walk far- maybe look into being dropped off so you can sit outside and enjoy your bakery - or inside. The seating is limited inside and it is small inside. But then you can look at the pretty case of desserts and think about your next visit.

I wish I wasn't in a rush or watching calories because EVERYTHING looked delicious. I had a breakfast Sammy and it was delicious. The fresh herbs, the thick bacon and the heavenly croissant made for a great start to my day.

I had no idea SmallPie was a subsidiary of Honeypie which is closer to our home. Located in a hidden commercial pocket of Bay View, SmallPie is housed in a cute transformation of a gas station. My wife and I walked in and oohed and aawed at the cookies and pies on display. I tried to joke and kibitz with the two women working this warm Thursday morning in February, but they didn't like me. No smiles, warmth, or interaction was forthwith. They were all business. We purchased a bunch of stuff: 5 slices of pie and at least 4 cookies. Prices were very high, but the slices were big. SmallPie ain't cheap. My chocolate chip cookie was good, but the Toffee cookie was great. My favorite pie was pistachio. Chocolate pie let me down. In summation, the baked goods were well made and enjoyable, but the price point might cause me to hesitate. I wasn't in pie ecstasy. The lack of engagement by the staff wasn't encouraging. My sense of self needs positive reinforcement. Milwaukee used to be much friendlier. Tribalism isn't good for mental health.

A great little spot to grab lunch in Bayview I recommend the chorizo and potato hand pieDogs allowed

Great spot to get some delicious treats for brunch or when having a sweet tooth. They have different pies and pastries that are all worth it. Different flavors for anyone, including vegans. They do have great service, they answer the phone and are polite. When you go in person they great you and make sure you're getting the correct items that you want. They have different crafts beers and wines. Ambiance is pretty cool and chill. Lots of locals so by that are walking their dogs. So get your dessert before they run out of it. Stopping by again.

Their website posts all the pi's that you an try when there, but when I stopped by and sat outside, which was nice with area for dogs, there was no pie to choose from other than just two or three in the case. This was about lunch time in early fall. I was disappointed.

The price of their pies has gone up but I feel like the quality has decreased. I will say the service is great, and the ambiance is always neat and clean.