Maxwell's

Came here on a Friday night at 5:30 PM. We had made reservations beforehand so kudos to Maxwells for taking reservations for a Friday ! Our waitress was quick and witty. We all ordered the fish fry with different sides. The sides are a large portion and the fish fry is two pieces of cod. I ordered white Zinfandel since they didn't have Prosecco which I was disappointed about. Bill for four people who had four fish fry's and 5 drinks total came to $114.

Julie was an excellent server despite it being super hectic due to the Wine and Harvest Festival. Food came out quickly and was fresh and hot. The deluxe grilled cheese was so good I couldn't even save any to take home. Restaurant temperature was very warm, but other than that it was a great experience.

I try to give this place multiple chances. They do have good boneless wings. At the price of $13.99 they should be! That is for very small sized boneless wings. I had the Bloody Mary. That was really good. Our server did a good job. (Again expensive) I tried the tots for the first time. B- Super small portion and barely any toppings. C for ambiance. It's a "dive bar", but they think they are in Cedarburg so they can charge more. It's kind of dirty in there as well. Prices reflect a higher end sports bar. B- food quality. Served in a basket and given a tiny plate. Service. B+ She was good!

This place is incestuous. The only people who you will see are the people that work there, drinking behind the bar for free. Wings are the staple, which should shine some light on the kitchen's ability to "cook" anything ‍. The ambiance is the equivalent of walking into a family argument between your cousins. Unfortunately, despite a great location and a local base, Maxwells has been squandered. Hopefully, someone else will take over, clean it up, and improve the community. ‍

This is the third time I have experienced the same situation. First 2 times with my husband and yesterday with my daughter. I am a firm believer of always giving a second chance. The first two times, my husband and I felt like we were racially profiled. The first two occasions, we were seated in the same place and we had to go get the waitress because we felt like they were ignoring us on purpose. My husband is a very patient man. I remember that I wanted to leave the place. We were nothing but nice kind and very patient with the waitress which it was the same one that took care of us before. He asked me to stay but yesterday was the worse!I went there with my daughter around 4:15 PM. I asked the server for a table and right away I knew how this experience was going to be because it has happened before. They looked annoyed that I was even there. We were seated right away but we were seated in the back behind the bar. They did the same thing the last time. The area was totally secluded. Everybody was enjoying the game and they were tables available upfront, but they chose to sit us back there. We were sitting there for 30 minutes, and nobody came in to give us not even a glass of water. Both my daughter and I used to bathrooms in separate occasions just to walk around to see what was the holdup but the servers didn't look busy at all. After a while of waiting, a Caucasian family was seated in the same area we were seated. The server came to service them not even 5 mins after they were seated. At that point I understood what was really going on and I decided to leave. I felt extremely offended. I could totally understand if it happened one time but three times? Too bad I can't give Zero stars. Stay away from this place.

Husband and I ordered Boneless Wings to go. Food is typical bar food. Nothing special but would eat here again AFTER COVID. It wouldn't be my first choice, but if someone wanted to eat here, I would go.Staff doesn't follow COVID protocol. No employees (hostesses, bartender, kitchen staff) wore masks. They had their kitchen door wide open and I watched one of the cooks making while he was making food as we waited for our take out. During that time he was texting on his phone, then going back and touching food and eating food then going back to cook. No hand washing between these activities. If this doesn't bother you then I'm sure you'll like it here! Otherwise, I would suggest not eating here as they don't seem to care about slowing the spread of the virus in the community.

Maxwell's is a fun spot to grab lunch or an afternoon drink. The service is good and the staff is friendly. They have great deals, and it's always packed! I always get the deluxe grilled cheese, which is the perfect "grown up" grilled cheese. I highly recommend to stop in while exploring downtown Cedarburg!

Sunday outing with my daughter and sister. Food was fine but the bill came with and extra service charge. I asked the waitress what that was for, she said if paying by credit card. I said I was paying cash. I gave her money asked for change said oh you are not tipping me? I said yes and waited for the adjusted bill. She came back with some incorrect change no bill and accused me of laughing at her. We were having a private conversation nothing to do with her. Never got a correct bill or correct change. Second time there that was a nightmare. Never again.

Disappointing visit. Cranberry salad with grilled chicken was okay. Grilled ham and cheese was falling apart from lack of cheese. Hamburger was the worst. For $16 you get what looked like a 1/5 lb patty on a small bun with some decent fries. Compare that to a half pound burger with lots of toppings at McJuggers in Dundee 25 miles away for the same price and you might never go back to Maxwells. The onion rings were overcooked too.

The service was very good, we sat down at a table right away. I loved the old charm & character they have maintained in this old building. The food was very good, we plan on going back