Nite Cap Inn

Came back and got the walleye this time and it was excellent. Some of the best fried fish I've ever had. The potato pancakes are also delicious. This is an odd restaurant in that you must initially sit at the bar where you order and wait for your table/food. Once you are seated your food is waiting for you. I can't say I've ever seen a restaurant operate quite this way but it works for me. I've noticed some people complain in the reviews and I think it's unjustified. My only complaint is that they aren't open more often and that they are too darn popular on Fridays.

The best Friday Fish Fry in Southern Wisconsin since the mid to late 60's. Best Potato Pancakes ever.

Fish fry fabulous but waiting over an hour when there were tables available is not cool especially when there is no decent wine. We said we were leaving and then suddenly they were able to seat us. This is a long time practice and it keeps me away.

We went for the Friday fish fry and knew we would have to wait. We even arrived before 5! We each had two drinks at the bar and they were delicious and reasonable. When we arrived they took our name and placed our order. We probably waited over an hour which is ok. What we did not like was being seated to have our food sitting on the table already. After waiting over an hour to eat we felt very rushed I'm sure they wanted to turn tables over as fast as possible but did not care for this type of service. We might go back but not for the fish fry.

Fish fry is great. We always get it to go. Hope to try in person sometime and try out the drink specials. It's a classic Wisconsin supper club.

Some of the best potato pancakes and fish fry in the area. Make sure you stop in early on a Friday to get a table! While you wait for your table make sure to go to the bar and have an old-fashioned

Haven't been here in awhile, and am glad to say everything was excellent!!! Best fish, potato pancakes, and all the sides. Had a slice of salted caramel cheesecake and it was to die for. Service was excellent, reorders were hot and served in record time. Glad we got there early, when we were leaving there were no seats at the bar and people were starting to wait outside. So happy nothing has changed, best fish fry around!!!

We have loved this place for several years now. It's an old fashioned Wisconsin supper club. You order when you walk in. Then you wait at the bar enjoying homemade bloody Mary's, old fashioned or manhattan. The hostess finds you at the bar, takes you to your table, and the food is there already. The fish fry is real good, the fried chicken is even better. The German fare is like grandma used to make. Plan on being at the bar for about an hour - so pace yourself on the drinks!!

I've been going to the Nite Cap Inn for almost 50 years. Still WITHOUT EXCEPTION the best Fish Fry with potato pancakes anywhere. A real slice of Wisconsin Americana. It's worth the drive to the little town of Palmyra. Don't expect to be wowed by anything but the food and people. All that's changed in the place since the 70's is they now have a color TV.

Great little place, supper club atmosphere. This family owned place serves one of the best fish fry's and German dinners (on Saturday) that I have had in a while. Mom is in the back cooking and daughter at the bar so be patient enjoy a great old fashioned and when it's time to sit down be ready to enjoy. Portions are just right and save room for the Schram Torte.