Mequon Pizza Company

Date of visit: October 19, 2024This is a favorite of our friends and neighbors, but I believe I have only ever been here one time before this visit. But given the state of the parking lot and the steady stream of customers on this Sweetest Day evening, this is a favorite of a lot of folks!The ordering setup is a bit odd, after getting a table you order at the bar and they bring the food out to you. You fetch water and beverages from the bar as well as to go containers. Despite the oddness of ordering, the food is quite good. I really liked the cheese bread, though my husband thought it was overcooked (he says that about a lot of things). We also went with the deep dish pizza and while it was good overall, the crust was lacking in any flavor. I hate letting any food (especially bread products!) go to waste and went looking for excess sauce to jazz it up a bit. I think a little garlic and butter brushed on the crust as the pie is finishing its time in the oven would be the chef's kiss!

I really do not like writing negative reviews, but one of the bartenders at this place is notoriously rude. She has made us walk over to the drink menu on the opposite side of the bar, she's called my drink of choice weird and she's completely skipped over me when requesting a drink. She makes the experience not fun to go to especially since you have to order at the bar for everything. I will always recommend for us to pick up instead of dining in because of this one lady. If I had her name I'd put it here

Meh. I really like their pizza and might go there again way before the dinner hour. Their eggplant appetizer was okay. Their service is what through me off. You order at the bar if you are able to get their attention and they deliver food to the table. If you want another drink or need anything else it gets busy and forget about it.

It was a busy Saturday Night but with a small wait we were able to get seated. We didn't realize we needed to order at the bar, so keep that in mind if you go. While we didn't understand their system, it works and it works well! Our food came out in a timely fashion and piping hot. The beer and whiskey selection are pretty extensive and they have a full bar.The food quality is pretty good. Think a slightly elevated bar food experience. Nothing here tasted bad but there was also nothing pushing me to go back. Solid food overall.It was loud in there as you can probably imagine. Lots of large groups this day so lots of people waiting for tables. So it's a good place for groups of 6.Would we go back? Yeah, there wasn't anything here to make us not want to come back. Next time, we will have to try to pizza!

Wonderful pizza. Great appetizers. Good beer selection (many on tap). Many food and beer specials.

Busy parking lot and tasty pizza! Sometimes they operate with shorter staff and lesser of a menu (see board in doorway for menu options of the day), but that doesn't bother us because we really enjoy their pizza. You just have to be willing to order at the bar. Oh, they also have a good Caesar salad.

The owner continues to try to disrespect me and shame me. Oh no a small business is going to go out of business because of my accurate and terrible review, clearly you were very busy, lord knows why. I am a jerk? I disrespected your staff? The only person I was even stern with was the manager and that was because she kept making excuses. I did hear an apology at the very end and it certainly wasn't sincere. If I do nothing else with my life than making sure everyone knows what a terrible place this is then my life will have meant something. Here is a novel idea, take my criticism and fix what is wrong, I realize that means fixing a ton of things and taking responsibility, but life is tough, get a helmet. I know this isn't going to change anything in that thick little brain of yours, but I don't care. You suck.

Was so looking forward to experiencing the food. Location and setting were very nice comfortable the hostess very pleasant but unfortunately, we were never served. We sat for 40 minutes my daughter and I watched as other customers arrived and were seated and served. And it wasn't even busy. Don't want to assume it was because the two of us were black. No one came to our table to see if we were ready to order or offer to get our drink order it was a first time and unfortunately, the last time.

I live in the area and decided to go with my family and try a new pizza place. The restaurant is located in a very nice area. And when we arrived the hostess seated us and was very nice. while waiting several workers walked straight past our table and never came to greet us. 30 minutes after we have been seated nobody came over to our table to take our drink orders or food. Very disappointed! Not returning!

Whoever the cook was tonight we had the best pizza we've had in the past few years we've ordered! Ordered a 14" deep dish pepperoni pizza to go at 7 pm and it was delicious!