Oscar's Frozen Custard

Food and service exceeded expectations I visited during Friday lunch. The staff were busting their humps working feverishly. There was noone in line in front of me and it took a while to be attended to but the cashier was knowledgeable and pleasant. Order was fulfilled much quicker than expected Grilled chicken sandwich bigger than expected. Bun lettuce tomato fresh. Only critique is too much mayo. Next time I will request EZ mayoChocolate malt hit the spot. Creamy flavorful. Size was perfect

I've been going to Oscar's for at least thirty years. The quality of the custard and food has always been excellent. The burgers are flame broiled and delicious. A friend of mine had a heart attack and was craving a burger, so he asked his cardiologist if he could get one. The doctor said the only place he would okay was Oscar's because they use a lean sirloin patty. My favorite sandwich is the fish, it includes pickles, tarter sauce, lettuce and cheese. It's always nice white fish with a crunchy breading. The custard is excellent, and the sundaes are great. They have a monthly special sandwich, sundae and shake. Lastly, the prices here are actually right on the money. I recently had the monthly special sundae at another custard stand in the Milwaukee area, and it was nearly $13 Oscar's is half that price.

It's always busy but the lines go really fast. Everyone is always coming in for custard and it does not disappoint. My favorite is their strawberry shortcake.

Every time we visit family in Wisconsin we have to get Oscar's at some point. This frozen custard is royalty amongst all frozen custard. It is so light and super creamy. The homemade waffle cones are wonderful with any flavor. Each day has a different Flavor of the Day custard. If you were also hungry I would suggest keeping it simple with a cheeseburger or grilled cheese for the vegetarians. Their cheese fries are a must and if you are an onion ring fan I highly recommend getting an order as well. You really can't go wrong here!

The custard is not too sweet, which is an issue we find with most if the chains like Kopp's. The mushroom Swiss burger was tasty and the mushrooms were lightly sauced, which was a nice surprise. The fries were hit and fresh. Plenty of seating, plenty of parking. Seating outdoors, too.

Went today to get ice cream.got a large cup and it had these 3 small balls of ice cream. Payed 4 something for it they are riping people off . My friend got a small cup and got more than I did

This place has some very poor customer service. The kids that work there don't know how to take orders or even prep food. As for a chicken sandwich with no mayo. I'm allergic to ingredients in Mayo got home covered in mayo. I was so disgusted decided to not go back. Just going to boycott them. Another one for the books

I have been thinking about the Peanut Butter Cup sundae from Oscar's for, well, longer than I care to admit. I dated a guy that lived in the area (more years ago than I care to admit) and we would hit this spot up fairly regularly. But I don't have much reason to get over to this side of town so Oscar's and their great food had faded into the recesses of my memory until I heard that vaccinated folks were able to score a free Krispy Kreme, and the only KK outlet in Wisconsin happens to be just down the street! But I digress.Despite the many years being away from Oscar's, it did not disappoint! The sundae was just as peanut buttery as I remembered it to be. And luck of all lucks, the burger of the month was that bastion of the few times we dined out during my childhood, the pizzaburger! The combination of these two items really brought me back decades, in a very positive way.The only reservation I have here from going with five stars is the clumsy process for ordering and waiting for your food. There just isn't enough room to do it properly and while I appreciate the rope line, it isn't effective and they should pursue some other solutions in place of their current setup.

Walked in to order, everyone talking to each other. Sat down to see if someone would acknowledge me, went back to the counter and said I was waiting for help. The young guy that claimed to be the manager was beyond hostile, snarky and insulted and misgendered me. I was beyond angry and left when the guy got more awful. I called back to get his name, he refused to give it. At the counter he told me he owned the store, but I have met the owners , not them. So he was completely combative and nasty. This was a horrible experience, i was told after the fire to try this location, I used to go there decades hy 18. This manager was just attacking my gender and clothing and thinking it was funny to provoke a customer. The owners need to follow up on this incident.

I always called and place an order for 12 sandwiches and they made it up but today when I called they wouldn't make it up because they thought it was a prank I'm so mad at the manager there he told the crew not to make it up because it was a prank call and I was there to pick up my sandwich and it wasn't my 12 sandwich and it wasn't ready to BLT sandwiches and he said he worked there for 7 years and never got a called like that before that's why he wouldn't make the 12 sandwiches until I got there I said I told him that I ordered couple times it before and they made it but he said he he's the manager and it never was like that before I told him he didn't know what he's talking about because they made it before for me so I'm giving that manager a one star today so they made a couple sandwich like s*** they overstuffed it where it was just coming apart