Johnny Manhattan's

Started dinner with a Johnny Manhattan signature drink with Basil Hayden Rye whiskey and it was fantastic. Dinner consisted of the Ribeye that came with a wonderful sear that was totally delicious, definitely a prime cut of beef that you just don't get at the local store. Highly recommend for a dinner to remember!

Wow, what a great experience. The pork chops and the scallops were perfect. Our waitress, Nicole was so much fun and added to the experience. Really special. The facility is top notch only to be outdone by the food. It is a gem!

Was here for a work meeting, had the private room! Lovely ambiance in the restaurant - HUGE and open! Private room was great, intimate and perfect for our group. I got the pork chop duo. It was THE BEST PORK CHOP IVE EVER HAD! You must must must order. Great spot!!!!

This is the best steakhouse in Milwaukee, or rather just outside of Milwaukee! My ribeye was done perfectly medium rare, and my colleague said he never had better pork chops. Bartender and waitress were very welcoming.

Great food and service. I enjoyed the fish fry, while my family enjoyed the chicken dinner deal. I am subtracting a star because they had high chairs, but absolutely no place to change a diaper. Please consider putting a changing table in ADA bathroom or finding another spot for one. The manager was kind enough to push to chairs together in a side office for a diaper change, but that is not the safest option and no guarantee they will let me do that again. I will either have to plan to change her diaper in the car or wait until we are out of diapers to return as a family.

We had an incredible dining experience here.Table of 5 sober got to try alot of dishes.The brandy old fashioned were perfect. The server was attentive and friendly and we actually got our own private room.We highly recommend the haystack onion strings and the cheese curd appetizers. The remoulade (?) sauce with the strings was fantastic.One of our diners had the lasagna. It was absolutely enormous and came with a salad and what he described as the best garlic bread ever. He also said the lasagna was the best he's ever had. He's a big eater and barely ate half his meal.The steaks were cooked perfectly and had an amazing char.The baked potato and the hash brown casserole were both great.We added side scallops and they were huge and tasty.Great meal. Hope to be back soon as there were at least 10 dishes that sound amazing.

We had a wonderful experience at Johnny Manhattan's. The setting is very beautiful - located in the scenic Holy Hill area. Inside the restaurant you'll feel like you're at a swanky steak house. I ordered the lasagna- it was possibly the best I have ever had. The portion was huge and it came with a delicious salad and a slice of tasty garlic bread. My significant ordered the pork chops- he said it was the best he had ever had. We definitely recommend this restaurant!

Food atmosphere and service were great Went for a work event in the private dining room and our group had a wonderful time

Until last night, every meal we have had at Johnny Manhattans has been fantastic, calling it one of our favorite places. Unfortunately both my husband (an avid steak lover who has never ordered anything but!) and I both ordered the lasagna which was a mistake. It was flat yet heavy, only had a few layers, was doused with a heavy sauce, and didn't have much flavor... so disappointing! Our friends who were with us said it did not look the same as they had seen in the past. I would not order this again.(However, Nancy's garlic bread with cheese and the bang bang shrimp were fantastic!)

What a nice time. Very pretty Christmas decorations. Really great food and service. I can see why they have been around for 25+ years. I would also recommend reservations. By 6pm, they were packed, and it was a Tuesday night.