Random Lake Pizzeria

Best Pizza in Wisconsin. The nicecream it out of this world! Tommy's the best! Had my wedding here because we met there.

We had takeout from here! Order was hot, delicious, and not a leftover to be had. Yum!

Went here for dinner with a large group of friends and ordered the Gyro Salad and Calzone. The gyro meat on the salad was nicely sized, extremely tender, and very well seasoned. The salad mix that came with it was well proportioned, and both tasted just as good the next day as leftovers. The breadstick was dense, warm, and incredibly delicious. You can tell the dough is handmade. The sausage calzone was not too big, and the handmade dough here did not soften or get soggy on the bottom. After reheating the next day, the crust held its firmness, and the calzone was just as flavorful. The interior of this place is pretty eclectic, with lots to draw your attention to. It's family orientated, and the wait staff is incredible. Tom was fast, extremely patient, and friendly. He was kind enough to grant our requests for separate checks and took the time to socialize with us. This is a great spot with great food and good people.

I have to say I was pleasantly surprised that Random Lake is where I would find some great pizza!They have unique pizza options and I encourage trying one of the specialties. We tried a plain sausage and the spaghetti and meatballs. Hands down everyone in our group was obsessed with the spaghetti and meatballs. It was buttery, noodley, saucy, meat goodness!! The breadsticks were also really good. Fun and unique pizzas. The staff was really friendly and polite. We will be ordering from here regularly while at the lake.

I was at a bonfire in Richfield and people were talking about great pizza they raved at how good this pizza was and I had to agree just happen to be around the area visiting an old classmate Tim S. Tommy, the owner seems to have dialed into what people want in a fresh, quality pizza restaurant. The place was packed on a Saturday afternoon crowd. The whole restaurant had a total of two seats available at the bar. Drink orders were quick. A few of the people getting home made ice cream to go while some got take out pizza and many were dining in.I found a great selection of craft beers. The owner is always onsite, a guarantee for great service. This place is decorated part man and she cave. The kids are allowed to decorate the walls with their own hands and name. It has a family feel. They have a WC Ramp for restroom access and outside has a bar with occasional live music out by the tracks. And yes I plan to have a few more visits before snowfall. 8/2019Food 5 no canned mushrooms thank god Ambiance 5Service 5Location 5Value 5

this place is great! I recommend it without hesitation. tom does a wonderful job. please check it out

This place is a gem! The staff is so friendly, the food is delicious, the decor is interesting, and they play great tunes. We shared a yummy cheesy crust app (try it with the spicy dipping sauce!) I had a half gyro-half muskie pizza, my son had the spaghetti (huge portion), and my husband had his usual: pepperoni, green olive, and onion. At the end of our meal, the power went out in Random Lake. The staff handled it like absolute pros, trying to accommodate a large party that had just come in. All of the guests seemed to take it in stride because the pizzeria team was so easygoing about the situation. We left with nice cream cones, full bellies, and smiles on our faces. We'll definitely be back!

Great Pizza and very customer friendly staff and owner.Homemade ice cream for desert was excellent!

Such a beautiful family place. Best pizza crust I've ever had. Delicious homemade ice cream. Menu is extremely interesting. The bartender is super cool. Clean kitchen. The owner is focused and loves his job. He is friendly to the customers. I'll have to go back a second time before I decide if it's a five star.

NEVER AGAIN!! NEVER HAVE I REGRETED BUYING A GIFT CERTIFICATE. Ordered food to go. Got home pizza was uncut, ok fine. My pasta was dry and sauce less. Like eating spaghetti noodles with Italian seasoning dumped on top. Awful.