Flat Iron Tap

My husband and I recently stopped by after seeing some great reviews on Yelp. The place has a small and cozy vibe with a really cool dark aesthetic. Even on a chilly Saturday in January, it was buzzing with people! We did have to wait about 25 minutes for a table, but that was totally fine with us (though I can only imagine how busy it gets during peak season!).Once we were seated, we kicked things off with two spotted cows and some delicious cheese curds to get our taste buds going--definitely a 10/10! My husband chose the Plane Jane, while I went for the Kurt-Astrophe. Let me tell you, the burgers are hand-packed and bursting with flavor, so be ready for some extra napkins because they are juicy and so-delicious! We really enjoyed our experience and can't wait to come back for another amazing burger.

This place is fun and this drink is amazing it's called Blueberry Muffin Tini The food is good and the service is great It's a busy place so make your reservations and come in for a good time!!!

Survived tornadoes here.In town for a work conference on a spring weeknight, this was the best of the choices open at what seemed like a reasonable hour of 7-8pm! We sat at a two top table. The back door was open a few feet behind me. It didn't take long before tornado sirens were going off. I said to my friend as I kept noticing the service staff heading downstairs, "There are stairs to a basement right behind you and I'm not going out in this to find our hotel."So in the spirit of spending time, and what I order any time I see it on a menu (because I also buy it at the grocery and make it at home), is the Bavarian pretzel from Milwaukee Pretzel Company. It was prepared properly, crispy and salty on the outside with a soft interior.Flat Iron Tap bills itself as having Lake Geneva's best gourmet burgers. This is a scratch kitchen so be prepared for big, beefy, juicy burgers. All the types and toppings available.Service was prompt and friendly. I do wonder if we would have been asked to exit if we had not exited. Other customers weren't really leaving either as closing time approached. Flat Iron Tap stands out in my memory in Lake Geneva as much for riding out the storms that had been touching down around Lake Geneva as we were there as for its food. I would return here in the future to have another pretzel and burger in its casual, low key environment.

Flat Iron Tap is one of our favorite spots in town. We love the fact that they don't use seed oils and that they have healthy options on the menu.I HIGHLY recommend their cauliflower bites as an appetizer! Just a heads up this place fills up fast on the weekends! This restaurant has a nice vibe and we've always had nice servers.

Service was great!! Plain Jane Burger was mediocre. Big patty. Very dry. Loved the pickles. Greens fresh.Fries were good.

The food and service was fantastic. Great small bar feel. Beer choices are many! Says I need more characters.

This place was PACKED on a Friday night. We put our name in and had to wait about 45 minutes, but it was worth it!! It was all decked out for Halloween, which was a very fun atmosphere. 10/10 recommend trying the burgers (locally sourced), the cheese curds (a lot of cheese but so light and fluffy), and the Brussels sprouts appetizer. All were wonderful! It is rare to find a "farm to table" bar, but here we are! It's a small space and a hot spot in town, but the crowds prove how great it was. Come for good food and a lively bar ambiance!

The cheese curds here are hands down the cheesiest! We're talking cheese pull every time you dip a curd in sauce. This small spot feels like a local hang. Seating is limited, so expect a wait during busy hours. While it offers classic bar food, which I'll be the first to admit isn't my usual go-to, the prices were surprisingly steep. With that being said, I did find the atmosphere to be unique (not touristy), service was solid, and the cheese curds are heavenly.

The food was delicious. There were plenty of people working that made the service great. Kind of a little hole in the wall place that makes it feel like a really neat place! Highly recommend!

Fantastic casual burger and bar joint in Lake Geneva! Loved the jazz duo! - Don't skip the appetizers! Some of the best softest cheese curds I've ever had especially with their house made ranch! - Brussels sprouts were perfectly crispy with thick cut bacon and tasty Korean sauce- hefty burgers with fun toppings. Such soft fresh bread! Note that the french fries are seasoned and cumin is a heavy flavor. One person in our group wasn't a fan and the server swapped out plain french fries for no charge.Our server was amazing! She brought her appetizers out super quickly because she realized how hungry our group was. She had great recommendations & we never felt rushed. Def worth the wait for a table!