Peabody's Pizza Company
Peabody's Pizza Company
Medium Supreme
Wow. Peabody's really goes the extra mile with their cold and soggy French fries. It's a good thing I got a very very small portion.
Small pizza
Mozzarella Egg Roll Sticks
a slice of pizza
Lisa H.
Sep 24, 2022
Excellent pizza place for delivery. Regular pizzas, specialty like blt, and taco which are our favorites. Cheesy garlic bread is delicious too. Lots of toppings, never skimpy. Delivery is fast.
Read More
Sarah K.
Aug 21, 2022
Our food was cold and flavorless. We ordered a taco sub and the toppings didn't even fill the whole length of the sub bun and was considered to be somewhat tasty compared to the rest of the items after loading taco sauce on it. The garlic dippers were cold and hard while the pizza was lukewarm. Disappointed for sure.
Read More
Sara T.
Aug 9, 2020
Wow great pizza! We were just traveling through for a night and got in a little late so most places had stopped serving food...we called about 30 mins before closing...the guy that answered could not have been more friendly. We ordered a supreme well done. Wow was it good! We had a few pieces left over and even the next day heated up on the grill - very, very good. Try this place. We absolutely will next time we are in town.
Read More
Jill O.
Aug 15, 2015
Peabody's is a consistently decent pizza. It's my go-to delivery when I'm in the Sheboygan areas.The delivery is always super fast, it's rare that it takes more than twenty minutes for our food to arrive. We usually order a large pepperoni with olives, and it's always well cooked and piping hot at our door. We also really like the Taco Pizza, which has taco meat, sour cream, and Doritos among other toppings, and the BLT pizza. Both are $18.99 for a large.We also are sure to get some appetizers. Their garlic bread with cheese ($2.99) is always solid. Our must-have is the Mozzarella Egg Roll Sticks ($5.99), which are mozzarella sticks but in a wonton wrapper instead of a normal breading. If you can't decide, you can get a sampler for $10.99 that includes Mozzarella Sticks, Mozzarella Egg Roll Sticks, Cheddar Cheese Nuggets, Chicken Strips, and French Fries. The only bummer is that most days they close at 10. When I'm craving a cheap assortment of fried and cheesy foods, I assure you it's usually after that time slot!
Read More
Nathan F.
Jun 14, 2020
Walked by and smelled pizza baking. We weren't even super hungry. Stopped in and split a small pizza. Great sauce and crust. Fresh ingredients. Price was right. We'll be back.
Read More
Jonelle S.
Sep 15, 2020
Love their BLT pizza, family loves the taco pizza. Their hot subs are delicious. The staff is very friendly and they have a bunch of different stuff to choose from with salads and appetizers. Would definitely recommend!
Read More
Bethanny R.
Jun 16, 2017
I've ordered Peabody's a few times and I'm usually satisfied. Not today. The pizza was cold and the quality is terrible. The crust is hard and chewy. I could get better from the frozen section. The fries were cold and undercooked. Considering how gross they are its a good thing I only got a few of them. I think next time I want pizza I'll spend my money elsewhere
Read More
Tim R.
May 12, 2024
I love pizza Peabodys is the place to go. I never been there and I ordered the Meat Head pizza with extra sausage. Boy did I get sausage lol. There was a lot it covered the whole pizza just the way I like it. Server was great very friendly. I will be going back again very soon.sorry I didn't take a picture because it would have shown how good it was.
Read More
Enjoli J.
Jun 19, 2023
The food is decent, it's the creepy lady that gives me "Karen vibes! Every time I order from there, it's a issue or something racially strange that happens. I won't go into details but I hope you see this message and analyze and approve yourself with customer service towards your black customers. It's 2023! You can't judge us all by the same book!
Read More
Josh A.
Aug 7, 2020
Refusing to wear masks. Unbelievable. When I asked them about it, the response was, we're not worried about it. Disgusting
Read More
