Honeypie Cafe

ADORABLE place with homey vibes in the seating and bar areas. AMAZING food and drinks with great service. Don't leave without a slice of pie!Found this place on yelp based on reviews while we're visiting the area and wanted to drive through Bayview. Couldn't be happier with the pick! Walking in you immediately get the cute diner/cafe vibes with the pie case and artwork you're met with. We went around 2pm and we immediately got a seat and great service. I ordered the burger after a server recommendation and it was delicious. It was cooked perfectly and the toppings all melded together amazingly. We also ordered the corn muffins which had a hint of sweetness and were perfectly warm. Others ordered the Caesar salad, breakfast casserole, and the hopple popple scramble. Rave reviews for those as well. You get your moneys worth as well, there is LOTS of food in each option. We also got slices of the Chocolate Cream Pie and Salted Caramel Pie, so glad we did. The Chocolate was perfectly rich with great whipped cream. The salted caramel was one of the best cream pies i've ever had. The chocolate crust and whipped cream tied it together perfectly with almost a cheesecake vibe. SO YUMMY! I am a huge ranch person and after asking the server, he said the ranch was wonderful. I like it however, not my favorite ever. It had a strong dill flavor which was yummy but too much mayo flavor for my liking.

Honeypie was the perfect place to spend the coldest day of the year. The retro decor made it feel homey and cozy. While we waited just 10 minutes for a table--as Honeypie doesn't take reservations--I ogled the needle-punch and embroidery-style artworks on the wallpapered walls, and checked out some of the merch and pie making gear you could purchase and take home. (If you're looking for a fluted pie plate from a local business, hit up Honeypie!) Once we were seated, our server was very attentive as we ordered an entree and a slice of pie to finish. If you're smart, you'll ask for the pie menu at the same time as the entrees so you know what kind of pie you need to save room for. They've got 10(ish) types of pie to choose from, so if you're ever craving a slice, you know where to go!

Honeypie offers an incredible selection of pies, and the coconut key lime is a personal favorite--absolutely delicious!I've visited for brunch a few times, and while the food is good, I personally find the pricing a bit steep. For example, the ham croissant (which does not include a side) was $16.50, the Cobb salad was $18.50, and a small fruit bowl was $9. I'm happy to pay for quality food, but these prices felt a bit excessive.Additionally, the seating situation can be challenging during busy times. Today, we had the option to sit at the counter (which has stools with no backs) or at the very small tables placed in the center walkway between the booths. We opted for a table, thinking it would be more comfortable, but the location made for a crowded and chaotic dining experience, with servers frequently bumping into each other. It might be worth reconsidering the layout to enhance the overall ambiance and guest comfort.That said, the pies alone make Honeypie worth a visit!

Wow I have not been here since they moved to a new space and apparently that is already 5 years ago now! The new space is open and spacious and has a great vibe. The bar is open and bright. Honestly would've sat there if I didn't go with my family. I ordered my usual - pork fries and pie. The pork fries hit the spot as usual although they now serve it in a bowl where it used to be on a plate. The is impacts the longevity of the fries crispyness. Still just as dense and heavy and plenty for a meal on its own. I also has the breakfast casserole with my nephew and wow that was flavorful and heavy too. Be prepared to take food home here! The gravy in the casserole was delicious and the biscuit was not dry. Wish the ratio was a bit less biscuit though. Pies are always good no specific notes except get yourself a slice.

Three of us had brunch at this restaurant on New Year's Day. The interior was decorated cheerfully, very fitting to the mood of the day. The place was full when we arrived, but there were no other customers waiting, although several other groups arrived shortly after. Our wait for the seats was probably less than 10 minutes; after we placed our order, however, it took more than half an hour for our food to arrive, indicating that the kitchen was quite overwhelmed that day.I ordered the Breakfast Burrito, and my companions ordered the Pesto Chicken Salad Sandwich and the Cobb Salad, respectively. We all liked the food we ordered. The Breakfast Burrito was the best I'd had in MKE, and I would rank it slightly below the best breakfast burrito I had in a NYC restaurant a few months earlier. The toasted croissant that came with the Pesto Chicken Salad Sandwich, which I also tasted, was very good - buttery, soft and almost crumbly. I would consider Honeypie one of the best breakfast and brunch restaurants in MKE.

