Out & Out

This place is a great choice when you don't have time to sit down but want something delicious and fast. The food is excellent, the service was fabulous, and I love that they have seating inside and out - but also super easy to take and go if you need to. My go-to is the thai peanut quinoa salad - yummy!! I would definitely recommend choosing Out & Out!

On my list to try for quite awhile and wish it hadn't taken so long to get here! Came with my 7yr old for lunch on a Wednesday and it was busy, and now I know why. She had the original mac and cheese and loved it, and she's a picky Mac n cheese eater. I tried a few bites as well and it was great, way better than Noodles and Co. and cheaper than Noodles as well. I had the Chipotle Chicken sandwich and it was excellent. We had some custard for dessert and it was also terrific, only $3.75 for a scoop and you get 3 toppings! Service was extra friendly, seems like a family and treat you like family, the kind of place I like to spend my money at, but don't need to spend a lot because for the quality and quantity of food, it was very reasonable. I look forward to coming back soon with the entire family to try more, great spot!

Leaving Strawberry Fest today I promised ice cream to my son that came with me because it was hot out and he was a trooper with all the walking around we did. We started driving towards the McDonald's in Cedarburg, but along the way I remembered previously seeing a different restaurant nearby that serves ice cream or custard. We pulled into Out & Out and hit the jackpot compared to going to McDonald's. It was so good, in fact, that we came back later in the day so my wife and other son could try it too. On our first visit my older son got a custard mixer with brownies, Oreos, and hot fudge and I got a half original mac and cheese and a strawberry lemonade float, which was their special flavor for this week. When we came back, my younger son got a chocolate custard mixer with cookie dough and brownies while my wife got the Spicy Chicken Kick mac and cheese without the red peppers.Both kids loved their custard, which was to be expected. It looks like they're pretty generous with the toppings and have a good variety to choose from on the menu. Way better than the soft serve ice cream from McDonald's.The mac and cheese was great. We both thought the cheese sauce reminded us a little of Kraft mac and cheese, but slightly more elevated in both the flavor of the sauce and the quality of the noodles. There was plenty of chicken in her mac, but it was little light on the andouille sausage.The strawberry lemonade float was otherworldly good. I've had other floats before like root beer and dreamcicle, but strawberry lemonade was a new one for me and frankly has set a new bar in my mind for ice cream/custard based drinks. I can't rave about it enough and I'm sad that it's only a one week special, but considering how good it was, I'm very much looking forward to trying other special flavors they have and having the strawberry lemonade again, assuming it's back during next year's Strawberry Fest.

I love Mac n cheese! To be completely transparent, I'm a Kraft kind of gal, and don't always like when the dish is jazzed up too much. So I went in not sure what to expect. Well, I thought this was amazing! I loved every bite of the original, just as it was. My husband had the spicy chicken (minus the bell peppers) and he was raving about his too. The staff was helpful explaining the options and it was a nice casual dining experience. I highly recommend this spot!

I am very disappointed because this has been one of my family's favorite Mac n' Cheese spots. We ordered two Spicy Chicken Kick Macs today and they both had little to no cheese sauce.. Let's just say plain noodles really kills the mood. I've also read other reviews on this restaurant recently and most seem to agree. When I order Mac n' Cheese, I don't expect to pay extra for enough cheese sauce to cover my food.

Yummy! Great spot to sit outside with a great sandwich and shake !The mac n cheese is the bomb and perfect for sharing.

Out and out is always a family favorite. Their Mac and cheese (no matter which you choose) is always amazing. For a healthier option the Thai quinoa salad is amazing! So fresh!Service is always great. It's not really "fast" food so be prepared to wait 10min for your food.

I had the turkey sandwich which was just outstanding and so flavorful. My sister had the Cuban and a mint shake. Both were excellent. I would highly recommend this place.

It was such a cold day and this place just made all better. Warm delicious mac'n cheeses and hot subs, Nice industrial vibe decoration . Service super fast and friendly.

We are very disappointed in Out and Out for the second time. The Mac and Cheese was dry and the container is now less than 1/3 the original size. It is so small now that it looks like a small plate instead of a bowl at barely 1" tall. My chicken, bacon ranch wrap had no bacon. It is so sad to see the downfall of one of Cedarburg's most popular restaurants. Now that it is employee-owned, the staff/owners have decided to get greedy and cut the quality, flavor and container size to put more money in their pockets. What a shame.