Pitch's

Came with a group to get the Supper Club experience. The service was pretty slow, the food decent, the prices sooo low! Bathrooms are a bit sketch.

Pitch's is an old-school supper club serving classic Italian dishes plus a nice assortment of meat and seafood options. There's also a full service bar, which makes great dirty martinis. The atmosphere is casual with a rather vintage decor, keeping the focus on the food. We ordered the Fried Calamari and Mozarella Marinara for starters. The Calamari was nicely breaded and crispy, and the mozarella pieces were large, lightly breaded, soft, and gooey. For dinner, we ordered the Deep Fried Shrimp, which was a little rubbery, and the Pork Chops Calabrese, which was very tender and flavorful. The side salad was made of a mixture of greens, the coleslaw was nice and crunchy but was lacking in tang, and the hashbrowns were good but very crunchy.Our waitress was friendly and enjoyed joking around with us, but she was a little slow and seemed distracted. Still, our food came out hot and overall timely.

I've walked past Pitch's so many times and it took way longer than it should have to stop in. This place has the classic Wisconsin supper club feel that is hard to replicate if you're not in the Northwoods. Every waiter is wearing a tie, and the waitresses are always super sweet and polite. Very classic looking bar in the front right when you stop in. I have never had to wait for a table, but I do usually come with reservations. Each time I come in I always get the chicken marsala, and I am happy to say it is my favorite in Milwaukee. The sauce is flavorful, plentiful and fresh, with loads of mushrooms and paired with a pasta side and bread. Can't go wrong with that!The drinks are very good, but sometimes it is hard to get another. I've had to ask for a refill just about each time I've gotten empty, when I would really expect the server to be more than happy to run to the bar and help me run up a healthy tab. Otherwise, no complaints. Given that their technical name does include ribs, I am happy to report that My friend stands behind them being the best he's had in Milwaukee.Definitely add it to your list.

I was on the hunt for a classic, affordable italian restaurant and Pitch's was exactly what i needed! The onion rings are super thin and delicious, I highly recommend. We had a half order and it was more than enough for two. I also had the ribs which were pretty good but the highlights for me were the bread and onion rings!

So The decor in pitch's supper club looks very nice and the restaurant is very quiet and the table and the staff are very nice. and I got onion rings and they were very good and salty. The bread tastes very good. For the main course I got the silicon stake and fries. I loved them both! and The music audio in the restaurant was songs by jazz players. Loved it!

Back home, there is a restaurant that we loved that served greasy and classic Italian food. It closed during COVID and ever since it closed we have been trying to find a place similar in Milwaukee. We tried Pitch's based on reviews and pictures, and it was exactly what we were looking for! It feels like you are stepping back in time when you walk into the dining area. The food is very well priced. We plan on going back whenever we feel a touch of nostalgia from home :)

This is such a classic Milwaukee supper spot! So charming, great food, super friendly staff, good service & not overpriced! What more could you want?Also had a parking lot which is unheard of in the city! I will definitely be back.

Love this place! Have been going there since I was a kid growing up in Milwaukee. Food is always tasty and the drinks that Jimmy makes are outstanding! Servers are awesome and are always friendly! Thank you Pitch's for always being my go to for a great fish fry too!

--consistently top notch food--friendly, gracious bar/wait staffI have been coming to this restaurant for DECADES. Every visit is nostalgic and increases my loyalty to return.

Excellent fish fry, incredible raison & Sciotino's Italian bread, delicious breaded asparigus appetizer & New England clam chowder, all with terrific & friendly service!!