Honey Pie in Bay View is everything you want in a neighborhood spot--a welcoming, cozy space with a retro vibe. From the moment we walked in, the friendly staff and inviting atmosphere stood out.The Lavender Sparkle mocktail was a refreshing start. They had a nice selection of mocktails and NA beers. It's hard to decide which entree was better - the Hopple Popple Skillet with its incredible aroma and steaming-hot deliciousness, or the Pesto Chicken Salad Croissant - perfectly flaky and so flavorful.And then there's the pie. Wow. We tried the Key Lime Pie and Cherry Pie--took them home to savor later. The key lime was perfect, and the cherry, warmed up and paired with some cinnamon ice cream, was next level.Can't wait to go back again!

I've visited Honeypie Cafe three or four times for brunch now and it has never disappointed! It's a cozy restaurant with some really delicious items on the menu. The French toast is a winner. It's fluffy and flavorful and the fresh berries are the perfect addition. The yogurt parfait is good too, and the house-made granola is absolutely incredible. However, I do think the honey drizzle is a little excessive -- it makes the dish just a tad too sweet. If you're looking for something savory, whatever you do you MUST order a dish that comes with the breakfast potatoes. Truly the best I've ever had. They're luscious on the inside with a good bit of crispness on the outside and packed with flavor. And don't forget to grab a slice of pie on your way out! The cookies and cream is especially yummy. The servers are always friendly and the food comes out quickly, but even when it's busy, I never feel rushed. When the weather is nice, try to grab a seat on the patio. It's a hidden gem with plenty of shade. For brunch, you can expect to pay somewhere around $40 before tip for two beverages and two entrees. It's well worth the price, in my opinion.

We went to Honeypie Café on a Saturday night and had no issue getting a table. Our waitress was great and so friendly! We were a little bummed right in the beginning because my mom tried to order the Airline Chicken but they were all out for the night. Then turns out my dad got the last Chicken and Biscuit pie of the night (this was at 6:30pm and they are opened until 9).The grilled cheese was great. Super buttery and great cheese to bread ratio. Dipping in the tomato soup was a must! The fries were so nicely seasoned, but sadly they were cold. If they were fresh out of the fryer it would have been a top tier grilled cheese meal. I had a bite of David's burger and it was delicious but messy. I also had a bite of my dad's chicken and biscuit pie (also great, really enjoyed the biscuits).Now the biggest debate of the night... were the pie's sweet enough!? My dad and I did not think the mud pie or pumpkin cream pie were sweet enough at all. Crazy enough, the coconut key lime was my favorite. I had high hopes for the pies and unfortunately was let down by them. However, David and my mom both felt the pies were sweet enough and they really enjoyed them.Overall we really enjoyed our time at Honeypie cafe. The ambiance was nice and staff were all very friendly. Check it out if you are in the area.

Who says you can't have pie for breakfast? You absolutely can, as much as some might disagree. I had an amazing start to my day at Honeypie Cafe! Before we allowed myself to get lost on not one, but two pieces of pie, we chowed down on the Breakfast Casserole. This is a party in a bowl, filled with biscuit, roasted potatoes, the most delicious house made sausage gravy I've ever had, white cheddar, and chunks of bacon all enveloped in a sunny side egg. It was hard to get a good picture, but the video says it all in 8 seconds. This dish was indulgent. Once that was well polished off, we treated ourselves to slices of Strawberry Rhubarb and Lemon Icebox pie to try a fruit and cream. Both were EXCELLENT. The Strawberry Rhubarb was wonderfully sweet and tart and yummy. The Lemon Icebox was topped with real whipped cream and based on a crumbly graham crust. It was refreshing. We hardly left a crumb behind of either. The service was excellent! Our server checked on us periodically and always made sure our coffee cups stayed filled. I highly recommend this place! It can get busy so I suggest you get there early!

The food was amazing! The French dip if it tasted this good can't imagine how wonderful the French onion soup will taste! Will try the French onion soup next time. Roast beef in the French dip was well seasoned and delicious!The honey pie burger I got without the egg with tomatoes and was so mouth watering it didn't last long on my plate! Homemade French fries were awesome but what stole the show was the homemade pickles that I could have eaten a big plate of them they were so tasteful!! Not to strong not to weak they were perfect and balanced! The waitress earned every ounce of the tip we gave her! Her attention to detail and the fact that we thought she read our minds to get us drinks without asking at the perfect time was one of the best experiences I have had! She made me feel special along with my GF! The atmosphere was on the down low and totally mellow and still added a bright notes to the meal! Seating was quite well with even sitting at the counter! The only longer issue we had was $9 dollars for a slice of pie that needs some help! Still tasted ok but to bring it up to the meal standards needs some fine tuning! The filling didn't have lots of flavor! But overall we shall make this place one of our favorite places to eat in the bayview area!