Lucky Star Pub & Eatery

A classic Wisconsin Pub- which is exactly what we were looking for. A great pit stop on our way home. They did have a pretty crowded restaurant since it was lunch time, but the service was quick and welcoming. The menu is a good size with options for everyone. We started with their queso blanco and salsa. I ordered a mushroom Swiss burger- which came with soup and a side. I had the chicken and dumpling soup and the classic Mac and cheese- both were great! The burger was cooked correctly and had a great flavor. I forgot to snap some photos, so you'll have to take my word for it! An upbeat atmosphere, a classic menu, and speedy service- what else can you ask for in a small town!?

You can't visit the Midwest and not go to a Friday night fish fry! So after getting picked up from MKE out group headed to Lucky Star to eat some fried fish. We arrived around 5:30p on a Friday and our group of six was seated right away. All of us ordered the fish fry. Appreciate that it comes with soup or salad along with your choice of side. The portions were large and the food was tasty. Make sure to check in on Yelp and get your free fried ice cream. I don't think many people do that because our server had to check with her manager to see if they could honor the coupon. They did and the fried ice cream was a cool experience.

Food was delicious. Service was amazing even with a trainee! The choice of soups that come with your meal are amazing. There's a reason why their parking lot is full.

four and a half stars really...knocking off that half star bc i only give 5 full stars to complete standout/shout from the rooftop places. everything was good here - service, ambiance, food. the menu covers it all - mexican and tex mex plus all the margaritas and cocktails. really no complaints!the food is good, again nothing memorable but good enough to spread the word. our server was extremely attentive and personable and food came out fast. this is definitely not a typical mexican restaurant - it really is a pub with mexican food... with a bit of biker bar feel ;) lots of character!

Super busy, but seated quickly. The interior is nice, pub like, as you'd expect.Good breakfast selections with a tex-mex flair. Chicken Fried Steak was not homemade and had a stale/freezer taste. Hashbrowns were actually cold in the middle. Pancakes were good and had generous fillings like blueberries and chocolate chips.I might try again, but probably not. If you are in the area looking, you could do worse.

Omg, this place is such a gem! We have been missing that pre-pandemic, restaurant feel. This place offers everything you hope for when you go out for dinner: great service, fully staffed with people who actually make you feel welcomed, amazing food, what more can you ask for?! Plus, when we were being walked to our table, we heard the kitchen staff and servers talking about actual work and no one was in the corner on their phone.Our server Becca and her co-workers Brent and Wyatt really made this place stand out for us. Becca, thank you for being so welcoming and fun! Brent, thank you for calling me out for staring at you because you looked familiar. That was hysterical!Wyatt, thank you for filling my drink for me when you brought out our appetizer! It was something you could have easily ignored but didn't.Just exceptional!

Amazing service and great food! Our two favorite servers are Chris and Sarah! They provide perfect service every time. My dad and I look forward to seeing them when we go out to Lucky Star. Thank you ladies!!

Our original waiter forgot about us, but mechelle stepped up and saw us patiently waiting for our order to be take. The food has always been good, and we were grateful for mechelle initiative and care.

Never again. Lucky Star use to be the place to go but in the last few visits... for get about it. The food that was supposed to be hot and fresh was cold, dried up and cold. Tasteless slop on a plate. Besides now charging $5.00 chips and salsa only to watch them recycle the left over chips and salsa from a dirty table was the icing on the cake. No wonder the talk of the town is all negative.

Our waitress was great, the food was delicious and the coffee was perfect. We had breakfast , I would recommend the Mediterranean skillet and my friend had eggs with sausage and pancakes which he enjoyed.