Jeff's On Rugby

I've yet to try something on their menu that I don't like. Their French onion soup is delicious! Last night we ordered NYE dinner specials to go. My deep fried shrimp and with ribeye was fantastic. My boyfriend got their lobster special dinner and enjoyed it very much.Past orders from us have included the cod, perch, fishermen feast, and the pot roast melt sandwich. All of it is good. Prepandemic, we dined in. We've been doing carry out and they always get the order right. Good quality food at a great price. Looking forward to dining in, hopefully soon!

I came here for dinner on a weeknight. I was called ahead to make a reservation but it wasn't necessary. This place is your typical no frills Wisconsin supper club.We started off of the cheese curds and hot fresh bread came out with it. The cheese curds were so good!For dinner I had the scallops with asparagus. I highly recommend this dish if you like scallops. You get a ton of them for such a good price. I also had some of the filet of sirloin, and that was one of the best steaks I've had in my life. After dinner, we went to the bar to drink and the bartender and all the staff were wonderful. I will definitely be back. If you're ever in OshKosh, you definitely have to stop by this supper club!

One of the better choices within walking distance of the airport, although it is probably at the limit of walking. However, the food is worth it. Our meals were the EAA prime rib special, only available certain days during the air show and broiled scallops. All the food was spot on and I have a high trust that the other dishes would be too. I was a little concerned about the serving size, I think was 6 scallops and a large portion of vegetables, but with the garlic butter, it was spot on. It was very noisy in the restaurant, but it also got very quiet when one particular table left. We could have a conversation but we were competing at times. Not suggesting this is an issue, but be aware.

Well.I'm a sucker for Wisconsin Supper Clubs. I really am.The bigger the shithole, the more I like it.I think I like them so much, I have put myself at a disadvantage, insomuch as when I stumble across a joint putting out simply competent fare, I register it as a letdown.Unfair, admittedly.Take Jeff's here. I dunno if what we were served was a decent meal, or proof someone in the kitchen didn't care. The place was packed, for real. The locals had to know something.Being in the land of professional drinkers, I HAD to have a heroic Old- Fashioned (Brandy, natch); and it was fine fine fine. Even better at $4.75!I opted for the "House special chicken", which was...nothing special. It was an edible chicken dinner, but nothing to light up the scoreboard.My wife had a Filet Mignon, which she said was not fab.I tasted it.The cut was of good quality, but not realistically seasoned.Prolly the same thing I could say about the chicken.Nothing horrible, but nothing great either.Was I waiting for a culinary frisson, or did I just need to eat?Sometimes a Wisco supper club is just a place to eat, and that's what I believe Jeff's is here. Too many fine reviews for the joint lets me know maybe I was setting the limbo bar a little too low. There was no way the place was going to clear that goal.I think Jeff's was prolly better than I remember it--so give them a chance and eat there. Have a cocktail or two while you're at it.The total tab here was $40. We've spent more at Steak and Shake, fer chrissakes.

Kelly is the fastest most a accurate bartender in town. We decided to try them one afternoon and were not disappointed. Breasted chicken and bloodies? Yes! They have chicken specials and drink specials. I kept Kelly on her toes ordering drinks and she not only kept up, but had an amazing attitude and connection with the regulars. I will definitely be back.Came back: not sure if I am more excited about my broasted "cheap" chicken or my loaded baked potato.

Just recently moved to Oshkosh and have been looking for our go to spot for fish fry. This place was not it. We ordered for pick up and our order was waiting for us when we got there which was great. We ordered the fisherman's feast which boast that it's enough for 2-3 appetites. We thought this would be perfect since it was two adults and a toddler. However what the portion sizes didn't seem to add up. On top of that everything was super oily. There wasn't much flavor either and the stuff was so soggy and cold, we needed up tossing most of it out. Pretty sure it had been made and sitting for awhile before being tossed into our to go box.

Omg a diamond in the rough. Sarah is the best, fastest waitress. Jen came over to talk to us and I just love this place. My new favorite place. The food was great and the atmosphere rocks. Love you guys!love Dawn, bob and Diane.

Fabulous service and food especially the fried chicken during the busiest time of year ... EAA Air Venture!!

Very good meal at Jeff's on rugby! Two of us got the stuffed shrimp. Nice and cheesy. It was also very crispy. We also had the broiled haddock. It was buttery and very yummy! Service was good. Very good time at Jeff's on Rugby!

Nothing I ordered was even slightly good. Great service, but will not go back.The potatoes tasted like they were boxed. The steak was just ok. The scallops were rubbery.