Nicos Pizza

I had this place on my list of places to try as it has been consistently featured on my Milwaukee Foodie group in Facebook. I am SO GLAD I asked friends to meet here--it was awesome food!We sat at a big bar and the bartender was friendly. We got garlic bread with cheese and then two pizzas---I have nothing bad or constructive to say about either--both were so darn good! Great amount of cheese and toppings. The next time I'm in West Allis, I'm absolutely getting pizza here..

Ordered the Sharp Dressed Man pizza to go. Their homemade sausage is the best sausage I've ever had on a pizza. I loved the sauce as well - it's very well-seasoned. Definitely a unique and delicious pub pizza to try!

This place is just lovely. I went there with my husband and in-laws on a busy Sunday. We were sat immediately, and our server was great. We ordered a 14" cheese pizza, a 14" sausage, pepperoni and onion pizza, some cheesy garlic bread and a basket of fries. Our appetizers came out pretty quickly and were delicious. The pizza came out shortly after we were finished with the appetizers and was also great. The crust was thin and crispy and the toppings were great on both pizzas. The pepperoni, sausage and onions were quite large, so don't expect small toppings. The pepperoni was sliced nice and thin as well, which was a perfect compliment to the pizza. All in all, the experience was lovely and we definitely plan to return.

First time trying out Nico's Pizza. We haven't been to this location since it was a Shakey's many years ago. The atmosphere was very nice and it was not very crowded for a Friday night. I liked the vibe of this place. Music was at perfect level where you could have a conversation without yelling. Very nice lighting and felt very inviting. Tylissa, our server was very friendly and attentive. I was happy to see that they had multiple 3 Floyds craft beer on tap!! We tried the mozzarella medallions for our appetizer and they were amazing! They were lightly breaded and drizzled with balsamic oil, fresh cherry tomatoes and basil and so delicious! We also had the Classic pizza which was loaded with HUGE pieces of sausage, fresh mushrooms and red onions. The sauce was very tasty and the thin crust was perfectly baked. I think I found my favorite pizza place in Milwaukee. Definitely try this place out for your next date night!

Visited Nico's for the first time today. A friend raved about their Oconomowoc location, so I was looking forward to trying them. I bought one of their frozen pizzas at Metcalfe's Market for $16 and was disappointed.Today's experience at their new West Allis location, in the former Crawdaddy's and Shakey's space, was a great experience! I ordered the 12" Classic, which is topped with BIG chunks of Italian Sausage, red onions, and fresh mushrooms, and I added pepperoni.The first thing I noticed was how thick the pizza was with cheese and toppings. Then I picked up a slice and was surprised by how well the crispy, Tavern Cut, slice held the heavy toppings. This was true of the center slices, as well. Super thin crust that doesn't flop or get soft in the center! That speaks to the quality of the ingredients, how well the pizza dough is made, and the temperature of the oven.The pizza tasted great, and I will be back. It may already be in my top 5 favorite thin crust pizzas in Milwaukee.

This was our first time at Nico's and we'll definitely be back. Killer pie. The pizza was outstanding. Thin, crispy crust. A well balanced sauce (not too sweet and not too savory--just right). Vinny's sausage is always a win for us, it's the best and the rest of our toppings: pepperoni, onion, black olives- all held their own as well. I have to admit we had a small issue with our order and a staff shift change that was taking place. Totally get it, sometimes these things happen...But you know what? They went out of their way to acknowledge it and make up for it. Honestly, it was so refreshing. Class act. And we will be back to try other things on the menu. There are some buffalo chicken thighs that are just waiting for me.

First time here. I honestly did not know what to expect. Absolutely fantastic!!! You can tell when a place uses a fresh ingredients. Nico's absolutely does. This is some of the best pizza in the city without a doubt.

I came back for the intriguing boneless buffalo chicken thighs and an adult cocktail as restaurant of the week and I must stress that they are new in the soft opening phase and because they are very new the full menu is not available but a limited one is on and mainly consist of pizzas.I ordered the spicy Bloody Mary which came in a frosted mug which I just love love with a basic fresh garnish, see my picture. The Bloody Mary was just average but good and not the craft kind but what you usually get around town.The buffalo chicken thighs had a good presentation and clearly not frozen bar food and more like something I would make in my kitchen I noticed. My first bite was yah this isn't frozen crap with a crispy coating and moist dark meat which is definitely different and very good. My only disappointment was the blue cheese dipping sauce because it seemed commercial generic and a chunky version like some places serve would have matched better, don't put all the effort in the chicken and serve a week dipping sauce.

First time there. Pizza was excellent only surpassed by the quality, attentive service. Do yourself a favor and try it out.

Pizza was awesome. Their sausage is very tasty. The service is just as good as the pizza too. Been twice and will go many more.