Pizza Man Wauwatosa
Pizza Man Wauwatosa
Up close, the other half of the meatball sandwich, looks good
a pizza on a plate
Deep dish
Da view
I think his name starts with a S, very friendly and a good face for the store
Da view
Nice place
pizza
oysters and mussels, drink
Razzberry Smash
Proof of my order.
The truffle frys
Behind those walls was a great hot lunch, side not it was a holiday weekend and may not be a typical experience not full
The meatball sandwich with truffle frys, great on my visit
Beautiful space
A real glass is always appreciated
We had two pizzas; cheese and sausage and cheese, onion and green pepper.
Milwaukee pizza
05/23
Burnt Pizza
Pizza Man Special
Gin Rickey
Valerie J.
Nov 10, 2024
I don't think I've ever had a bad experience at Pizza Man. I've attended both group functions (work holiday parties, etc.) and gone with friends. I appreciate both the pizza options (they're all good!), as well as the non-pizza menu items. There is a balsamic cauliflower dish that is amazing! The servers are always friendly and patient. I've had at least two recent visits where I've lingered at the table way too long, catching up with friends, and the servers never rushed us out. Top notch!
Read More
Audrey G.
Feb 27, 2025
Hmmmm.......You start to wonder about business when you see a rating of 3.2 out of 333 reviews. So I gave them a chance anyway since I heard that they closed other locations recently and changed the hours to this locationThe service was great since we arrived shortly after opening Food was okay and it always depends on who you have in the kitchen. Obviously it it was employees who was just going through the motions in my opinion Would I come back to this restaurant. Maybe since so many restaurants are doing a better job bringing people back since Covid has ended
Read More
Isabella K.
Dec 23, 2023
I've been to Pizza Man a number of times and never had a bad experience. Tonight was no exception. Our server Lucci was spectacular. They were attentive and friendly and quick to grab refills. For a Saturday night at 5:30, it wasn't too loud or busy. The food itself was delicious. I had the baked mac and cheese and it was creamy and savory. The bacon was a nice touch. The rest of my party split a Pizza Man Special, and they thought it was delicious. I'm giving Pizza Man four stars because it was nothing mind-blowingly extraordinary, but it was quite yummy.
Read More
Jessica J.
Sep 27, 2023
It's rare we make our way out to this area, so this was only my second time at this Pizza Man location. I'll say it's really well designed, with their rustic decor and open, airy concept. A really large restaurant. Kind of a bummer to see it so empty for the dinner hour. My husband, son and I came in and were quickly sat at a booth table. They brought over a highchair, kids menu and crayons - always appreciated! Right away we put in an order of mac n cheese for our son (who's always hungry so asap is best)! I'll say the kids mac is super tasty, like quality and flavorful cheese! However it's also very, very soupy, which can make it tough for a smaller kiddo to eat without lots of mess. Just something to note for the parents.Our server, though super sweet, wasn't the most attentive which seemed a little odd given how empty the restaurant was. My husband and I split a Hawaiian pizza and chopped salad. Both fantastic! They might have one of the best Hawaiian pizzas in town. I'm personally a huge fan of the big cream cheese dollops, plus their Canadian bacon is thick and in good quantity. I really like the thin crust here too. As for the salad, it's a big ol' mixture of greens, salami, garbanzo beans, various salty olives, smoked provolone, cucs, red onion, and tomato, all tossed in red wine vinaigrette. It's the kind of salad you could pair with any pizza really. But let me tell ya, a size small was plenty for two people to split (we had leftovers). I've always been a fan of the food & atmosphere at any Pizza Man location. Hope to see the place more bustling next time, because they deserve the business.
Read More
Liz F.
Jun 30, 2024
My food was served to me mainly burnt. It's interesting that the kitchen pulled this out and chose to serve it to me. Service is a struggle here. There may have been 7-10 tables occupied but it took 5-10 minutes of standing at the front to be seated. There was no one there. It's not staffed appropriately and I don't feel as though they excel at what they do. I know hiring is tough but never has it been more apparent than here.There is a lot of great pizza out there from Balistrari's to Pizzeria Scotty to Classic Slice or Ian's. For what pizza man is charging it's hard to recommend this to anyone.
Read More
Steven T.
May 29, 2023
I stopped here for the new restaurant of the week, actually it can be more than one, finally and I'm the last one to the party because I have shopped the mall and surrounding area since they opened. For a pizza restaurant it's done very well with a modern upscale feeling and it's beautiful with the wood, exposed brick upstairs, chandeliers and exposed hi ceilings. The view is not much from the window seats but it's still nice to have a view.The staff was all very nice and took good care of me. I was looking for a calzone but the lunch menu didn't list one which is no big deal because the meatball sandwich on garlic bread with truffle frys sounded way better than what I wanted. It was a holiday weekend and the place was not very full just as a note but all my food was hot/cooked to order and not warm from a heat lamp. I also want to thank them for seasoning all the food because I do a lot of restaurants and I'm sick of seasoning the food at my table.Let's start with the truffle frys that were hot and crisp with the truffle oil and grated cheese sprinkled on top, I don't know if the seasoning solely came from cheese alone but it works because seasoned potatoes are good. Next the meatball sandwich and once again hot with melty cheese and seasoned nicely. The bread was toasted panini's style with minimal marinara sauce so it's not a sloppy mess but that grated cheese looked like it was in it by the couple drips on my plate, regardless if that's where the seasoning is coming from it works well for me.Overall I was surprised at how good a sandwich and frys was from PM and fresh/hot to my table was much appreciated. Great job PM and well done with real glasses and cloth napkins is a nice touch.
Read More
Tempting R.
Jun 3, 2024
Would love to review the food. Unfortunately, that's not going to happen, because it never got that far.Stepped in to sample the cuisine as part of takeout service on the way home. The sign on the window is fairly clear about the entrance - but once inside, nobody was at the counter. There was a guy at the liquor taps who seemed disinterested and completely not engaged in the slightest. After standing there for about 3 minutes a different guy walked by and directed me to what is allegedly the takeout counter. Of course, there's no menu or anything there. So now I have to wait another 2 minutes - and the disiniterested guy wobbles over, clearly not excited to serve, and doesn't even offer a menu. When I asked for a menu he muttered something about some girl that was supposed to be somewhere (she wasn't) and handed me a paper menu, then went back to taps, never looking back in my direction to take my order.I walked out - since it was clear that they didn't want my money.
Read More
Megan C.
Jun 10, 2024
As a person who is very picky about pizza, I'm glad to say I have found a new favorite pizza place! The staff have been nothing but amazing, checking in and making sure we have everything we need.The appetizer options are great, having something for everyone, I recommend the eggplant fries, my son and anyone else I've had try them all love them. There are some new menu items, such as salmon with broccolini that are absolutely amazing. If you like pasta, my favorite is the fettuccine, but the others are just as good!I love the vibe in the restaurant as well, the wine bar is a nice size and the decor is cute. The women's bathrooms have stickers on the mirror that go in a circle saying "pizza made me do it" which is fun. I also love that they have big open windows in good weather.So all in all, 5/5 stars. Definitely recommend!
Read More
Kevin K.
Dec 31, 2024
Food very good the fettuccine Alfredo was so yummy. Our waiter was very friendly and positive. The one thing that could change is that they could have a little more space in the restaurant but over all great food. Look for more reviews coming in 2025
Read More
Brittany B.
Aug 1, 2024
Bbq chicken pizza is our family fav. First time having the chicken Marsala and we thoroughly enjoyed it.
Read More
