Sal's Pub And Grill
Sal's Pub And Grill
Shrimp butter garlic
Cheeseburger with jalapeños known as the Hotwheel Burger
Pizza
Perch fish fry
the front of the building
Orange roughy fish fry
14" thin crust pizza
Homemade meatball sandwich
Machines
Perch fish fry
Wings
Front bar dining area
Broiled cod
Bar
outside
Menu page two
interior, sushi and sashimi
Menu page one
Try our yummy cheesy garlic bread!
food
Jerry M.
Nov 6, 2016
Sal's is a most interesting discovery, on the southwest of the Four Corners of Menomonee Falls. bar and grill with a kitchen instead of a grill. The place is too nice to be classified a dive (you don't stick to the floor) but it's not quite a restaurant, either. Sal's appears to be a neighborhood bar "...where everyone knows your name," at least, most of the people there fit that description. It's in a 19th century building that used to be a hotel (so I've been told) and it still has tin ceilings. Tables are tall with bar stools. There's a back room with two pool tables that were unused while I was there.We were greeted by Sal who sat and chatted for a bit. There's lots of microbrews on tap so I started with my go to, Lakefront Riverwest Stein, my dinner partner had the Lakefront IPA. The menu is extensive by pub & grill standards, lots of sandwich choices. From the description of their signature burger, had I ordered it, I'd still be there trying to finish it.I ordered a meatball sandwich, and it was a more than pleasant surprise. There's a lot of effort that goes into the making of the sandwich. The meatballs are loosely packed, soft and easy to bite into. Ground beef, pork, onions, homemade bread crumbs, onions and there's something else in there that I couldn't identify. There was just enough homemade marinara sauce, the sandwich wasn't swimming in marinara like some places do. It was toasted and hot when it arrived at the table, and was served with chips and Sal's cole slaw.My dinner date ordered Chicken Parmesan without singing the little seven note jingle Peyton M. sings. It's served with the same marinara sauce that was on my meatballs that helped make it a great sandwich. Overall, it was a good experience. The music was a little too loud for my taste, making dinner conversation difficult. I'd take off half a star for that if I could, but the food will cause me to return.
Read More
Kevin N.
Sep 8, 2023
Our first time here looking for pizza, so we called it in came at the designated time but no pizza... waited an additional 25 mins. Wasn't busy, I was little agitated at about hour to get a couple of pizzas but as the saying goes, crap happens". The bartender was polite and courteous, pizza was average...
Read More
Teddy R.
Mar 1, 2024
I waited 80 mins at least for a meatball sandwich to-go. I waited patiently as the guy kept serving me a beer. When I asked 80 mins later (he said it was going to take an hour). He told me I I initially said "f-it, I can't wait that long". But what I really said was "It is Friday, I am patient and I can wait, I am enjoying myself". Instead I had to go to subway to get a Italian Meatball instead. I really wanted to support a local business but I can't if they can't make me a sandwich.
Read More
Herb P.
Jan 19, 2023
We stopped to try something new. Should have passed it by. The onion pedals were tiny pieces of chopped onion that had a flavor of last years oil.The chicken fingers were were ground chicken ( frozen) dropped in hot oil. No flavor. The FF were crispy on the outside and soggy inside. The pub burger was probably the only item fresh. Cooked well but no flavor except from the grease on the flat top.Don't bother as there better out their.
Read More
Jodi R.
Apr 28, 2023
We always have the best time at Sal's! From the delicious food to the friendly service, Sal's can't be beat! Try the blackened ahi tuna, it's awesome! Cheers to Bri, Trish, Dominique, James, Salvatore, and especially Sal!
Read More
Prince S.
Dec 4, 2022
Very disappointed in this place. My husband and I wanted to try something new so we decided to stop at Sals. He got to Miller Liked, Half, Beers and I had a bloody Mary we ordered theCajun steak sandwich and I don't understand why they call it that because there was nothing about it that had that flavor and it was super dry and tough and hardly any meat. The bartender was cold, but came back outside from smoking and reeked of cigarettes so I had a smell that why ate. We also ordered poppers for an appetizer and they were piping hot and they were nothing other than Store bought from the frozen section. And somehow my bill came out to $54. The bloody Mary didn't have anything more than a lime and a lemon and a pickle. Slice not a wedge a slice never again.
Read More
Michelle B.
Mar 13, 2018
We wanted to try a new place for Friday night dinner.We chose to eat at the bar.Bartender was very attentive but this is the best thing I could say about the place.Fried cheese nuggets were overcooked and too heavily breaded.Blackened Ahi tuna was overcooked.Fried Haddock was little chunks of overly breaded and over cooked fish. Terrible!
Read More
Greg B.
Dec 15, 2017
The perch on Fridays is phenomenal. The herb breading prefectly accentuates the flavor of the perch. The cajun wings also have the right amount of heat to leave your lips and tongue tingling. Both are a must try. Don't miss this hidden-in-plain-sight gem downtown in the Falls.
Read More
Hannah F.
Feb 24, 2024
unreal burger and delicious meatball sandwich but even better service from James! 12/10 spot!
Read More
Extremely D.
Dec 28, 2022
Stopped in to have some food and drink and play a couple of video games.Ordered some food which looked good and tasted fine. However I will never return. I understand this can happen but I wish the cook would have worn gloves. After I finished one sandwich I decided I would order a second. As I approached the bar to place a second order the cook came out of the kitchen and sat at the bar and ordered a bandage from the bartender. The young cook mentioned that his band-aid had fallen off making my first sandwich as he sat at the bar and applied his fresh one to his bloody finger. As you can imagine I turned and walked out of the bar to never return. I literally felt like throwing up on the way out the door. This happened over a year ago but noticed this bar on yelp as I was looking for a review on another place I was going to eat at today. So I thought I would finally write about Sals .
Read More
