Oakfire

I recall being on the beach a couple of July's ago with a large group and looking across the street asking "What's the place with all the people? Let's go there."Turns out it was Oakfire. And while the majority of my group headed home from the beach not to return, I somehow ended up somewhere else in town after my post-beach shower/reset. So when I returned to Lake Geneva this spring for a work event, visiting Oakfire was top of mind.So on an early May weekday I had lunch here with a friend. We were sat outside promptly and for this I was thankful. A couple of weeks later when prime tourist season hits and it would be like it had been that July I am sure. So be warned, timing is everything here. A wait should be expected if its summer season.I had not seen the words "pepperoni cups" prior to perusing the Oakfire Pizza menu. I am a red sauce trad pep pizza kind of gal and a fan of the wood fire style. The pepperoni curls up a bit around the edge - who knew pepperoni could have new things done to it? It was lunch and I am a small amount of food at one time eater so I had leftovers. After a drive back to my home city and time in the car while I went to the gym, I reheated this pizza and finished it for dinner. Yeah its that good that I took a risk. No I did not get sick. I finished.This is my must go to spot for any and all future returns to Lake Geneva!

The restaurant has a good vibe as we walked in to the place. The restaurant is strategically located in front of Lake Geneva with a great view of the lake. Instead of being seated inside right away, we opted to wait for a table in the patio for a better view of the lake whole dining. I wanted to sit at the second floor balcony, but the restaurant host told us second floor wasn't open today. This took about 20 minutes or so but we didn't mind since we weren't hungry. The Verace pizza came out really quick and kinda cold... Even before the beers. I think there must have been a mix-up of some sort. I'm thinking it might have been another table's cancelled order or something. If that wasn't the case it something like it, the pizza couldn't be cold like that and wouldn't have been ready even before they brought out drinks. I had to ask what was happening with our drinks and it took almost 20 minutes to get out beers from tap. A little while later, the Bosco pizza was served nice and warm and very tasty. I would definitely order the Bosco if I was eating here again.Except for the mishap with the first pizza being a bit cold and the beers from the tap taking so long to get served, we had a great time talking and enjoying the view even though it was getting dark so we couldn't see much of the lake. The lights reflecting on the lake from the other side were pretty as well. I would probably come back to this place just because of the location and the food and service isn't bad.

Tried out Oakfire and I enjoyed myself but I will say be prepared to pay a hefty price for what you could essentially get from like places like MOD, pros, blaze etc. When I arrived I was greeted by the hostess and was seated near the open window which overlooks the lake. They have patio and upstairs seating also.My server was very attentive and made sure to tell be before ordering my pizza what to expect. It's woodfire and some pieces may be more charred but the dough is still very pliable after cooked. I ordered the meatballs as an appetizer and my goodness I would come back just for that. I ordered a drink The Queen, it was tasty. For the pizza, I got the classica Bianca. It is a white sauce based pizza with a honey drizzle. I decide to grab dessert to go but in all honesty could have skipped it. I got the apple crumb cheesecake with ice cream. It was nit worth the price. I love a good piece of cheesecake but the flavors weren't quite there. Overall a good experience.

Came here with a few friends. Started with the spinach & ricotta arancini which was very flavorful. The sauce tasted fresh and even though they were fried, they weren't greasy. I thought the portion could have been bigger for what they charged. We also got the special of the day pizza which isn't on the menu, but everything was great there as well. Service could have been better as we waited multiple times for our waitress. Our pizza also came out 15 minutes after the rest of our table was served which was kind of annoying. The atmosphere can be loud around lunch time but it kind of fits the vibe.

When we went there was a 25min wait. There's a patio to wait at with fire pit tables. The food was pretty good I had a Cesar salad and my wife had Margherita pizza. Our friends we came with had their pizza take about 15 mins longer than the rest of our food which is why I gave 4 stars not 5. Might stop here again in the summer if I come back to Lake Geneva.

This is a really great pizza spot. I would rate the pizza five stars. Unfortunately the cocktails were not very great. If you order a cocktail here, I would recommend getting something standard. I did not like their seasonal drink options and I tried multiple. The service was was average and it depended on how busy it was. Overall, we still had a good time and ordered a variety of food. The cheese curds and pizza were really stand out. The calamari was just OK. Overall, this place is very casual. It gets busy, especially when you go for their trivia night. This is a good place to stop by for pizza with the family or to pick up pizza for yourself as well. This is one of the best woodfired pizzas I've had in a long time.

Solid pizza with a view! Our server was super kind and guided us to make delicious choices. The pizza was a little floppier than I would have liked but the taste made up for the texture.

We went on Labor Day so we're prepared for a wait. But, gave us a buzzer and had us seated within 20 minutes. Sat at bar while we waited, and had a glass of wine, and kids had a soft drink (free refills)Ordered an app, and two pizzas for the four of us. LOVE that they give kiddos a piece of dough to play around with while you wait for food. So much more fun than crayons!Service was exceptional, and views are UNMATCHED!

Pizza is delicious! Softest thin crust, and service was delightful and ambiance relaxing.

The restaurant is located right on the lake so if you are willing to wait, you can get a good seat upstairs. We stopped in for a quick bite to eat before heading to a concert that we were attending at Alpine Valley. We ordered the classic margarita and Bella pizza. Pizza was coal fired so it had a fluffy crust with a very thin droopy center. The toppings were falling off as soon as we picked a piece up so it was hard to eat. It was good, but we found ourselves using forks to eat our pizzas.Service was good and it was reasonably priced.