Pizza Pete’s

I've read mixed reviews about consistency, but thought we would give it a try. We definitely loved the pizza. It was tasty, well topped and the crust and sauce and combination of toppings- just YUMMY!! Called and placed the order over the phone, they were pleasant and fun and pizza was ready when we got there. If this is how everyone would receive their pizza- there would be all smiles--- just like ours. Thanks Pizza Petes!!

Terrible. Ordered delivery, took longer than was told. Food arrived cold. One pizza missing a requested topping and looked like it had been dropped, see picture.

If you are looking for a delicious pizza, whether it be thin crust, hand, tossed, deep dish, or New York style. Pizza Pete's is your answer. This was my first time trying it and the pizza was wonderful. The sausage was great. The garlic bread had a nice tangy flavor to it. They also serve buckets of chicken. The staff was wonderful, extremely friendly, My favorite test for pizza is how well does it taste the next day cold out of the refrigerator? And Pizza Petes tasted just as great the next morning. Definitely check them out. Cudahy has always had great tasting pizza places... and Pizza Petes continues that tradition.

I heard some good things and maybe my expectations were too high, but this was just not good. The sauce was plain, not tasty and there was a lot of cheese, but it was gluey. I've had way better frozen pizzas to be honest. I hear they are inconsistent. Maybe I will give them another chance someday.

First off, if the Dingbat behind the register would answer the phone rather than leave it off the hook you may get more business. I could here it when I went to pick up my pie. Some of us don't want to deal with an App. I want to call and put my order in. She will always be nothing more than a cashier, very low low energy. I had to repeat my order 5 times; thin crust, olives, onions, pepperoni...5 times.Now the pizza; thin crust it is not. When I think of thin crust I think of Neds Pizza. Ned's pizza will always be the very best in town. While the sausage and other toppings were plentiful it needed more sauce. But if it had more sauce the thick "thin" crust would be even more soggy. Not sure if I did get the thin crust. I see that there is a "hand tossed" crust too, however that differs from the thin not real sure. The Dingbat Low Energy cashier probly got the order wrong.The crust sucks.

Ordered a pie for delivery. It arrived 25 minutes after the delivery window time had expired. I had to walk out to the sidewalk because the driver was just sitting in his car scrolling through his phone while being double parked! He handed me a box straight from his car seat that was not kept warm at all with a thermal bag and yes the pizza was luke warm. when I got it inside and opened the cover I discovered the all the sauce and toppings were sloshed to the side and on the inside lid of the box. When you are paying 36.00 for a pizza you would hopefully expect it to be warm and arrive within a reasonable time.

The delivery was 40 min late , the marinara sauces which I paid extra for was missing , and the worst part the pizza had NO sauce on it! Let me repeat No sauce on the pizza , it was crust , cheese and very little toppings! And the breaded mushrooms were barely breaded.

Pizza was scrimpy on the toppings. Too salty. The cheese was rubbery not gooey like it should be. Almost wonder if they use fake cheese?We did carry out, so no opinion on service or atomosphere.Sorry to say, probably won't order again.

For starters I would like to say how nice the workers are. I am from Michigan and definitely not used to that from a pizza place. We ordered the eggplant strips "!omg!" Delicious!Pizza was acrimonious, onions still had that little crunch to them, tasted like it came out of a brick oven. And good lawd those cheese sticks talk about phenomenal-they was friggen HUGEEeee.

Food arrived completely wrong and the driver was a complete ass and still demanded a tip not only that but when I called the restaurant to explain the issue I got transferred to the owner who was of no help abd refused to do anything regarding it.