Geno Nottolini's Pizza

This is the second time I've ordered delivery and this time is a major disappointment. The first time we got lasagna and chicken parmesan and it was great. Big serving, plenty of sauce and it was delicious. This time we got fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp, a chicken parmesan and an order of breaded mushrooms. The fettuccine was watery and only came with 6 shrimp for an additional $3.75. The chicken parm was dry and what sauce they did add was watery. The mushrooms were cold and soggy, they didn't even have dipping sauce. Don't think I'll spend my money here again.

I love the food, but the service in the restaurant sucks. They might have 3 or 4 workers in there (family), and the place is always empty but the tables are never cleared, you have to get up, and walk over to them for another drink, or yell to get their attention because they are always playing on their phones or computers. The owner seems like a good guy, but the bartenders need to care more, its no surprise its always dead in there

The food was absolutely freezer burnt they ask how everything was we told.them they did nothing about it. Tasted like cardboard. Garlic cheese bread was only two small slices not even enough to to serve 2. The combo appetizers were only for onion rings 6 verry small breaded mushrooms 3 mozzarella sticks which also were freezer burnt. Pizza was burnt. Never again!

We were waiting for about an hour so I asked how much longer it would take. They said it would take another 10-15 minutes. Bullshit. It shouldnt tske that longer for 20 chicken wings. I could of drive to Buffalo Wild wings and come back and my good wouldn't even be ready yet.

It's pretty good...sometimes. I have found their pizza is really hit or miss. Some times it's great, wonderful homemade tasting crust, hot, good toppings. Other times it is a hot mess. Would totally order all the time if they were consistent in their good pizzas, as it's the only one my husband and I can agree on. But not sure we're gonna order any time soon as it's too inconsistent, and you don't know what you're going to get.

Food was bad, and their delivery guy was racist, when i called and complained they stopped taking our orders & hung up on our call. 0/10 don't recommend.

Wanted some New York style pizza and Faye's was closed so we found this place and ordered. We got a New York style "basic cheese" pizza, 16", and mozzarella sticks.The mozzarella sticks were okay. Kind of oddly sized; one was an inch and another was 3-4 inches. But tasted okay. The marinara sauce was pretty good.The pizza... *sigh* ... someone please get these guys a ticket to NYC to taste the real thing because it seems like they got a description from Google and just made it without a recipe. Hell, just go to Faye's; they have the closest I've seen in Sheboygan.As a New Yorker, it's outrageous.A real New York style pizza is juicy, with very flavorful sauce and lots of it, and gooey, oily cheese all over. It fills your mouth with euthoria and slides down your throat effortlessly.This, on the other hand, was the driest pizza I have ever encountered. I didn't even know it was possible to make pizza dry, but these guys did it! Congratulations! I had to have a cup of olive oil on the side to chase this pizza down just so it wouldn't activate my gag reflex. It was mostly dough, and dry dough at that; very little flavorless sauce, and an adequate amount of cheese. The cheese was not oily, as if it was a store-bought Tombstone pizza or something.OH! But wait! They sprinkled some italian herb seasoning on top! That's gonna make everything better, right? Both the guy on the phone and the delivery driver were nice and courteous. So they've got that going for them, I guess.

The delivery time was fast, which was nice and the delivery guy was very friendly! The pizza (pepperoni and olive) was decent. The Alfredo though...don't get it!!! It was off to a good start because it smelled pretty good and had a lot of sauce, but it had no seasoning and was very bland :( Overall my husband and I were a little disappointed. Especially because they advertise as being famous authentic Chicago style pizza. We will not order from here again.

Be warned!~! Horrible food and even worse service. They were the only place open on a Monday so I thought I would try. I called back to complain and the employee was a jerk. Will never order from them again.

Poor service all around. I was told they had something available only to have them call me back 30 minutes later to tell me that they did not have it and that they would send cash with the driver instead of crediting my card. The person that took my order said that it would be delivered within the hour of me placing the order. 1 1/2 hours later the rest of my order showed up and it was all cold to the point that I needed to heat all of it before my family and I could eat. Not only was it cold and late, I ordered New York style crust and had thin crust delivered. The icing on the cake was the cash that was refunded to me was only 75% of what it should have been. I guess I didn't expect them to be crooks on top everything else. Don't waste your money here