Schwarz's Supper Club

Always an amazing meal! Service is excellent! (No reservations) Adult beverages are spot in as well!

We came just shy of 3 hours to try out the infamous Schwarz's!We arrived just at 4 on a Saturday, and the parking lot was stuffed full already. Their bar opened at 3.We walked in with a dozen other people and it was already difficult to scoot around everyone. When you arrive, the bar is a giant V shape. You can go to the right, which is toward the dining room area OR you can go to the left. Along the left side are a few booths and tables for waiting. If you follow the left side along the bar, you'll come upon an entire side room further to the left. Full of tables and booths to sit at. Could definitely have a cocktail waitress or five!We got a drink right away, since we didn't know much about the ordering process before going. I asked the bartended how we order, and she said to look for a lady with menus.It took a while to get one to even LOOK at us to get a menu from. Luckily, we didn't look over the menu beforehand and really already knew what we'd be ordering. When I finally caught a hostess to ask how she knew whose order she would take next, she said, you have to put your menu in the air so she knows you are ready. I replied with we didn't have any, but we were ready anyways whenever she was. She took our order right then and there. They ask your name and party number. Then when your table is ready, they will announce it over the loud speakers.We were told it would be an hour before we go to our table, but it's wasn't even a half hour! I think stopping her and knowing what we wanted really helped speed up our time. But we didn't know the process, and it's not mentioned anywhere!When your name is called, you follow the V Bar off to the right from the entrance and toward the dining room. There is a desk before you enter the dining area and you check in there to see which table you are at.Your salads are all there waiting for you, paired with a classic supper club relish tray and rolls.We had scallops, prime rib, baked potato and fries.Everything was very yummy and our waitstaff were so attentive. I love seeing them work together! Even the teens cleaning off the tables were noticing our water glasses were empty and stepped in to help.Only place it lost a star is the lack of organization with ordering. I know it works for them, but could very well simplify it for both them and the customers by mainstreaming it a bit. A few hostesses looked distressed, but I would be too if everyone was stopping me constantly for menus and to see when they can order or what the process is.Definitely a good one to experience once, but I would hate to navigate the craziness with any additional people in our party.

What a great place! The system is great: they take your order in advance, so by the time you get seated, salads and/or appetizers are on the table. This is highly appreciated as this place is extremely busy on a Saturday night.We got there at 5pm and the bar was full...and also the waiting area. The layout of the restaurant is interesting; divided in rooms that you don't see until you get to your table.The menu is great, and the service is even better. One of the best supper clubs in the state! Highly recommended!

This is a great place to visit, and to show others when they visit. The steaks are amazing, the people were amazing and the atmosphere was amazing. We are all looking forward to visiting again and trying other items on the menu!!

Friends of ours have suggested Schwarz's as an old fashion Wisconsin supper club that we needed to try. It's the typical order at the bar, have a few old fashioneds and get called to your table when it's time to eat.Our group suggested I had to have the cowboy ribeye. Oh my goodness, what a steak it is. So thick and well prepared. We had a great time with good company, good food and good prices.

They've really got it down here. They staff is a well oiled, hustling machine. You wait in the bar until you're ready to order and stand the menu up to let them know. They take your order and call you when you're table is ready. You sit down to your salad, rolls and relish tray waiting for you--followed by your delicious meal.Everything we had was delicious. We opted for: Prime Rib, Walleye, Lobster, Rib Eye with sides of baked potato, french fries, and onion rings. Everything was cooked and seasoned perfectly. As always, the perfect way to end any supper club meal is with a Brandy Alexander or Grasshopper. We always share one and opted for the Brandy Alexander. Sooo good (but you can't go wrong with either of them).

We had an outstanding experience in every respect. Food, service, price, and cocktails were all terrific

Interesting visit. You order at the bar which we've seen at other places. However, no one really explains the process unless you explicitly ask. They also didn't have the vegetable and potato options on the menu so we had to ask after that. The bartenders seemed over it real quick. They must have regulars primarily who know exactly what to do. It was tough to come prepared since they don't have a food menu on their website.Once your salad is at the table, they call your name over a loud speaker so you know to seat yourself in the dining room. They had bread and a relish tray at the table, too.After we finished, our meals came out pretty soon. The first few bites were good, but they serve the entrees on metal plates to keep the meal warm which continues to cook the steak. By the end, the sirloin was well done and tough to eat. Our server stopped by to check in on things but also didn't seem that invested.Now that we know what to do and what to expect, it might be a better experience next time but we're not in a hurry to go back. Not the supper club vibe that we have grown accustomed to, maybe.

Food and service was amazing!!! The bartenders were super friendly!!! The atmosphere was very nice too!!

The layout perfect.The drinks great!The service 100% incredible!The most delicious steaks served by the most on point waiter staff.A big shout out to Sierra for being friendly attentive and accommodating.