Baked potato soup
Buffalo flatbread- Haddock sweet potato
Entrance from the parking lot.
the front of a restaurant
The Library Dining Room
a man standing on the stairs of a restaurant
a neon sign for the good times
A beef stick will be all you get in your bloody here.
interior
drink
Lobster bisque soup
interior
The sign from the street
Crispy chicken sandwich
Pumpkin cheesecake
Cookie Skillet
Lasagna
Potato skins
drink
Queso Dip with Beef Added
California Wrap
Gluten free menu
interior
Megan K.
Nov 1, 2024
Food was better than expected, service was nice prompt, being a full house they did well. Ambiance is amazing old fashion- did not expect the inside to be so full of character. Mia our server was wonderful!!
Read More
Kylie W.
Mar 21, 2024
THE GOOD COMPANY WAS IN FACT NOT GOOD! We came in a group of 31 so we knew what we were getting into. We had two servers for our two tables, one was absolutely fantastic she had a smile on her face the whole time but the other one was either having an off day or is bad at her job. She forgot about one of our meals and the cook was not happy. The food was mid... personally I had the French Dip which was one of their specialties (not done right). Some others in the group enjoyed their steaks and wraps. We were told we couldn't do separate checks by the one waitress but the other was not on the same page because she was ready to split for our table. One positive to add... the desserts were AMAZING!
Read More
Jim B.
Aug 31, 2024
This is a local place that's been in business for a long time. The building is huge. We sat in the French Quarter themed area. The ceilings were very high, and sound echoed some. But with so much space, they've kept the tables spread out, and though we were seated near two groups of 10-12, the noise level was ok. Service was good, starting with a very engaging and friendly hostess. Our server seemed very new, but did well. The food was really good pub grub. I had a bacon cheeseburger with fries and my wife had French onion soup and a baked potato. All was very good. The kitchen was doing very well, the two large groups ordered before us, but our orders came quickly. The group's food all came out together, and looked great. We'll be back to work through some more of the menu.
Read More
Samuel D.
Dec 29, 2023
I ordered the rings and chicken. Both the ribs and chicken were great. The chicken was perfectly moist yet dry wile the ribs flavors were complemented greatly by the sauce.The service was great and friendly with the waitress checking on us every so often.The ambiance was relaxed with a calming feel.
Read More
Ally S.
Apr 29, 2022
Highlights/Lowlights1. Friendly Service2. Average Food3. Good/Basic Menu with a Lot of Options Stopped in at Good Company on a Sunday afternoon for lunch. We did not have a reservation but there were plenty of tables available for seating. Ambiance is cozy and a little dated which makes it charming. The space is really big with several dining rooms, a big bar area, and an events room.Our server was friendly and pretty quick to get our order in and get us drinks. The menu is big with a good selection of soups, sandwiches, salads, appetizers and entrees. This is a good menu for picky eaters as there are a lot of very basic pasta/sandwich/entree options. We ordered wine first. The wine list is very average/grocery store wine varieties. My friend and I split the queso dip and added beef. The appetizer was average. Queso was pretty good, chips just tasted like your standard grocery store variety. I had the California Chicken Salad for lunch. Again, this item was very average. You could definitely tell the chicken was pre-cooked/frozen as it had that slightly rubbery texture but not inedible. Overall, I enjoyed my time here and would probably visit again as you don't need a reservation and it's centrally located. The food, unfortunately, is not the star of the show here.
Read More
Jack G.
Sep 3, 2020
Great ambiance with quirky decor and a maze of rooms add to the dining experience. The food was good but unremarkable (above average pub fare). My wrap was very good, but I could not taste the avocado that was listed in the menu description. The French Dip was tasty. The French Fries could use improvement.My Brandy Old Fashioned was well made (our pleasant server politely steered me away from the cocktails that were premixed) - I ordered a second one!Good service and reasonable prices.Good Company is also a great wedding venue (they have separate rooms to accommodate wedding parties). I observed a wedding ceremony during one visit here.
Read More
Paul R.
Jan 22, 2025
Good food but you could possibly die of thirst. Ordered on with at able of six others on a early Friday evening. I just had a tap water as my beverage. After being just about through with my entrée the server asked me if I wanted a refill, no, that's wrong, I had to ask her. After about 10 minutes the water never came, we paid the bill and left. The takeaway from all of this? Maybe bring a couple of bottled waters for yourself if you go there.
Read More
Barb W.
Jan 15, 2025
Great food and atmosphere. The building and architecture is just beautiful. Convenient location.
Read More
Brett C.
Nov 18, 2024
Went to good company in Appleton Saturday night for dinner with a group of six. Bar drinks were great, good bartender. They had free popcorn. When we went to eat there seem to be confusion and who was waiting our table. I ordered turkey pesto sandwich with avocados. And sweet potato fries. Waitress came back and I was told they were out of sweet potato fries. When the sandwich came, I opened it up after the first two bites and there was very little avocado in it and I couldn't even taste the pesto mayonnaise that was supposed to be on it. So kind of disappointed. on the other hand, two of our group had a French dip sandwich, and said it was the best they ever had. Another person in the group ordered salmon and they thought it was dry. So kind of a mixed bag we have been there a number of times and this was the first time some have had issues with, the food
Read More
Tim H.
Apr 25, 2024
Walking up the wood rampWhere the concrete and wood Butt up the wood is decaying And could break and a person Could fall thru and get hurt ( (very unsafeThe food is goodHope this gets replaced
Read More
Rated: 3.3 (26 reviews)
Sports Bars, American, Venues & Event Spaces