Glass Nickel Pizza

First time customer and wow, love this pizza! The crust is my favorite type of crust - not too thin, not too thick. Husband and I opted to try the deluxe and the thai pie pizzas - we got the 10" and it was perfect so we could have leftovers the following day. I would recommend both pizzas and take out :) timely and very delicious!

Ordered delivery Build Your Own pizza. Fantastic and fast delivery! Courteous and professional driver. Pizza arrived hot and delicious. Highly recommend!

Decently priced and good pizza. You can order classic pizzas to non traditional pies. They are pretty quick as well.

Shout out to delivery driver Nate. I put in the wrong address for the delivery. He called to say no one was home. At that point I realized my mistake and called him back with the correct address. On a very busy night for him, he then delivered the pizza to the correct address. I apologized for my mistake and he was patient with me and kind, in spite of the additional time and work for him. The family I sent the pizza to said it was delicious and they devoured it!

Eh Lots of options but just eh Pizza sauce is weird to me and Buffalo sauce I was told by a coworker it tasted like franks red hot (BLEH)

Have been here several times now, staff is always friendly, and welcoming. They often have great specials and deals. The pizza has always been very tasty and high quality. I've done carry out and dine in. The pizza is always ready quickly, and the dining area is always clean. Truly a hidden gem.

They have not always been great with timing but did good this time. We ordered 2 14" 2- topping pizzas for carryout and it was ready when we picked it up. They were warm and tasty!!We tried pepperoni with black olives and sausage with Boar's Head pepperoni. They have some deals on their website and a few daily specials to look out for.

Never had a bad experience with Glass Nickel! I have enjoyed their food via delivery, carry-out, and dine-in in their small lobby area. Always hits the spot! Their pizza is made well. It seems to be good quality and that shows in the taste. It is definitely the best delivery pizza in the area. They have even more than pizza too! I love their calzones. They are huge, reasonably priced, and delicious. You get to choose your own fillings, and their ricotta & house cheese blend make the calzone delicious. Their sauce is fresh and tasty, too! Lots of choices, so you'll find something for everyone! A bit pricey compared to other delivery pizza options, but like I said, their quality is obviously better so I guess you get what you pay for.

Always great service and food. One of my favorite pizza places in Wisconsin.

What is advertised on their app is NOT what you get! Poor quality food, don't waste your money. It's sad, used to be good.