Faye's Pizza

Perfect place for great pizza. High quality pie. Much better than any of the chain options.

This is our family's go to take out spot in Sheboygan. The pizza is a classic crispy cracker crust, the sauce is a little sweet for my taste, but otherwise it's great! Doesn't take too long for pickup! The inside is nice and cozy feeling, but I have yet to eat inside! Solid choice

Pizza is personal and it depends on what style you like. This was good for a thin crusted pizza, but not great, imo. Pros: It was open, isn't a chain, has good beer and pizza, cute ambiance, friendly people, and the pizza had a good sauce, good cheese, wasn't oily, had a thin crust, and the aroma from outside smells just like a NY pizzeria, and so does the taste!Con's: While thin and supposedly hand tossed, the crust certainly isn't really New York style. It is missing the chewy (like good bread)) crust around the outer edge of the pie, and it didn't seem quite baked through, although there was a crisp to the bottom. Instead of slicing into triangles with each slice cut from outer edge to the center, they cut it into little squares which means the entire center of the pizza is without edge crust. (In NY, we simply fold the large slices in half and the super thin crust has a slight crisp on the bottom, bends not cracks when you fold it, and the outer thick edge of every slice is a lovely, chewy "grip". Salad was fine. Nothing special, packaged dressing. If I really want pizza next time visiting Sheboygan, I might go again, but I'd order a smaller pizza (or two if we needed that much pizza rather than the very big pie, to assure each slice has a crust around the edge.

Great pizza, and the sausage potato soup is fantastic.........plus the take and bake is excellent. ...........................

Delivered to blue Harbor resort. Delivery person was very friendly. Food was fantastic. Would definitely recommend this place.

Everything was great from the service to the food and pricing was low. On a drive home to De Pere from Milwaukee on a Friday night we were craving classic family style pizza and this hit the spot. We enjoyed a deluxe pizza and I had an amazing sausage & potato soup. Our kids loved the cheesy garlic bread (it was as an 80s baby would want it to be from their childhood) and cheese pizza because they're toddlers. Service was prompt and fast.

Delivery driver trying to charge for a pizza that has already been paid for . Pretty shady practice

Out of towners, just passing through... we stopped here and we're so happy we did! Delicious pizza, awesome potato sausage soup (a homemade recipe I was told) and great service. Cody was authentically kind to each customer in the place, and very warm and welcoming to us. Highly recommend; love the family atmosphere. If we're ever back this way, we wouldn't hesitate to go back again and again. Yay for local family owned businesses!!

This is our favorite pizza, we have to get it every time we're in town. Their extra cheese is very cheesy! Be warned! It is delicious, and they don't skimp on the

The best thin crust pizza around! Fresh, quality ingredients along with a friendly staff makes Faye's a longtime Sheboygan landmark!