Molly's Gluten-Free Bakery

Great selection of gluten-free items, both fresh and frozen. They have a nice case with beautiful desserts displayed, too. We really enjoyed the take and bake pizza, bagels, English muffins and bread we tried on our most recent visit. Everyone was super friendly and helpful. Can't wait to come back to try new items!

Great variety of gluten free goods, both sweet and savory, and very reasonably priced compared to other gluten free places. We bought their coffee cake, brownies and pizza and it is all great tasting. Super nice staff and overall a 10/10 experience especially with the other cute shops in the same building!!

The bakery is inside another store, "Vintage Barn Chicks". It is just that - a bakery, and not a cafe. Don't expect to come in for coffee and dessert. It is, rather, a bakery with lots of gluten free options for breads, cakes and desserts. They also seem very open to experimenting with other food restrictions (egg, dairy, etc.) and I can see how it would be appealing to people with food allergies and problems. While I am not sensitive to gluten or any other food, I do like to vary my diet. I believe there is too much soy and wheat and everything we eat already, and do enjoy alternative foods for balance. And for taste! Many of the gluten free options are delicious!And while I enjoyed finding a place with as much options as this place had to offer, I wasn't wowed. To be fair, I am only comparing the cookies I had here with other gluten free cookies, and I must say, I've had better. Also, despite the friendly "ask about" signs, asking questions to the person manning the cash register was like pulling teeth. They weren't friendly, and made me feel like I had to hurry up and leave. As much variety they had in the store, I didn't feel comfortable looking through the items. Hence I ended up with just a box of chocolate chip cookies. That were just, as we say in yelp-land, a-OK.

Will not disclose ingredients. They only ask what you're trying to avoid and will let you know if it's an ingredient. Sorry but I won't eat anything if I don't have a fully disclosed ingredient list. Especially when asked for!!

Super cute bakery in a charming setting in Pewaukee. Great selection of gluten free goods and they also have dairy free items on request. Delicious! Must check our!

My husband and I stopped into this bakery and got the Twinkie like pastry and that was delicious! My husband is GF so it was really neat to find out about this bakery. We picked up the gf garlic bread to take home and make later. We came towards the end of the day so you could tell that they had been busy and sold a lot. The bakery has a variety of options and loved the take home fridge with all the pizza's and bread's.

New owner, Heather and family, are doing an amazing job! Had the hot dog buns last weekend and GF sausage pizza this weekend! So many great options! Love that I can shop in person on the weekends!

I've never been so let down the birthday cake before. This thing is like car engine oil in your mouth and on your fingers it is literally filled with palm oil and cotton seed oil oh but the chocolate cake I'm describing from Molly's does have ingredient chocolate listed... WHOOPTY DOO!

I started shopping Molly's menu during the covid pandemic. She had such a great system for ordering and pick up. I appreciate how sensitive she was to her customers' needs and her employees' health while keeping everyone safe and satisfied. Her doughs are the best!

Delicious gluten free bakery! Customer service was superb and I love that they sell cookie dough too.