a close up of a sandwich
Dining area
I think someone working here needs to go back and get a bagel cutting degree before assassinating another bagel....
Dining area
Half of spinach quiche bagel with veg cream cheese
the menu
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Bagel.
Pumpkin chocolate chip
hours of operation
My bf with his pizza bagel and the note.
Morgan G.
Oct 25, 2024
Nice little place for a bagel and cream cheese. 1 star docked because they don't have low fat cream cheese, hot tea, or any type of vegetables to put on your bagel. Despite all of that, I really enjoyed my breakfast here, steady stream of customers and they go quickly through the line. There's a good variety of bagel flavors and the bagels are soft and fluffy with a generous amount of cream cheese on them.
Read More
Sue M.
Nov 24, 2024
Great little bagel shop. Service staff is very friendly and helpful. Great bagels and coffee. Good prices. A few tables for dine-in but more of a take out place.
Read More
Lauren O.
Oct 3, 2021
Maybe people come here for bagels but they absolutely don't come here for breakfast sandwiches on a bagel. We ordered two this morning and there was a line but it moved quickly. The egg on the sandwich is definitely microwaved, reminiscent of the fast food chains. The bacon totally soggy. Even Dunkin' Donuts bacon had more to it than this bacon. And fast food chains have improved their microwaveable eggs so Jersey bagels eggs are actually worse than fast food. I would come back and get some bagels for home but I wouldn't get any hot lunch sandwiches or breakfast sandwiches from them. It takes a minute to cook an egg the NON lazy way!
Read More
Bri B.
Sep 7, 2017
Atmosphere: Very classy inside, light and airy. Great display of their product. So funny note: we got some bagels early on a Sunday morning, just a few, and we loved the so much we went back for more to bring in to work the following day, but they close at 1 p.m. on Sundays just an FYI. We were 10 minutes too late for more carb filled goodness. Service: Friendly, the staff had plenty of suggestions and information about pricing. Food: Shut uppppppppppppppp. These bagels beat the pants off of Einstein Bros. and their cream cheese is a whole different level of goodness. We are hooked, we actually didn't renew our Costco membership since we now have a local bagel place vs. buying Costco's bagels ( Kirkland-Einstein bros. recipe). We have had the blueberry bagels and cheddar herb.I can't wait to try more items off of their menu.
Read More
Debbie G.
Jul 5, 2020
Yes, go here! The bagels are fresh with just the right crust and soft inside. The garden cream cheese is flavorful. The honey butter, yum! Cute, very clean place with quick friendly staff. And you can't beat the prices.
Read More
Clarence D.
Nov 3, 2024
Jersey is a favorite in my house, they have such amazing bagels and so many choices! The staff is always friendly and efficient.
Read More
James G.
Aug 28, 2023
Bagels so good, they're almost worth moving to Appleton for! My wife used to live there and brings lots of them back to Chicago whenever she goes back to visit. I'm always sad when they run out!
Read More
Gabrielle S.
Apr 22, 2023
Excellent bagels! Nice variety of sweet and savory! The staff was super nice and service was freaky fast, two thumbs up must try again.
Read More
Elizabeth J.
Apr 30, 2022
The bagels here are the best in town! They have so much variety and it comes out quick and yummy! The staff is also awesome! They are so nice, they even wrote us a note on a napkin to have a great day! I 100/10 recommend!
Read More
Linda K.
Feb 20, 2023
I regularly order catering from Jersey Bagel. In the last six months I've had issues with staff hanging up on me or taking my order and then when I go to pick it up, there is no record of it. I won't be back.
Read More
Rated: 4.4 (200 reviews) · $
Coffee & Tea, Breakfast & Brunch, Sandwiches