a man sitting at a table with a pizza and a beer
10"x10" Pepperoni Pizza with Light Cheese
Large pepperoni with half jalapeños
Trash glob of plain meat this is by far the most disgusting sandwich I have ever had
Meat sauce? It's more like barely sauce. Sorry guys! I really wanted to enjoy this but it really fell short.
The homemade garlic bread...
Calzone
Marty's sub
Chicken Parmigiana
Meatball sub
Spinach chicken Alfredo pizza large
Garden Gluten Free Pizza
Marghetia Style pizza
food
Marty's Also Delivers
Beer!
The Works pizza with pepperoni
Spotted cow! YUM!
Cheesy pizza!
12x12 pepperoni onion jalapeno
Salads pilled high.
Double order of cheese curds.
food, pasta, pasta dish
Pizza by the foot!
Becky B.
Feb 20, 2025
I almost forgot how good this place is. I recently went there on a date with my husband. I got the chicken Parmesan sandwich. It was so good. I hadn't been since I was a teenager but Marty's is still so good.
Read More
Mary Lou S.
Oct 3, 2024
We stopped next door for gas and it was lunch time, so we decided to give Marty's Pizza a try. Our server was very nice. She was the only one taking care of the tables at the time and did a great job. The hubby decided on the lunch pizza. It was a thin crust individual pizza and it came with a piece of yummy garlic bread. I got two pieces of garlic bread for my check in on Yelp! I had the Italian sandwich, which I really enjoyed. The restaurant was clean and had lots of seating.
Read More
Carrie R.
Dec 23, 2024
We love the pizza at Marry's Pizza. We have eaten both in the dining area as well as ordered it to go. Both are always hot and delicious. The sauce is not too sweet, which I prefer and has an addictive and robust flavor. The dough is just the right texture. Best pizza in the area in our opinion. We've been going there for years.
Read More
Craig W.
Mar 2, 2024
Nice portions. Very good food. Something for everyone. Recommended for families or groups.
Read More
Brooke s.
Jul 5, 2024
I got a grilled chicken sub. They were out of their sub buns, but said their sandwich buns were essentially the same. WOW, the bread was delicious!!! Homemade too. Our service was okay, but probably just the waitress having an off day? My mom always loves the pizza here! They are unique since they are rectangular instead of circular.
Read More
Sarah H.
Dec 27, 2023
My husband and I have been visiting Marty's Pizza for almost two decades. We enjoy their pizza, breadsticks, and garlic bread. Their pizza has a nice crispy cracker crust and the perfect ratio of toppings. Their pizzas are also available in a multitude of sizes which makes them great for large and small groups. Very happy with our visits to Marty's Pizza and will continue to visit!
Read More
Dave V.
Aug 26, 2023
The pizza is really good. I love the crust.I got a huge pizza for the guys I work with. I ordered half pepperoni, half sausage. Since 2 people don't eat meat, I asked that they spread the ingredients 1/3 pep, 1/3 sausage, and leave 1/3 just cheese. I'd still pay for half and half.They said no, they wouldn't do it. It didn't seem that much to ask; particularly after I left a big tip.
Read More
Troy T.
Oct 9, 2024
I heard a bunch of good but I am sadly disappointed. I ordered the spaghetti with meatballs and meat sauce.... I don't know what they call meat sauce but in my opinion this isn't it. The meatballs were very dense and not tender at all. The house made garlic bread was soggy white bread sandwich style. I wanted to like this food but I would rank it a 2-10.
Read More
Steve B.
Jun 2, 2024
This is a review that I should have done a couple of years ago. Marty's has been our "go-to" place for over 35 years. The pizza is both good and consistently made. When my ex-wife and I remarried, deciding to use Marty's as our reception was an easy choice. Unfortunately, we were a bit too free in extending our invitations and (accidently) essentially took over the place. The wait staff and cooks were superb about it.
Read More
George K.
Aug 18, 2024
A group 20 I was with went to Marty's Pizza in Delafield for an afternoon lunch on a Saturday and totally enjoyed our time there. We had delicious pizza and garlic bread with excellent service. You cannot go wrong at this place.
Read More