Mama Mia's West Allis

We had never been to this location but grew up eating this pizza and bread. Made the decision to stop in and I'm so glad we did.It was everything we remembered and we'll definitely be back. The space had a retro/old school but neighborhood feel. The garlic bread can never be beat. While there are close impersonators--Mama Mia's is the GOAT. The pizza, thin crispy, with the perfect amount of a well balanced sauce and you can actually taste each of the toppings. Looking forward to coming back and diving into an order of the lasagna. Mangia, mangia!

Let's start with the cozy old school vibes. Old leather booths. The salad was on point. The perfect mix of fresh and acidic. Then I ordered the chicken parmigiana with garlic bread and it was magical!! Garlic bread you can dream about!!

Growing up in the Milwaukee area Mama Mia's was a treat meal for us. So I go whenever I'm in the area. A little bit of nostalgia and a whole lot of happiness in my belly. Their lasagna and garlic bread are unlike any other Italian restaurant. The bread drips buttery goodness. The lasagna has a healthy portion of cheese with and heaps of meat sauce. Service is fine, nothing special. But the food is the star here so that's ok.

Mama Mia's used to have more than one location. West Allis is all there is now. Usually do carryout. Great sauce, great lasagna, great spaghetti and meatballs. Best garlic bread i have ever had. Dripping in garlic butter! Yumm! Its an older brick building but well cared for. Many specials like buy a lasagna get one free (don't remember what day) but they have wonderful deals like that. Applies to carryout too! Service has always been excellent both in restaurant and at their separate entrance carryout window!

Service was top notch! The beer, lasagna and pizza was outstanding!! The lasagna had so much sauce and cheese it was heavenly!!!

Me and my 5 friends went there last night. We had a great time. Food was good. Garlic bread is to die for. The place has been there for a long time and I'm curious when was it established?

Went in here to have a pizza. While sitting and waiting for it I saw this odd large bug on top of the napkin holder. I asked my husband ..'what is that"...all he could do was laugh and say.."Don't you know what that is??""...I said noooo.he then told me it was a ROACH!!..I got up and said we are leaving and the waitress brought the pizza so I told her we are out of here you keep it and the bugs. Never will we ever go back and you can't ever get them out of a restaurant!!!. I had to look it up to see and sure enough that was what it was.

Good food, good service. Nice cozy establishment. It was cool talking to some of the other people that were in there had been coming there for along time, they came when they were kids they were bringing there kids and grand children. It was really cool experience

Mama Mia's in West Allis is still the place for the best garlic bread and delicious pizza and many other entrees, try the lasagna!!

Pizza a bit dry but ok. Seating worn. Salad nice but served dry and not chilled. Bread is AWESOME. We've had better pizza, ie Lalis in Wauwatosa. But mamas brings us back with its bread.