Reilly's Pub

I could go on and on about how great the food and service was... Instead I need to talk about a negative. I went into the men's bathroom to wash my hands. When entering I saw a urinal and a toilet separated by a partition, with no door to the sectioned off area with the toilet. After a moments consideration I decided to use the urinal. Yet there was the toilet to consider. I didn't want to use the urinal for even a short time just to have another person come in to just to drop a mudslide into a toilet that doesn't have a door. I locked the door after coming to the conclusion that it is meant for single use at a time. Within SECONDS of doing this another patron SLAMMED into the locked door, yelling "WHY'S THIS DOOR LOCKED?!" The waitress on the other end responds "There is a stall, the guy in there is probably using the toilet." "IS THERE EVEN ANOTHER BATHROOM I CAN USE?!" "No, you will have to wait for this one to open." "Arghhh (sigh)." Mind you my table was right in ear shot to this whole thing, and this was not even 2 minutes. I was mortified. When I finished I didn't even know how I would be able to look my friends in the face. Upon exit there wasn't even anybody that was waiting to use the bathroom, and none of the people at my table even heard that exchange. The food came and was good. I got the beer battered cod, with the potato pancakes, and cottage cheese. Plenty of food, and the price is good. 5/5 stars. Keep up the quality!

If it were possible to rate negative stars I would. Told it would be about 10 minutes to be seated... bar is empty, high tops were pretty full until the 25 minute mark. At which point we ordered an appetizer at the bar, while still waiting for a table. At 45 minutes we just ordered our food to go.PSA: If you only have one god forsaken accessible table in your establishment, save it for people who actually need it. That was the most asinine seating thought process I've witnessed.And to top it all off, frozen Vandekamp's from Walmart is comparable to the fish served here.Disappointing is an understatement. We won't be back.

Reilly's Pub was rocking on a Sunday night when there were not a lot of dining options open. The hostess was also bussing, serving, sweeping, moving tables,... it was all hands on deck. We started with onion rings, cheese curds, and shrimp. I liked the onions rings best, crispy but not too crispy. I chose the Cobb salad for my entree. Chicken was an extra charge and I didn't opt to add it. There were lots of toppings and all the ingredients were fresh. The outdoor patio looked cozy and it would have been nice to have a table out there. We enjoyed our meals - good, not great. Really appreciated how much the hostess was doing to fill gaps.

Really good pub food and bar with good Wisconsin service. My crew enjoyed fish fry on Friday including cod and bluegill. Loved the potato pancake and Cole slaw sides. Returned on Saturday and loved the homemade lasagna special, BLT, and burger. Lots of beer choices including Knuth Brewing Blue Eyed Blond which is now a favorite. "Giggles" was the name of our server. Super nice gal. When near Green Lake Wisc this is a must stop.

This place is looking run down, barstools all torn, foam coming out, napkins leveling tables, slow, unattentive bartenders... makes you wonder..

We had a nice dinner at Riley's! They have solid outdoor seating options, which is a plus when you're traveling with a dog and a two year old! They also start serving dinner pretty early (4/4:30). The waitstaff were very kind and checked in multiple times. If you're in the area, definitely recommend checking this place out!

Received wrong sandwich and would only give 20%discount. Shame. We frequent the restaurant and this was a disappointment.

Great service, great food! Every time !Wonderful place and close to home plus a great view of the Lake.

Great all American (and some Irish) pub fare. Live that there are gluten free options. And glad water access is back!!

had to give at least one star but would like to have given them none - stopped by for ice cream - first girl just walked out on us and the second one told us that their tables was their priority and we would have to wait until someone was free to serve us - we waited about 10 mins and left. We'll use our money somewhere else where it is appreciated