Park Avenue Pizza Company Pub & Restaurant

Had a Company President Large with Garlic Bread . Highly recommended. Great sauce . Terrific service. Lisa Z . Was great . Around enough but not too much . I will definitely be back next time visiting.

I called for a takeout this evening and went through the entire ordering process and then they took my credit card process and asked for my address. I was outside their delivery area (Hartland vs Peewaukee). Start the process with where do you live before charging my credit card. I WILL NOT refer anyone to this business albeit it's only 3.6 miles away..Terrible customer service and business process.

I'm not sure why this place isn't rated higher. I love the old movie theme and all of the posters and tchotchkes on the walls. The pizza was very good. Not that most in WI would know but it tasted very similar to one of multiple favorite pizzas out of Dayton OH called Marian's Piazza. The service was very friendly. When I visit WI I will be back.

Very, very good GF pizza. It came highly recommended from someone who knew we were Celiac. I will be back . . . but the ambience is somewhat lacking. Go for the food ... but it is basically a room with no windows.

Came in, sat at bar, and I'm only one at bar. 2 people sitting at table in bar area. Table of 7 in restaurant. And they seated 2 more 3 workers coming and going behind bar. I asked 2x for menu. Asked to place my order, they said just a minute. They seated the other people, 15 minutes after I asked to place my order i left. No wonder nobody was in there. I went to Billy ho,s next door, great service and food thereI used to love park avenue 20 years ago. Not anymore.

Stopped in today for lunch with my wife. Haven't been here in years. Was very surprised how well things looked. I had the anti pasta salad and my wife had the BBQ chicken pizza. They were great. Will be a new stop on our lunch and dinner favorites.

In the never ending quest for the perfect pie, we tried Park Avenue Pizza Company recently. This is an easy-to-access restaurant with sufficient parking in a lot next to the restaurant. We started with the beer battered mushrooms. These were delicious with a light, crispy coating. This is a very generous order - my husband only had a few and left the bulk of the order for me and I was quite full just finishing these. We opted for the Company President pizza. This is good pizza with no shortage of toppings. We were quite happy with our choice. The building this restaurant is in is an old movie theater and the decor capitalizes on that theme. It was fun to look at various items while we waited for our food. We felt the prices were fair and we'll happily go back someday.

Pizza was great. Service was a little slow. Used a Groupon coupon. Ambiance was good. Not like a fast food restaurant.

In these times, it's incredibly hard to get good help and many places are working short-staffed. I've read many of the reviews and found a common theme to be a long wait and rude wait staff.I was there at the end of May 2024 around 4:45pm, and was immediately seated. There was a bit of a wait for the waiter to appear, once he did we immediately ordered. We ordered a small pizza, cheese garlic bread and blue gill. Everything is hand prepared and that takes time. The waiter was attentive as he could be considering that he was also serving at the bar. The pizza was very good. So was the blue-gill. The pizza is very similar to Ned's Pizza in Milwaukee. We got out of there at about 6:10pmWill I be back. Yep. Not a once and done place.

Park Avenue Pizza truly is the best pizza in Pewaukee! A great family run business with great food and staff. If you're looking for a cool place to take the family, meet up with friends, or a cozy spot to relax this is it. I recommend this place for dine-in, carryout, or delivery! Fabulous pizzas, made to order chicken, pastas, and apps! Come try what you've been missing!