Mama Cimino's
Mama Cimino's
Burnt pizza
Good buffalo & bbq wings, good calamari (some fancy places are worse), and good service. Shrimp average.
24" inches of perfection
Cimino Sicilian Pizza & Pepperoni Rolls
Pepperoni Rolls
Mamma Mia!!
Pizza Box Inside
Delicious slice sausage pizza Mama Ciminos approved!
1/2 Artichoke Dip Pizza & 1/2 BBQ Chicken Pizza
The burned that hid under noodles is lasagna
a pizza sign on a table
Since 1974
Mushroom half pepperoni Cimino crust pizza
Cimino's regular pizza
This is the view from the street.
This is what you see when you walk in. This is the counter for takeout orders.
There is an outdoor patio.
The second pizza looked like this. We aren't even Buddist.
pizza
pizza
menu
chowder, food, soups and chowder, soup
The Best Pizza in Lake Geneva!
Christina F.
Sep 14, 2024
Amazing food! First visit and had a phenomenal experience. Nick (the owner) was so personable, attentive and checked several times to make sure we were fully satisfied with everything. Cheese curds, fries, pizza, fettuccine alfredo, Caesar salad, and a house salad were all made to perfection. Loved the pizza sauce, not too thick, not too heavy, it was the perfect amount to let all the toppings the star of the show. Waiter was awesome. Very genuine and kind. He also made sure we were fully enjoying our visit. Great first experience - we will definitely be back!
Read More
Trina T.
Sep 16, 2024
Stumbled upon this place on a random Monday night. Had an amazing server and an awesome spinach dip pizza! 10/10 would recommend!
Read More
Jess S.
Mar 24, 2024
Nice little pizza joint. Staff is friendly and helpful. Place isn't fancy. Prices were good. Got the Pepperoni Rolls and they were great. Got 14 inch Ciminos Crust(thin) with Sausage/Black Olives. Very Tasty and thought sausage was excellent. Will go back.
Read More
Jeanne U.
Aug 15, 2024
Cimino's pizza is better than my favorite local family pizza place in Chicago! The sauce was amazing and they use quality cheese. A thin crust but not crunchy or soggy. The pizza was ready promptly and the staff was friendly.
Read More
james j.
May 29, 2023
Great place great food great people just like family your best bet in town for pizza. A good time great service and overall great food that's gonna leave you with a smile.!
Read More
Jimjim C.
Jan 10, 2024
The food had a sticky paste on it and the driver told me it was spunk. The other pizza had a swastika on it with the pepperoni.
Read More
Beck S.
Sep 22, 2024
I just had a private event at this reaturant and it was just absolutely amazing. The food was delicious, especially the meatballs and the sauce! The gluten free pizza was awesome too! Jim was so great helping me plan this. He opened the place early to accommodate 40 people for me, and took care of us like we were family. The resturant was clean, well lit and spacious. Great experience. 10/10 would recommend!
Read More
theresa m.
Nov 28, 2024
This place is lovely! We went on Thanksgiving, and were served quickly and kindly. The pizza was great and our server, Jim, was awesome. They're open on major holidays and we're very friendly. The bathrooms were cleaner than any I'd ever seen, enough to encourage me to write this review! Great place !
Read More
Tracey T.
Aug 17, 2024
Absolutley amazing pizza pie!!! We are from Chicago and were really impressed!!! You gotta try it!!
Read More
Cristina L.
Oct 20, 2024
Amazing and open late! I left to Cali and I am so sad that I don't get this amazing food anymore. However, I always come back so that says something. I can't wait to visit again and enjoy the wonderful flavors of Ciminos pizza!
Read More
