Landmark Creamery

Line took a few, but not bad and it was a beautiful day! Lots of cheeses to sample and purchase, along with a ton of other unique products!

If you're looking for a great charming place to stop in and have a delicious grilled cheese sandwich, then this is the place. While my husband and I were on a day trip, we stopped in Paoli, Wisconsin to check out this cute café. What a treasure! So many cute gifts, wines and cheeses. It was hard not to leave with some thing. But the bonus was the grilled cheese sandwich. We opted for the Anabasque sandwich with the shallot and red wine confit topping and it was over the top delicious. Perfect amount of cheese with the best pull and crunch. There is also a small but nice wine selection. The owner is friendly and wonderful to chat with. Not a lot of seating, it's just a long table that doubles as a display but somehow it works perfectly for dining. Don't miss out on this place and bring a cooler to load up on cheese to purchase for a perfect holiday charcuterie board.

We always stop here on our way into Paoli! I love the small town atmosphere and the selection of gifts in the front shop! I picked some out this year as Christmas presents! The only wish I had is that they had more coffee selections, only hot and iced drip coffee. Basic, fits the need but definitely would love to see more!

The "Annas" have been making some of the most delicious cheese in the US (if not the world) for quite awhile. I have my favorites, the Rebel Miel, their take on Telligio, Pamona?Paloma? Their Pecora Nocciola, and a tiny delectable round soft cheese they make only once in awhile. It's worth dropping by and exploring their cheese offerings and to peruse all the other delights in their store - you've been warned! They also do sandwiches. These folks are the real deal

About a year and a half ago my husband and I went to Harvest on the square for dinner and ordered a cheese board. One of the cheeses was Pecora Nocciola, and I swore I would track it down and buy more. Time passed, and then the pandemic hit, and it went to the back of my mind. Last weekend I finally decided it was time to get a wedge. I ventured to Paoli to the cheese shop and grabbed some Pecora Nocciola, as well as the Pipit. Of course the trip wouldn't be complete without picking up some Potter's Crackers. The shop is cute and quaint, and I had to take a picture of the adorable sheep statue. I will be back for sure!

No reviews for this place yet? Well, let me be the first to tell you - YUM YUM, give me some!Today I had the most amazing toast for breakfast that I have EVER had. I could eat this every morning. $4.50 and absolutely delightful. I got the "sweet" with fresh sheep cheese, pear ginger jam, and thyme. It wasn't overly sweet just downright delicious. Very generous with the toppings and they pared together perfectly. My husband tried the savory and he loved that as well. Coffee was $3, kind of pricey, but hey, it was good. It was a beautiful day so we sat outside on a picnic table and enjoyed this light breakfast. The picture really doesn't do it justice. You just need to try it. They have grilled cheese sandwiches as well which I can imagine are great. I need to ask what kind of bread they use because it was soooo good!I can't wait to go back. Never thought I'd be this so enthralled by toast!

So glad to see that cheese is back in Paoli. And tasty too. They have a nice selection of cheeses from other area dairies, as well as their own creations made from sheep's milk. They have a nice menu of sandwiches (my wife loved her grilled Anabasque cheese sammi) and other packaged artisan foods and gifts. Alas, the famous water pump at the nearby park was broken. So much for nostalgia.

Spent a lovely afternoon in Paoli today and one of the owners fixed us an amazing lunch while the other gave us a tour of the cheeses for sale! It was such a nice visit and the cheese board and sandwiches were amazing! Thanks 2Annas for the amazing visit! I can't wait to come back!

We have always come in here when visiting Paoli, such a cute little shop with some fun little items and excellent cheeses. Each time we have always wanted to get one of their grilled cheese sandwiches that they make there as they smell SO GOOD! So this time we got a couple of sandwiches with various cheeses and then a chipotle raspberry and rose scallion spread, both were very good. We also got their "Mac and cheese" blended cheese mixture and took home to make an incredible baked Mac and cheese. The girl working the counter (daughter of the owner) was super friendly and helpful, nice job.

Love this place! Paoli is such a magical little spot and Landmark Creamery makes it so. Everyone is always super friendly. Interesting array of cheese and products, all delicious. The grill cheese sandwiches are divine. Get a sandwich, beverage and step next door to eat in the park. Doesn't get better!