Pirates Cove

Brought a group of 11 from Lake Geneva--kids were in a tournament and we were looking for a reasonably priced fish fry. This place came up in a search for fish and being spacious for a group. We get there & there are massive billboard-type Trump signs outside the place. The kids (17 & 18) take one look & tell us " no way". Two are black and one is gay---as one said, "I'm not just uncomfortable--I'm scared". Another said, "For us, it's sort of the opposite of a welcome sign". I felt terrible. Thank god we got in across the street at Lakelawn Lodge for a great meal & view...they accommodated all of us despite it being last min on a Friday. Im assuming the intention of the business IS to communicate they want only certain types of people so i wanted them to know its working.

Clearly this bar only wants the few regulars it has I walked in waited to order a drink bartender was busy then she told me it would be a minute that's fine... I go over and play a machine low and behold I hear a regular whining cause I started winning on the machines then the owner proceeds to come over and ask if I need anything by then I decided they don't welcome outsiders so I was gunna cash out and leave even though I've been there many times and spent a lot of $ there the owner told me just so you know if one of my regulars wants that machine you have to get off it they are spending money here you are not......i then had the conversation about how putting money in the machines is patronage to the bar and she said no it's not your not tipping the bartender.....btw I always tip the bartender even though I don't drink or just have a soda also the machines at this bar print a ticket that you take to a atm and it pays you so yea no work for the bartender there so I cashed out threw 2$ on the bar walked out while the bitchy owner screamed thanks for the tip" wow never been so uncomfortable in my life and never ever going there again and I thought this bar was so comfortable and nice atmosphere but that changed big time I do not recommend this place the waterfront down the road is much nicer

Cozy bar with lots of locals! My husband and I came here the other night after seeing a local horse show and we were sure glad we did. This place is visited by locals that are super sweet and welcoming. We had a blast talking with locals and telling them about our travels. We had an absolute blast! The staff here is great, and the bar food is delicious. Great place overall, we will visit again soon!

Met Jason for the first time! What a gentleman! Played Bingo won 2x's Sunday at six...... X-treme entertainment!! "TODAY I GOT THE CRABS!" Pretty good! Give it a try you won't be disappointed! I'm not family but it feels like it!JIMMIE PICKLES!

super friendly staff. super interesting interior. lots of spooky stuff, which i prefer. and the food was like a supper club with the salads and fish fry of course. blown away.

Stopped by this bar very late. Bears fans walking into a hole in the wall Packer bar. We we completely welcomed! Wish we would have found this place earlier! We wanted to buy the locals a shot and they ended up buying us one! Definitely coming back. Fun people, great local small bar feeling. Made me feel at home. Loved it!

Karaoke Night was the best night of our lives! Pirates Cove is truly a hidden gym! The staff, patrons, karaoke, random dogs, margaritas, slots....makes for the best well rounded experience on a Saturday night! John you have a great voice, keep on rocking friend! Thank you Pirates Cove!!!

In a nutshell, this place is average, at best. I'm from Wisconsin and love supper clubs, fish fries, and old fashioneds. I've lived in Delavan for more than 10 years, and have driven by the Pirates Cove hundreds of times. For the first several years, I thought it was permanently closed because the place looks a bit neglected. As newer reviews were being posted about this place having "great" food, I thought it was a hidden gem and perhaps the food would far surpass the building's rough looking exterior. When I walked in, I definitely felt out of place, and everyone seated at the bar turned to look at who was coming through the door. I really wanted to try the fish fry and have old fashioned, so I found a seat and ordered. The drink was fine, as it should be in Wisconsin. The fish was completely forgettable, and there was nothing "great" or unique about it that would warrant a glowing review. The bartenders were nice & the prices were good, but overall my visit was a bust. The most exciting part about the experience was the thought that a fantastic or fun dining experience was hiding inside this unassuming building. It's not.

Awesome atmosphere, can't get much of a better ambiance for a dive type of bar. Good drinks, beer on tap. Food was great and extremely reasonable on price. Service was fantastic as well!

When we moved to Delavan, Pirate's Cove was the first place we tried. It was a happy accident. Their food was excellent, their waitresses (no waiters were ever encountered) were calm and efficient and friendly, and we felt we were at home. Their fish fry is especially recommended, and their potato pancakes are wonderful -- but do ask for sour cream with them, especially if you're Polish like my wife. Their burgers are tasty, and if you happen upon them on Sunday, their chicken dinners are like a home-cooked meal -- if your mother was a good cook who enjoyed making it.Man, this is like being back home, if you had a really good home.