North Shore Pizza And Subs

Not good at all, couldn't even manage to get a single thing correct in the entire order. The pizza wasn't even cooked all the way and wasn't even the correct pizza. I asked for ranch and instead got blue cheese. The fries also weren't even cooked all the way and then someone genius thought it was a bright idea to stick a container with a press on lid inside the aluminum foil then wrapped the fries in like a burrito.... So they were all smashed, soggy and soaked in the exploded sauce. This place is a complete waste of time, it's shocking how an established restaurant can't even manage to get one single item correct in an order. It's almost like all the good reviews are lies they paid for and not honest reviews

Will be back to have another sub here. Cold Italian was my first try, and it has me piqued in what other tasty food I can devour. This is some quality sammich materials being used here. Bread is perfectly soft, yet bitable. The salami and bologna were fatty and salty. All the fixings (I recommend) bring this up to be an above average experience at a wonderful price. Literally, the large is a 16 inch sub for like $11!? Fantastic. Looking forward to coming back for something else.

Great sauce! Good people and good prices! Yummy!!Meatball Hero is my go to but I love the pizza, too.

First time at this small joint. Called ahead for pickup and ordered the Steak Special (cheese, mushrooms, onions n pepper) and opted in for the 'large' 12in. They definitely packed the full 12"! I wish there would've been more cheese otherwise every bite contained all the special. Also got a side of fries, not sure if it was already packed n waiting but it was soggy. Saved the second half for lunch the next day. I'd definitely be back!

First time trying north shore pizza. The lady helping us was very nice and luckily we they were not to busy while we decided what we wanted. Pizza had a lot of good toppings ect for the price

Hands down best pizza in the Madison area. Got a classic cheese pie, definitely authentic New York style. Sauce was fresh, from scratch and delicious. Crust was light, had the perfect chew and some nice crunchy spots. Cheese melty, bubbly, and not greasy. Accidentally inhaled 4 slices on the way home . In addition, it felt like a nice and chill neighborhood spot. Plus, it has a dope arcade! Would highly recommend for anyone looking for that NY style.

Give them a little time.That was the general sentiment from the 14/16 year old employees that were working tonight. They were sweet and knowledgeable but unprepared for a steady stream of customers on a Friday night.No fountain machine. You can purchase bottled sodas for $2.50 each. They don't have an alcohol license yet so no beer and no BYOB. No water dispenser, the staff (half) filled plastic cups from a bartender's sink. You can't bring drinks in the arcade area, which felt like it was 90 degrees in a tightly packed nook past the dining area.We ordered the grilled chicken salad, mozzarella sticks, onion rings, a large fajita pizza. The salad arrived as torn pieces of iceberg lettuce, shaved carrots, onions, tomatoes and blackened chicken chunks in a plastic takeaway box. The mozzarella sticks and onion rings were unremarkable with the latter served without a dipping sauce, likely from the folks at SYSCO. The pizza was the star here with generous toppings sprinkled throughout the large pie, but the middle portion appeared undercooked and mushy.The arcade is on the pricier side with most of the games costing a dollar to play. It is my understanding they have only been open for 2 months so maybe give them some time to work out the kinks and we will return.

We decided to give this place a try, had heard enough buzz about it to peak our curiosity. It's a clean, brightly lit place, ample seating and an arcade in the back. The person taking our order was polite and quick, informed us it would be about 30 minutes until our pizzas were ready and she was right. We ordered 2-16" pizzas, sausage and black olives. The crust is really good, just the right balance of chew and crispness. There definitely could have been more sauce on both pizzas. The sausage pizza was a bit greasy, but good. Sausage itself was good, but a little sparse. Black olive pizza was good, less greasy. Pizza is obviously a saltier food in general, but these seemed a bit saltier than most. There is room for improvement, in my opinion. But don't rule them out, definitely give them a try.

We are Monona residents so wanted to try the new local place. I want to try the pizza, but we got 2 sandwiches instead- the veal and the chicken bomb. There are no online descriptions of what is in them, or what size the small vs large is, but I guess one can figure it out. The sandwiches are large and filling and tasty! We also got a side of fries (delicious) and jalapeño poppers (lackluster & need a sauce).But because of the arcade, we'll be back. I would assume if they sold beer, North Shore would do a bit more business but as of now, they do not.

Love this place. Really tasty old school pizza. Calzones are excellent. Great prices and you can play a few retro arcade games while you're waiting for your food.