Old Fashioned Food

Check out The Cheese Cave, it is just unbelievable. I have visited several cheese shops in Wisconsin but this is by far the best. Over 300 varieties of cheese, surrounding you on shelves from floor to ceiling, that's The Cheese Cave. A cheese lover's dream!Unlike the touristy cheese shops, this place has very reasonable prices. And the cheese varieties on sale cans beyond reasonable, and grouped together on a long table in the middle of the cave.Also unlike the touristy cheese shops, the employees here are friendly, helpful and extremely knowledgeable. You can learn a lot about cheese on your visit here.I like spicy cheeses, and I found varieties of cheese with hatch peppers, sriracha, chipotle, jalapeño, and ghost pepper. I ended up purchasing four different cheeses but I found dozens that I would like to try. If I lived anywhere near this place I would be stopping by every week to buy a few new varieties.A very enjoyable experience!

Consider coming to this cheese store if your in town. Of the things to do in Wisconsin finding a good place to buy cheese is key.Like other cheese stores, this one has a great variety. Down a slight ramp and through a glass door there is about a 15x10 room filled with Gouda goodness. Cons about this place is there isn't a private parking lot.However, there is ample 10 minute public parking which is more than enough to get in, get cheese, and get going. Each cheese was clearly labeled and priced. Every employee was friendly and helpful. Sale priced items were put on a chalkboard outside the cheese room. Everyone in my group enjoyed looking at the selection, from curds to hard cheeses. Right off the front entrance there was a room that appeared to have samples but I didn't try any. Obviously they had more than cheese including wine and cheese themed knickknacks. Open until 6 on Saturday's to get your cheese fix. Make sure you stop by because who doesn't need more cheese in their life. TL/DR: Read the first letter of every sentence for a key take away message.

Old fashioned cheese tasting was awesome!!I got some Wisconsin labeled goods and postcards.Try the chocolate fudge cheese!

I have not had the please of visiting this venue, but I received cheese from there and it is outstanding. I live over an hour away, but if the weather holds out I am going to visit. The people I spoke with and the owner r fantastic. Thank you so muchDarla Brown

This is the best cheese shop ever. I'm from WI and am no stranger to cheese shops :) This place is incredible because:1. The selection. My goodness the selection. They have all the standards and many things I had never heard of. They even had a blue cheese that I looked everywhere for and pander. 2. All cheese is cut to serve. You only want approx 1/4 pound? That's cool! 3. The cheese they do have cut is in a variety of sizes. With only two people in my house, I don't need to get 1lb of every cheese I want to try. 4. They even offered to try to obtain any cheeses we wanted that they didn't have (but honestly, with the selection, it's not necessary)4. The family who owns it is super friendly. It was a fun shopping experience. Although this is an hour from my house, I would definitely make the trip out there!

Love doing tastings there especially with addition of more wines. Staff is sooooo friendly and knowledgeable to help to choose the best cheese for my specific need. When entertaining while on frequent vacations I can always count a box of great cheeses to be just a day away. Great shipping. Have friends in several states that now use "Old Fashioned Cheese" in Mayville Wi.