McFarland Liquors

We just moved to the area and are looking for "our" local liquor store. I enjoy whiskey and am always looking to pick up something interesting. The whiskey selection was decent, as were the prices. I definitely appreciate how they handle allocated whiskeys through a lottery system.

This is a very nice, hidden gem just outside of Madison. Part of the Monumental Enterprises group of stores (McFarland Liquors, Party Port, Liquor Town and Village Liquors), they have a huge private barrel program that is always growing, and they know how to pick a barrel. I've yet to be disappointed by their choices.The inside of the store is a little tight, but the selection is top-notch and vast. Browse slowly through the aisles, you don't want to miss a great whiskey by going too fast. They also have an impressive collection of wine and beer. The prices are very fair and they aren't into the secondary market pricing game that seems to be all the rage with some store owners these days.Nathanael is a super nice guy who wants to make sure you're getting what's the best choice for you. He's very knowledgeable and full of advice. Cheers!

Always helpful; super friendly staff. Good selection of wines. We won't go to any other liquor store in McFarland.

Good selection, decent prices, and friendly service.This is about the best local liquor store one could hope for in a village this size. Their selection of beer and wine are quite good for such a small venue, and the remaining shelves are well-stocked with with a nice variety of spirits.There are some advantages to being a bit off others' maps. They frequently have hard-to-find B. Nektar meads in the cooler. Likewise, a friend found a couple bottles of a Scotch not currently distributed in North America.Star sees more variety and rare bottles, and Woodman's has better prices, but that can be said of most any store in the area. What keeps this review from five-stars is the inconsistent knowledge of the staff. Some folks seem to know their wares well; others aren't familiar with local breweries, can't recommend wine pairings, and have never heard of ouzo.Don't sign up for the email newsletter. The large PDFs they send are painfully busy.

This is an awesome store, with quality items you wouldn't expect from the look of the exterior. Lots of hard to find hidden gems, and if they dont have it they will get it! Some of the staff is amazing, we like Tim the best.

I've never written a yelp review, good or bad. When I stopped in to make a purchase, an employee with long curly hair at this liquor store was extremely rude to me in front of other customers. I avidly support small business, and went out of my way to go to this store over countless others in the area. In the future I will be taking my business elsewhere, and recommending others to do the same. Very disappointed