Mama Mia Pizzeria Baraboo

Fantastic food and exceptional service. No wonder my son loved coming here. The hot rolls were delicious and gone in seconds.

Outstanding pizza! Great service! Ice tea was just right. Quick service. Absolutely no negatives at all. Highly recommended.

We went back for pizza this time. We got an 18 inch Large Mama Mia pizza. It was packed with lots of toppings. The crust was delicious. Huge slices. I could only eat 2 slices and I was stuffed. Very good. Come for the pizza!

Inconsistent. Sometimes they knock it out of the park, just picked up a large pie tonight and the bottom is black and crust is burnt. Hit or miss.

Moved from new haven, CT where we had an Italian community with the most amazing eateries and pizzerias. We moved to madison a few months back and stumbled upon mama Mia on our visit to Devils lake. It was just amazing. A family run restaurant with great homemade food. The ambience and service were top notch and welcoming. Everything was great, but I'll definitely be back to try more of the garlic bread and the marinara sauce.

I truly enjoyed our visit to this restaurant. I had been visiting friends in Baraboo and my friend Jess swears by the pizza. So naturally, I had to check it out. We ordered a pepperoni pizza together. Jess's husband got the shrimp Alfredo. It was all very delicious! The pizza was huge! The shrimp were large and well cooked. The Alfredo was absolutely delicious! I would definitely recommend it. It did need a touch of salt but I MUCH rather them under season than over season. It was a very easy fix with a touch of salt added in. I think I'd order that if I ever went back, yum! The pizza was greasy, but if you order pepperoni that's to be expected. And I wasn't complaining, it was delicious! Every grease drop on that pizza was amazing. Service was friendly and attentive. Food came out at a decent time, got and ready to go. My stomach is growling just thinking about it. I'll be so happy to return when I'm in the area.

Got take out from here this week. Dough was really bready and felt raw. The sauce was under seasoned and unremarkable. The pizza, overall was nothing special. My motto is "there's no such thing as bad pizza only better pizza" and there is definitely better pizza out there

Great locally owned pizzeria with taste of Italy.We usually get the 14" with sausage and mushrooms. The crust is light and very tasty along with the toppings. We also get the salad with their wonderful Italian dressing. The dressing is very flavorful and brings out the flavor of the lettuce.Pricing is very reasonable.

We were just passing through, stopped in here for lunch after hiking. We had a Stromboli and the Spicy shrimp marinara. Both were excellent. Both came out piping hot, apparently food doesnt sit under a heat lamp here. The portions were huge. We will eat the leftovers for dinner and probably as a snack on the road tomorrow. The service was good. The mother came out to ensure we were happy with our food.

We love everything about this restaurant. First we love the people that own it, and are hands on in every way. Family owned and friendly. Second the food is delicious. We have eaten in the restaurant and we have carried out pizza. We love the pizza and we love the rest of the menu. When we go there we feel like we are family and that is a great feeling to have at a restaurant. Grateful for this place in the neighborhood