New York Pizza Delivery

the staff were very friendly and the pizza was great highly recommend! will be going again in future the place is very neat inside as well

Good food. I just wanted a thin crust pizza that wasn't super greasy. We ordered the New York Supreme Pizza. Pretty tasty. Garlic bread with cheese is simply French bread with cheese and some seasoning. All in all it was decent food. Box had grease but the pizza wasn't oily and messy at all. Expect that with thin crust Milwaukee pizza. I'd definitely spend my money here again on another late night when I'm craving thin crust. Satisfied.

I know I said I would never go back for pizza, but a friend of mine, whose palette I trust raved about their pizza on her visit, so I decided to give them another chance. What a huge difference from my previous visit!First, the place was spotless. It was clean the last time I visited, but tonight there was a shine coming off the tables. As I pulled up, there were guys sweeping and mopping!The crust was much crispier and the sauce had much better flavor to it, a combination of spiciness with a subtle sweetness. The topppings were still solid like the last time. Even the service I had tonight was great. It's like this was a completely different restaurant.I'm going to have to go back again to see if the issue is consistency, or if I just went on a bad day with the wrong cook.I know 2 stars to 4 stars is a big jump, but I definitely had a 4 star experience tonight.

Went into this place to get a pizza and right after I paid my money a guy came in with a pizza to return it. Pizza didn't have the extra cheese and sausage he had asked for over the phone and had also paid over the phone. The guy explained to the mgr that he wanted his money back and stated this was the second time this had happened to him and mentioned that he got hung up on after he made the paymt for the pizza. The mgr argued with the guy and would not return the money all the while talking over the pizza (the box was open). mgr shoved the pizza back and forth to the customer. In the end, the guy was made another pizza and was forced to take a pizza with no money back... its unreal.Also, they got a 73 on their health report, that explains the flies and icky feeling of uncleanliness. Please don't support this restaurant. I won't be going back.

I really can't believe we've been waiting for almost 2 hours for our food to be delivered! We've called numerous times for an update on where the food is and every time they've said it's out for delivery. Now this restaurant is only 10' from where we are staying and could have picked up but damn, it's taken forever! Well, it's still not here so I don't know what forever really is. I can stay relaxed but I have a little guy here waiting for his pasta. Me and my wife keep saying, let's just go get him McDonald's but then we say, we might as well keep waiting but we've said this for over an hour. Needless to say we won't ever order from here again. And I would only give 1 start but I want to make sure this post makes it up on the board because I never complain about this stuff but this is out of control!Aaaaand the food arrives. We speak to the driver a bit and found out that everything the person on the phone we spoke to was a lie. The person on the phone said they couldn't make deliveries due to police activity but the driver said it didn't take long to go around. So... the food was cold, The pasta wasn't done correctly with the sauce on the side as asked for and the cheese sticks were definitely not warm at all. On the positive side, we were given back $5.00 for the inconvenience but we pre tipped 20% so in the end these liars still won. Not that it matters but we will never order from here again. And we hope anyone who reads this and takes the risk ordering from them doesn't have the same experience as we did.

They delivered my family cold pizza and cold greasy disgusting chicken that was not even cooked all the way never eat here this is what we got the $30

The Garlic Cheese Bread was not flavor full.The NY Finest Pizza has no Pizza Sauce. It was horrible, and the price was outrageous at $18.99! For that price, 3 Jacks or 2 Drafthaus could have been purchased and enjoy them much better.

Left out the utensils, received two cans of soda instead of the 2liter bottle I had ordered. Beef ribs were fatty, couldn't eat it, spaghetti was watery with no taste and the pecan pie was dry with no taste. Just say'n !!!!!!! Lesson Learned

Had to pickup doordash from here. I was 10minutes late, but they made me wait 45 minutes and she was not giving me updates. I will never accept an order to this location again.

I didn't expect NYC pizza in Milwaukee, but I at least expected NYC-style pizza. What I got was hardly distinguishable from frozen supermarket pizza. It was also barely warm and was mystifyingly cut into small squares instead of slices even though the pizza was round. The pizza was a disappointment.