Mid-Way Brownies L: Caramel Fudge, B: Dulcey, R: McCosmic
Italian hoagie
Peanut butter chocolate chip cookies
Italian hoagie
Caramel fudge brownies
Souper Bowl! Mid-Way Bakery Bread Bowl with Broccoli Cheese soup
Menu
eat like a local or milwaukee
Menu and display case.
Plain croissant
Menu
Frontage
Chocolate chip cookies
Register.
Kale Cesar salad with grilled chicken and, unopened, my Broccoli cheddar soup (with bread and butter).
Cream puffs
Feb 2023 Lunch Menu. Soups change frequently, so the soups listed may be different depending on when you visit.
View from their bar seating area.
Storefront
Seasonal cream puff cut open!! Ahh!
hot dark chocolate mocha coffee, chocolate croissant
interior, donuts
Hours.
Menu
Carrie L.
Feb 4, 2025
Delicious! I tried the chocolate chip cookie at Mid-way. It is a good sized cookie. I'm picky with the bake of my cookies, this one is just right. It has a crisp edge and gradually gets chewier, but the center is not basically raw like many bakeries make the mistake of doing.
Read MoreNicole S.
Oct 10, 2024
This was a great option to eat after a conference at the Baird Center. I always love a vegetarian option and fun drinks. The veggie hoagie was generous and filling. The oatmeal cookie oat milk latte was fun. Plenty of seating and atmosphere. I like that you can order through the app early, start a tan and use Apple Pay. Great people watching, place to hang out with friends or play games. Something for everyone. Need to come back for dessert!
Read MoreSarah P.
Aug 1, 2024
I will forever dream of the vanilla bean cream puff here. The flakey, crackin-like exterior, crossiant like pastry interior and light, whipped, fluffy cream to cut the pastry is absolute perfection. Not overly sweet but with a rich vanilla flavor.Service is fast and efficient. I love the set up of this market.
Read MoreAndy K.
Feb 16, 2024
CrustyI've made stops at Mid-Way numerous times but always for their donuts and other baked goods and have had their sandwiches on my todo for some time. I've been crushing recently on deli sandwiches so I made a break for lunch to try their turkey, bacon and swiss sandwich. The bread loaf itself is huge with a fantastic crust. Turkey and all the other fixings were heaped on as well. Definitely filling. I opted to order onsite vs online and it was served up rather quickly. Staff was friendly and the market hall is always clean. Of course I could not pass up the bakery too - I snagged one of their delicious apple fritters and peanut butter cookies for tomorrow snack! :)
Read MoreRachel K.
Oct 15, 2023
Mid-Way Bakery is part of the Third Street Market Hall and has Mid-Way Bakery and Supernova Coffee & Doghnuts items at their kiosk.Since it's part of Third Street Market Hall there is plenty of seating and there is an attached parking garage.I ended up getting the Mid-Way Bakery Italian Hoagie that has capicola, ham, salami, provolone, pickled sweet peppers, lettuce, tomato, red onion, tomato and pesto mayo on a hoagie roll. It was huge. I also ordered a coffee, but technically that's from Supernova Coffee and Doughnuts.The overall sandwich was delicious, the hoagie roll wasn't my favorite and seemed a bit overcooked but the toppings and flavor combinations made up for it. The pesto mayo was a really nice touch.
Read MoreRohan D.
Dec 12, 2023
The only place ready to open on time Saturday morning, but good coffee and doughnuts is all it took for me to be happy. Lots of good looking baked good that smelled enticing. If only one of the many establishments in this food hall can open on time in the morning, then let it be this one.
Read MoreKate G.
Feb 3, 2024
Now I am not an oatmeal raisin cookie type of person but I must say that theirs is a must try. It's the only thing I've ever bought from the bakery and it keeps me coming back. Would highly recommend!! I wish they had their own spot, but I don't mind heading to 3rd market hall. It's a fun spot for any time of day. The staff at the bakery stand are nice and will often offer to warm up any pastries or baked goods that could use it!
Read MoreSamantha R.
Jul 22, 2022
I had the turkey hoagie on my first visit to Third Street Market Hall and afterwards I was craving this sandwich. Of course I've sensibly tried other vendors since then, but it's worth craving. It has a delicious seeded bun, lettuce tossed in vinaigrette before being added to get that perfect light vinegar zing, high quality meat and cheese, and tangy pickled peppers and onions. And it's a decent portion for the price. I was originally planning on getting something else on today's visit but I saw someone walking around with one of these and I had to get one. Today I also got a cup of broccoli cheese soup which came with a slice of different, but still delicious, bread and some butter. It was also good. I've tried the cookies and they're awesome. I've had my eye on the banana danish but haven't gotten it yet. I would say get a baked good if you have room when you're there.Now I'm thinking about the sandwich again. Seriously.
Read MoreMaryDan H.
Apr 17, 2022
Don't let Mid-Way Bakery's seemingly "carnival-like" name fool you. Mid-Way is a legit premium bakery offering breads, cookies, bars, Croissants and more.I purchased plain Croissants and a Pecan Blondie bar to keep overnight for brunch the next day. Wow! The Croissants were still flaky crisp on the outside yet moist on the inside. One of the best Croissants that I've every had!The pecan blondie was very very rich and sweet. Too sweet? Maybe, but supremely delicious at the same time. Definitely check out Mid-Way Bakery at 3rd Street Food Hall for excellent fresh bakery!
Read MoreDavid C.
Jul 12, 2022
Totally a super cool spot with great coffee amazing savory pastries and sweets. Buttery and flake croissants both classic and dark chocolate great chocolate chips cheese puffs and the cupcakes are amazing they are more icing than they are cup. Great food bars coffee cake and service.
Read More