Ian's Pizza Milwaukee | Story Hill
Ian's Pizza Milwaukee | Story Hill
Buffalo chicken, Spinach Feta pesto
a salad in a bowl
interior
pizzas on display
Pick your pre-made slice
6-Pack Sticks
Buffalo chicken Mac and cheese quesadilla pizza
a view of a pizza counter
two pizzas on a table
Special slices of the week: chicken noodle soup and pork egg roll
Food preparation
The crust is so good.
food, pizza
12" GF pepperoni and parmesan
Mushroom and Cheese 20" Pizza
All The Veg without olives, added cheese
Pepperoni
16" pepperoni
pizza
Wasn't even careful not to touch the food.
food, pizza
Sticks with ranch and green chili ranch
food
Linda B.
Dec 2, 2024
Great! Fresh! Yummy! Pepperoni, sauce and crust ON POINT! I'd put it right up there with any woodfired pizza out there. Delivery was a little late, but it's so cold out. I was just happy to have delivery.
Read More
Candice R.
Jul 14, 2024
Service was great, they are very nice. The crunch of the pizza was really good. Better than expected. Sauce was good for the dipping. Now the bathroom peeee yewww!! The urine smell was so bad.The prices are to high for just a slice. $2.00 per slice would have been more appreciated and appropriate.
Read More
Kristianne B.
Mar 11, 2024
My favorite pizza please. First tried this in Madison and fell in love. Wish we had some back in Illinois for sure. Luckily on my way back from Madison, stopped by this place in Milwaukee. Service was pretty quick. I ended up ordering the Mac and cheese pizza and the mushroom penne. So delicious!!! I also ordered 3 breadsticks with the vodka marinara. Which the vodka marinara was to die for. I ended up ordering to go. But still the best pizza ever!
Read More
Laurel B.
Dec 1, 2024
Delicious pizza as usual. If they don't have one that you normally eat, they will make it just for you. I love the unlimited sodas.
Read More
Ankita S.
Jun 9, 2023
I got takeout from here for my friend who just had knee surgery and myself. I placed the ordered online earlier in the day and scheduled a pickup for 6:15pm the same day. The online ordering portal was very easy to use. I received a text at 6:14pm saying my order was ready, just as I was pulling up. There was still a few minutes wait to get my order, but it wasn't long and it gave me an opportunity to look at all the other pizza that's available by slice (bigger than my head) that were available.I ordered a small pepperoni and a small All the Veg without olives and extra cheeses. I don't usually check my orders before I leave, but I'm really glad I did here. The veg pizza had olives. The person helping me was very sweet and confirmed that my order was supposed to be without olives. They comped the price of that pizza and remade it for me, which honestly didn't take very long. As I waited, temptation got the better of me and I ended up getting a 6-pack of breadsticks with the marinara and the garlic butter.Despite the olive mishap, the experience was very pleasant! The pizza was delicious and the toppings were not sparse. The pizza had a nice crispy crust and the slice was perfectly chewy. The breadsticks were thick with a fluffy interior. I only wish they were more garlicky. The leftovers reheated nicely as well. They also have so many different flavors of pizza and I am definitely going to be back to try some of the others.
Read More
Tiffany T.
Oct 22, 2022
It doesn't get better than Ian's. This is a staple every time I go to Milwaukee.They are always coming up with new and innovative features such as crab Rangoon pizza. Tried their GF build your own for the first time tonight and my expectations were low because gluten free pizza, generally, is usually just edible...but wow! I almost ate the whole 12" in one sitting. I made my husband that enjoys all the gluten try it and he could not tell that it was GF and if you've ever had GF pizza, you always know. The texture is never quite right. Anyways, it was awesome and can't wait to order again.Their regular crust pizza is always spot on and never disappointing.They have coke products - Cherry coke on fountain & the best ranch. (Green chili ranch is amazing too.)LOVE Ian's so much.
Read More
Victor H.
Feb 28, 2022
(From September 2021)I remember strolling in here on a late Sunday night after bar hopping. Of course pizza is the way to go when you've had several drinks in you. You'll be greeted by the variety of slices in the display when you walk in. They have a variety of slices to choose from such as Mac and cheese pizza, bbq chicken, and baked penne.I went with the buffalo chicken and spinach feta pesto. The taste was alright, but the consistency of the slices weren't there with the middle areas of the pizza not as hot as the others. The slices are pre-made also so who knows how long they've been sitting out. The restaurant is clean so credit for that given how germaphobic we've become these days.The location is in their favor being near a bunch of bars and they're open late (I think). I may try them again when I'm back in MKE.
Read More
Ophelia M.
Nov 18, 2021
I just want to say a huge thank you to Ian's Pizza for existing in Story Hill!Not only do they have some of the best and most inventive slices in the Milwaukee area, having them right in my neighborhood is nothing short of magical. I've tried many of their slices and have been pleased with all. I love that they have such a wonderful selection of vegan pies! And they're all completely delicious.My recommendations? Their mac & cheese pizza (comfort food in a pizza slice), baked penne pizza, drunken ravioli, vegan veggie the bandit, and vegan veggie cheesesteak.Of course, if you're looking for a simple slice of cheese or pepperoni--they have that too.Get to it! #thankyouthursday2021
Read More
Steven T.
Feb 2, 2020
I finally got over try this place and check them out because sometimes I just want a slice of pizza and not a whole pizza. The place was empty on a Sunday afternoon, the super bowl probably had everything to do with that. The place is nice and fresh looking with red walls and exposed brick.This place doesn't make your slice fresh like the place on the south side and all the pizzas are pre made and heated to order. I ordered the sausage slice which was ready in minutes. The menu also has some beer and salads I noticed.The sausage pizza is horrible looking with super thin sausage slices like pepperoni that curl up from cooking. The crust was thin just like the toppings and cheese that has a slight crisp on the bottom. This pizza slice didn't really satisfy me for a cheese and sausage pizza because because the toppings are thin, it's not meaty or cheesy like a good pizza. If I was blind folded and feed this pizza I would have said it's one of the better frozen brands.I would much rather go to one of those two pizza chains that have the unlimited toppings and cook your pizza to order if I'm going to do fast food pizza.
Read More
Joanna T.
Sep 7, 2019
A 2.5 from me. This new Ian's is in a great location - right near all the Bluemound Brewers bars and pretty close to Wick field. If you know Ian's you know the deal - strong vegetarian & vegan options, "crazy" slices and late hours. We stopped for lunch and there were probably 8-9 pizza choices. They aren't labeled at all so you'll have to guess or ask. We kept it classic with a sausage slice and a sausage/pep slice for the man. Two good sized slices and 2 fountain drinks - $13. Pretty cheap!IMO you get what you pay for. Even though they just opened, their soda machine ice was broken so our drinks were lukewarm. My slice was just "ok" - I really did like the perfectly crisp crust but there were just 4 skimpy sausage bits on my rather large slice. I think I'd like Ian's a lot more if I were drunk, enjoyed mac and cheese on a pizza or were a vegetarian. (Honestly, they do have great choices for veg/vegans). I'm sure I'll probably eat a drunken slice after a Brewer game someday but I wouldn't rush back. Also, if you leave nearby (Story Hill, the Heights, East Tosa) they do deliver.
Read More
